Addendum to the HARP WhiteBook

In this Addendum to the HARP WhiteBook, gross contradictions are discussed between (i) the 2006 HARP Status Report to the SPSC, (ii) the HARP Technical Paper, (iii) the `Rebuttal' of our `Comments' on the HARP Technical Paper, and (iv) the IEEE Paper on the RPC performance, all of which we...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Ammosov, V, Boyko, I, Chelkov, G, Dedovitch, D, Dydak, F, Elagin, A, Gostkin, M, Guskov, A, Koreshev, V, Krumshtein, Z, Nefedov, Y, Nikolaev, K, Wotschack, J, Zhemchugov, A
Lenguaje:eng
Publicado: 2006
Materias:
Detectors and Experimental Techniques
Acceso en línea:http://cds.cern.ch/record/1143069
_version_ 1780915629478379520
author Ammosov, V
Boyko, I
Chelkov, G
Dedovitch, D
Dydak, F
Elagin, A
Gostkin, M
Guskov, A
Koreshev, V
Krumshtein, Z
Nefedov, Y
Nikolaev, K
Wotschack, J
Zhemchugov, A
author_facet Ammosov, V
Boyko, I
Chelkov, G
Dedovitch, D
Dydak, F
Elagin, A
Gostkin, M
Guskov, A
Koreshev, V
Krumshtein, Z
Nefedov, Y
Nikolaev, K
Wotschack, J
Zhemchugov, A
author_sort Ammosov, V
collection CERN
description In this Addendum to the HARP WhiteBook, gross contradictions are discussed between (i) the 2006 HARP Status Report to the SPSC, (ii) the HARP Technical Paper, (iii) the `Rebuttal' of our `Comments' on the HARP Technical Paper, and (iv) the IEEE Paper on the RPC performance, all of which were published within three months only. It is shown that the published TPC pT resolution of ~30% at pT=1 GeV/c, the published intrinsic RPC time resolution of ~140 ps, and the published overall time resolution of 305 ps for pion tracks cannot co-exist, and thus cannot be part of a coherent physics analysis.
id cern-1143069
institution Organización Europea para la Investigación Nuclear
language eng
publishDate 2006
record_format invenio
spelling cern-11430692019-09-30T06:29:59Zhttp://cds.cern.ch/record/1143069engAmmosov, VBoyko, IChelkov, GDedovitch, DDydak, FElagin, AGostkin, MGuskov, AKoreshev, VKrumshtein, ZNefedov, YNikolaev, KWotschack, JZhemchugov, AAddendum to the HARP WhiteBookDetectors and Experimental TechniquesIn this Addendum to the HARP WhiteBook, gross contradictions are discussed between (i) the 2006 HARP Status Report to the SPSC, (ii) the HARP Technical Paper, (iii) the `Rebuttal' of our `Comments' on the HARP Technical Paper, and (iv) the IEEE Paper on the RPC performance, all of which were published within three months only. It is shown that the published TPC pT resolution of ~30% at pT=1 GeV/c, the published intrinsic RPC time resolution of ~140 ps, and the published overall time resolution of 305 ps for pion tracks cannot co-exist, and thus cannot be part of a coherent physics analysis.CERN-HARP-CDP-2006-007HARP Memo 06-105oai:cds.cern.ch:11430692006-10-22
spellingShingle Detectors and Experimental Techniques
Ammosov, V
Boyko, I
Chelkov, G
Dedovitch, D
Dydak, F
Elagin, A
Gostkin, M
Guskov, A
Koreshev, V
Krumshtein, Z
Nefedov, Y
Nikolaev, K
Wotschack, J
Zhemchugov, A
Addendum to the HARP WhiteBook
title Addendum to the HARP WhiteBook
title_full Addendum to the HARP WhiteBook
title_fullStr Addendum to the HARP WhiteBook
title_full_unstemmed Addendum to the HARP WhiteBook
title_short Addendum to the HARP WhiteBook
title_sort addendum to the harp whitebook
topic Detectors and Experimental Techniques
url http://cds.cern.ch/record/1143069
work_keys_str_mv AT ammosovv addendumtotheharpwhitebook
AT boykoi addendumtotheharpwhitebook
AT chelkovg addendumtotheharpwhitebook
AT dedovitchd addendumtotheharpwhitebook
AT dydakf addendumtotheharpwhitebook
AT elagina addendumtotheharpwhitebook
AT gostkinm addendumtotheharpwhitebook
AT guskova addendumtotheharpwhitebook
AT koreshevv addendumtotheharpwhitebook
AT krumshteinz addendumtotheharpwhitebook
AT nefedovy addendumtotheharpwhitebook
AT nikolaevk addendumtotheharpwhitebook
AT wotschackj addendumtotheharpwhitebook
AT zhemchugova addendumtotheharpwhitebook

Ejemplares similares