Comment on "The third Zemach moment of the proton", by Cloet and Miller

Cloet and Miller, in arXiv:1008.4345, state that "existing data rule out a value of the third Zemach moment large enough to explain the current puzzle with the proton charge radius determined from the Lamb shift in muonic Hydrogen. This is in contrast with the recent claim of De R\'ujula [...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autor principal: De Rújula, A
Lenguaje:eng
Publicado: 2010
Materias:
Particle Physics - Phenomenology
Acceso en línea:http://cds.cern.ch/record/1287527
_version_ 1780920615445725184
author De Rújula, A
author_facet De Rújula, A
author_sort De Rújula, A
collection CERN
description Cloet and Miller, in arXiv:1008.4345, state that "existing data rule out a value of the third Zemach moment large enough to explain the current puzzle with the proton charge radius determined from the Lamb shift in muonic Hydrogen. This is in contrast with the recent claim of De R\'ujula [arXiv:1008.3861]". To be more precise: it is not. It is, however, contrary to what they claim that I claim. Cloet and Miller have simply misinterpreted my claims.
id cern-1287527
institution Organización Europea para la Investigación Nuclear
language eng
publishDate 2010
record_format invenio
spelling cern-12875272019-09-30T06:29:59Zhttp://cds.cern.ch/record/1287527engDe Rújula, AComment on "The third Zemach moment of the proton", by Cloet and MillerParticle Physics - PhenomenologyCloet and Miller, in arXiv:1008.4345, state that "existing data rule out a value of the third Zemach moment large enough to explain the current puzzle with the proton charge radius determined from the Lamb shift in muonic Hydrogen. This is in contrast with the recent claim of De R\'ujula [arXiv:1008.3861]". To be more precise: it is not. It is, however, contrary to what they claim that I claim. Cloet and Miller have simply misinterpreted my claims.arXiv:1008.4546CERN-PH-TH-2010-202-aoai:cds.cern.ch:12875272010-08-27
spellingShingle Particle Physics - Phenomenology
De Rújula, A
Comment on "The third Zemach moment of the proton", by Cloet and Miller
title Comment on "The third Zemach moment of the proton", by Cloet and Miller
title_full Comment on "The third Zemach moment of the proton", by Cloet and Miller
title_fullStr Comment on "The third Zemach moment of the proton", by Cloet and Miller
title_full_unstemmed Comment on "The third Zemach moment of the proton", by Cloet and Miller
title_short Comment on "The third Zemach moment of the proton", by Cloet and Miller
title_sort comment on "the third zemach moment of the proton", by cloet and miller
topic Particle Physics - Phenomenology
url http://cds.cern.ch/record/1287527
work_keys_str_mv AT derujulaa commentonthethirdzemachmomentoftheprotonbycloetandmiller

Ejemplares similares