Cargando…

Planck 2013 results. XXIII. Isotropy and Statistics of the CMB

The two fundamental assumptions of the standard cosmological model - that the initial fluctuations are statistically isotropic and Gaussian - are rigorously tested using maps of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropy from the Planck satellite. Deviations from isotropy have been found and d...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Ade, P.A.R., Aghanim, N., Armitage-Caplan, C., Arnaud, M., Ashdown, M., Atrio-Barandela, F., Aumont, J., Baccigalupi, C., Banday, A.J., Barreiro, R.B., Bartlett, J.G., Bartolo, N., Battaner, E., Battye, R., Benabed, K., Benoit, A., Benoit-Levy, A., Bernard, J.P., Bersanelli, M., Bielewicz, P., Bobin, J., Bock, J.J., Bonaldi, A., Bonavera, L., Bond, J.R., Borrill, J., Bouchet, F.R., Bridges, M., Bucher, M., Burigana, C., Butler, R.C., Cardoso, J.F., Catalano, A., Challinor, A., Chamballu, A., Chary, R.R., Chiang, L.Y., Chiang, H.C., Christensen, P.R., Church, S., Clements, D.L., Colombi, S., Colombo, L.P.L., Couchot, F., Coulais, A., Crill, B.P., Cruz, M., Curto, A., Cuttaia, F., Danese, L., Davies, R.D., Davis, R.J., de Bernardis, P., de Rosa, A., de Zotti, G., Delabrouille, J., Delouis, J.M., Desert, F.X., Diego, J.M., Dole, H., Donzelli, S., Dore, O., Douspis, M., Ducout, A., Dupac, X., Efstathiou, G., Elsner, F., Ensslin, T.A., Eriksen, H.K., Fantaye, Y., Fergusson, J., Finelli, F., Forni, O., Frailis, M., Franceschi, E., Frommert, M., Galeotta, S., Ganga, K., Giard, M., Giardino, G., Giraud-Heraud, Y., Gonzalez-Nuevo, J., Gorski, K.M., Gratton, S., Gregorio, A., Gruppuso, A., Hansen, M., Hansen, F.K., Hanson, D., Harrison, D., Helou, G., Henrot-Versille, S., Hernandez-Monteagudo, C., Herranz, D., Hildebrandt, S.R., Hivon, E., Hobson, M., Holmes, W.A., Hornstrup, A., Hovest, W., Huffenberger, K.M., Jaffe, T.R., Jaffe, A.H., Jones, W.C., Juvela, M., Keihanen, E., Keskitalo, R., Kim, J., Kisner, T.S., Knoche, J., Knox, L., Kunz, M., Kurki-Suonio, H., Lagache, G., Lahteenmaki, A., Lamarre, J.M., Lasenby, A., Laureijs, R.J., Lawrence, C.R., Leahy, J.P., Leonardi, R., Leroy, C., Lesgourgues, J., Liguori, M., Lilje, P.B., Linden-Vornle, M., Lopez-Caniego, M., Lubin, P.M., Macias-Perez, J.F., Maffei, B., Maino, D., Mandolesi, N., Mangilli, A., Marinucci, D., Maris, M., Marshall, D.J., Martin, P.G., Martinez-Gonzalez, E., Masi, S., Matarrese, S., Matthai, F., Mazzotta, P., McEwen, J.D., Meinhold, P.R., Melchiorri, A., Mendes, L., Mennella, A., Migliaccio, M., Mikkelsen, K., Mitra, S., Miville-Deschenes, M.A., Molinari, D., Moneti, A., Montier, L., Morgante, G., Mortlock, D., Moss, A., Munshi, D., Naselsky, P., Nati, F., Natoli, P., Netterfield, C.B., Norgaard-Nielsen, H.U., Noviello, F., Novikov, D., Novikov, I., Osborne, S., Oxborrow, C.A., Paci, F., Pagano, L., Pajot, F., Paoletti, D., Pasian, F., Patanchon, G., Peiris, H.V., Perdereau, O., Perotto, L., Perrotta, F., Piacentini, F., Piat, M., Pierpaoli, E., Pietrobon, D., Plaszczynski, S., Pointecouteau, E., Pogosyan, D., Polenta, G., Ponthieu, N., Popa, L., Poutanen, T., Pratt, G.W., Prezeau, G., Prunet, S., Puget, J.L., Rachen, J.P., Rath, C., Rebolo, R., Reinecke, M., Remazeilles, M., Renault, C., Renzi, A., Ricciardi, S., Riller, T., Ristorcelli, I., Rocha, G., Rosset, C., Rotti, A., Roudier, G., Rubino-Martin, J.A., Rusholme, B., Sandri, M., Santos, D., Savini, G., Scott, D., Seiffert, M.D., Shellard, E.P.S., Souradeep, T., Spencer, L.D., Starck, J.L., Stolyarov, V., Stompor, R., Sudiwala, R., Sureau, F., Sutter, P., Sutton, D., Suur-Uski, A.S., Sygnet, J.F., Tauber, J.A., Tavagnacco, D., Terenzi, L., Toffolatti, L., Tomasi, M., Tristram, M., Tucci, M., Tuovinen, J., Turler, M., Valenziano, L., Valiviita, J., Van Tent, B., Varis, J., Vielva, P., Villa, F., Vittorio, N., Wade, L.A., Wandelt, B.D., Wehus, I.K., White, M., Wilkinson, A., Yvon, D., Zacchei, A., Zonca, A.
Lenguaje:eng
Publicado: 2013
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201321534
http://cds.cern.ch/record/1530693
_version_ 1780929584031596544
author Ade, P.A.R.
Aghanim, N.
Armitage-Caplan, C.
Arnaud, M.
Ashdown, M.
Atrio-Barandela, F.
Aumont, J.
Baccigalupi, C.
Banday, A.J.
Barreiro, R.B.
Bartlett, J.G.
Bartolo, N.
Battaner, E.
Battye, R.
Benabed, K.
Benoit, A.
Benoit-Levy, A.
Bernard, J.P.
Bersanelli, M.
Bielewicz, P.
Bobin, J.
Bock, J.J.
Bonaldi, A.
Bonavera, L.
Bond, J.R.
Borrill, J.
Bouchet, F.R.
Bridges, M.
Bucher, M.
Burigana, C.
Butler, R.C.
Cardoso, J.F.
Catalano, A.
Challinor, A.
Chamballu, A.
Chary, R.R.
Chiang, L.Y.
Chiang, H.C.
Christensen, P.R.
Church, S.
Clements, D.L.
Colombi, S.
Colombo, L.P.L.
Couchot, F.
Coulais, A.
Crill, B.P.
Cruz, M.
Curto, A.
Cuttaia, F.
Danese, L.
Davies, R.D.
Davis, R.J.
de Bernardis, P.
de Rosa, A.
de Zotti, G.
Delabrouille, J.
Delouis, J.M.
Desert, F.X.
Diego, J.M.
Dole, H.
Donzelli, S.
Dore, O.
Douspis, M.
Ducout, A.
Dupac, X.
Efstathiou, G.
Elsner, F.
Ensslin, T.A.
Eriksen, H.K.
Fantaye, Y.
Fergusson, J.
Finelli, F.
Forni, O.
Frailis, M.
Franceschi, E.
Frommert, M.
Galeotta, S.
Ganga, K.
Giard, M.
Giardino, G.
Giraud-Heraud, Y.
Gonzalez-Nuevo, J.
Gorski, K.M.
Gratton, S.
Gregorio, A.
Gruppuso, A.
Hansen, M.
Hansen, F.K.
Hanson, D.
Harrison, D.
Helou, G.
Henrot-Versille, S.
Hernandez-Monteagudo, C.
Herranz, D.
Hildebrandt, S.R.
Hivon, E.
Hobson, M.
Holmes, W.A.
Hornstrup, A.
Hovest, W.
Huffenberger, K.M.
Jaffe, T.R.
Jaffe, A.H.
Jones, W.C.
Juvela, M.
Keihanen, E.
Keskitalo, R.
Kim, J.
Kisner, T.S.
Knoche, J.
Knox, L.
Kunz, M.
Kurki-Suonio, H.
Lagache, G.
Lahteenmaki, A.
Lamarre, J.M.
Lasenby, A.
Laureijs, R.J.
Lawrence, C.R.
Leahy, J.P.
Leonardi, R.
Leroy, C.
Lesgourgues, J.
Liguori, M.
Lilje, P.B.
Linden-Vornle, M.
Lopez-Caniego, M.
Lubin, P.M.
Macias-Perez, J.F.
Maffei, B.
Maino, D.
Mandolesi, N.
Mangilli, A.
Marinucci, D.
Maris, M.
Marshall, D.J.
Martin, P.G.
Martinez-Gonzalez, E.
Masi, S.
Matarrese, S.
Matthai, F.
Mazzotta, P.
McEwen, J.D.
Meinhold, P.R.
Melchiorri, A.
Mendes, L.
Mennella, A.
Migliaccio, M.
Mikkelsen, K.
Mitra, S.
Miville-Deschenes, M.A.
Molinari, D.
Moneti, A.
Montier, L.
Morgante, G.
Mortlock, D.
Moss, A.
Munshi, D.
Naselsky, P.
Nati, F.
Natoli, P.
Netterfield, C.B.
Norgaard-Nielsen, H.U.
Noviello, F.
Novikov, D.
Novikov, I.
Osborne, S.
Oxborrow, C.A.
Paci, F.
Pagano, L.
Pajot, F.
Paoletti, D.
Pasian, F.
Patanchon, G.
Peiris, H.V.
Perdereau, O.
Perotto, L.
Perrotta, F.
Piacentini, F.
Piat, M.
Pierpaoli, E.
Pietrobon, D.
Plaszczynski, S.
Pointecouteau, E.
Pogosyan, D.
Polenta, G.
Ponthieu, N.
Popa, L.
Poutanen, T.
Pratt, G.W.
Prezeau, G.
Prunet, S.
Puget, J.L.
Rachen, J.P.
Rath, C.
Rebolo, R.
Reinecke, M.
Remazeilles, M.
Renault, C.
Renzi, A.
Ricciardi, S.
Riller, T.
Ristorcelli, I.
Rocha, G.
Rosset, C.
Rotti, A.
Roudier, G.
Rubino-Martin, J.A.
Rusholme, B.
Sandri, M.
Santos, D.
Savini, G.
Scott, D.
Seiffert, M.D.
Shellard, E.P.S.
Souradeep, T.
Spencer, L.D.
Starck, J.L.
Stolyarov, V.
Stompor, R.
Sudiwala, R.
Sureau, F.
Sutter, P.
Sutton, D.
Suur-Uski, A.S.
Sygnet, J.F.
Tauber, J.A.
Tavagnacco, D.
Terenzi, L.
Toffolatti, L.
Tomasi, M.
Tristram, M.
Tucci, M.
Tuovinen, J.
Turler, M.
Valenziano, L.
Valiviita, J.
Van Tent, B.
Varis, J.
Vielva, P.
Villa, F.
Vittorio, N.
Wade, L.A.
Wandelt, B.D.
Wehus, I.K.
White, M.
Wilkinson, A.
Yvon, D.
Zacchei, A.
Zonca, A.
author_facet Ade, P.A.R.
Aghanim, N.
Armitage-Caplan, C.
Arnaud, M.
Ashdown, M.
Atrio-Barandela, F.
Aumont, J.
Baccigalupi, C.
Banday, A.J.
Barreiro, R.B.
Bartlett, J.G.
Bartolo, N.
Battaner, E.
Battye, R.
Benabed, K.
Benoit, A.
Benoit-Levy, A.
Bernard, J.P.
Bersanelli, M.
Bielewicz, P.
Bobin, J.
Bock, J.J.
Bonaldi, A.
Bonavera, L.
Bond, J.R.
Borrill, J.
Bouchet, F.R.
Bridges, M.
Bucher, M.
Burigana, C.
Butler, R.C.
Cardoso, J.F.
Catalano, A.
Challinor, A.
Chamballu, A.
Chary, R.R.
Chiang, L.Y.
Chiang, H.C.
Christensen, P.R.
Church, S.
Clements, D.L.
Colombi, S.
Colombo, L.P.L.
Couchot, F.
Coulais, A.
Crill, B.P.
Cruz, M.
Curto, A.
Cuttaia, F.
Danese, L.
Davies, R.D.
Davis, R.J.
de Bernardis, P.
de Rosa, A.
de Zotti, G.
Delabrouille, J.
Delouis, J.M.
Desert, F.X.
Diego, J.M.
Dole, H.
Donzelli, S.
Dore, O.
Douspis, M.
Ducout, A.
Dupac, X.
Efstathiou, G.
Elsner, F.
Ensslin, T.A.
Eriksen, H.K.
Fantaye, Y.
Fergusson, J.
Finelli, F.
Forni, O.
Frailis, M.
Franceschi, E.
Frommert, M.
Galeotta, S.
Ganga, K.
Giard, M.
Giardino, G.
Giraud-Heraud, Y.
Gonzalez-Nuevo, J.
Gorski, K.M.
Gratton, S.
Gregorio, A.
Gruppuso, A.
Hansen, M.
Hansen, F.K.
Hanson, D.
Harrison, D.
Helou, G.
Henrot-Versille, S.
Hernandez-Monteagudo, C.
Herranz, D.
Hildebrandt, S.R.
Hivon, E.
Hobson, M.
Holmes, W.A.
Hornstrup, A.
Hovest, W.
Huffenberger, K.M.
Jaffe, T.R.
Jaffe, A.H.
Jones, W.C.
Juvela, M.
Keihanen, E.
Keskitalo, R.
Kim, J.
Kisner, T.S.
Knoche, J.
Knox, L.
Kunz, M.
Kurki-Suonio, H.
Lagache, G.
Lahteenmaki, A.
Lamarre, J.M.
Lasenby, A.
Laureijs, R.J.
Lawrence, C.R.
Leahy, J.P.
Leonardi, R.
Leroy, C.
Lesgourgues, J.
Liguori, M.
Lilje, P.B.
Linden-Vornle, M.
Lopez-Caniego, M.
Lubin, P.M.
Macias-Perez, J.F.
Maffei, B.
Maino, D.
Mandolesi, N.
Mangilli, A.
Marinucci, D.
Maris, M.
Marshall, D.J.
Martin, P.G.
Martinez-Gonzalez, E.
Masi, S.
Matarrese, S.
Matthai, F.
Mazzotta, P.
McEwen, J.D.
Meinhold, P.R.
Melchiorri, A.
Mendes, L.
Mennella, A.
Migliaccio, M.
Mikkelsen, K.
Mitra, S.
Miville-Deschenes, M.A.
Molinari, D.
Moneti, A.
Montier, L.
Morgante, G.
Mortlock, D.
Moss, A.
Munshi, D.
Naselsky, P.
Nati, F.
Natoli, P.
Netterfield, C.B.
Norgaard-Nielsen, H.U.
Noviello, F.
Novikov, D.
Novikov, I.
Osborne, S.
Oxborrow, C.A.
Paci, F.
Pagano, L.
Pajot, F.
Paoletti, D.
Pasian, F.
Patanchon, G.
Peiris, H.V.
Perdereau, O.
Perotto, L.
Perrotta, F.
Piacentini, F.
Piat, M.
Pierpaoli, E.
Pietrobon, D.
Plaszczynski, S.
Pointecouteau, E.
Pogosyan, D.
Polenta, G.
Ponthieu, N.
Popa, L.
Poutanen, T.
Pratt, G.W.
Prezeau, G.
Prunet, S.
Puget, J.L.
Rachen, J.P.
Rath, C.
Rebolo, R.
Reinecke, M.
Remazeilles, M.
Renault, C.
Renzi, A.
Ricciardi, S.
Riller, T.
Ristorcelli, I.
Rocha, G.
Rosset, C.
Rotti, A.
Roudier, G.
Rubino-Martin, J.A.
Rusholme, B.
Sandri, M.
Santos, D.
Savini, G.
Scott, D.
Seiffert, M.D.
Shellard, E.P.S.
Souradeep, T.
Spencer, L.D.
Starck, J.L.
Stolyarov, V.
Stompor, R.
Sudiwala, R.
Sureau, F.
Sutter, P.
Sutton, D.
Suur-Uski, A.S.
Sygnet, J.F.
Tauber, J.A.
Tavagnacco, D.
Terenzi, L.
Toffolatti, L.
Tomasi, M.
Tristram, M.
Tucci, M.
Tuovinen, J.
Turler, M.
Valenziano, L.
Valiviita, J.
Van Tent, B.
Varis, J.
Vielva, P.
Villa, F.
Vittorio, N.
Wade, L.A.
Wandelt, B.D.
Wehus, I.K.
White, M.
Wilkinson, A.
Yvon, D.
Zacchei, A.
Zonca, A.
author_sort Ade, P.A.R.
collection CERN
description The two fundamental assumptions of the standard cosmological model - that the initial fluctuations are statistically isotropic and Gaussian - are rigorously tested using maps of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropy from the Planck satellite. Deviations from isotropy have been found and demonstrated to be robust against component separation algorithm, mask choice and frequency dependence. Many of these anomalies were previously observed in the WMAP data, and are now confirmed at similar levels of significance (about 3 sigma). However, we find little evidence for non-Gaussianity, with the exception of a few statistical signatures that seem to be associated with specific anomalies. In particular, we find that the quadrupole-octopole alignment is also connected to a low observed variance of the CMB signal. A power asymmetry is now found to persist to scales corresponding to about l=600, and can be described in the low-l regime by a phenomenological dipole modulation model. However, any primordial power asymmetry is strongly scale-dependent and does not extend to arbitrarily small angular scales. Finally, it is plausible that some of these features may be reflected in the angular power spectrum of the data, which shows a deficit of power on similar scales. Indeed, when the power spectra of two hemispheres defined by a preferred direction are considered separately, one shows evidence for a deficit in power, while its opposite contains oscillations between odd and even modes that may be related to the parity violation and phase correlations also detected in the data. Although these analyses represent a step forward in building an understanding of the anomalies, a satisfactory explanation based on physically motivated models is still lacking.
id cern-1530693
institution Organización Europea para la Investigación Nuclear
language eng
publishDate 2013
record_format invenio
spelling cern-15306932023-10-12T05:28:12Zdoi:10.1051/0004-6361/201321534http://cds.cern.ch/record/1530693engAde, P.A.R.Aghanim, N.Armitage-Caplan, C.Arnaud, M.Ashdown, M.Atrio-Barandela, F.Aumont, J.Baccigalupi, C.Banday, A.J.Barreiro, R.B.Bartlett, J.G.Bartolo, N.Battaner, E.Battye, R.Benabed, K.Benoit, A.Benoit-Levy, A.Bernard, J.P.Bersanelli, M.Bielewicz, P.Bobin, J.Bock, J.J.Bonaldi, A.Bonavera, L.Bond, J.R.Borrill, J.Bouchet, F.R.Bridges, M.Bucher, M.Burigana, C.Butler, R.C.Cardoso, J.F.Catalano, A.Challinor, A.Chamballu, A.Chary, R.R.Chiang, L.Y.Chiang, H.C.Christensen, P.R.Church, S.Clements, D.L.Colombi, S.Colombo, L.P.L.Couchot, F.Coulais, A.Crill, B.P.Cruz, M.Curto, A.Cuttaia, F.Danese, L.Davies, R.D.Davis, R.J.de Bernardis, P.de Rosa, A.de Zotti, G.Delabrouille, J.Delouis, J.M.Desert, F.X.Diego, J.M.Dole, H.Donzelli, S.Dore, O.Douspis, M.Ducout, A.Dupac, X.Efstathiou, G.Elsner, F.Ensslin, T.A.Eriksen, H.K.Fantaye, Y.Fergusson, J.Finelli, F.Forni, O.Frailis, M.Franceschi, E.Frommert, M.Galeotta, S.Ganga, K.Giard, M.Giardino, G.Giraud-Heraud, Y.Gonzalez-Nuevo, J.Gorski, K.M.Gratton, S.Gregorio, A.Gruppuso, A.Hansen, M.Hansen, F.K.Hanson, D.Harrison, D.Helou, G.Henrot-Versille, S.Hernandez-Monteagudo, C.Herranz, D.Hildebrandt, S.R.Hivon, E.Hobson, M.Holmes, W.A.Hornstrup, A.Hovest, W.Huffenberger, K.M.Jaffe, T.R.Jaffe, A.H.Jones, W.C.Juvela, M.Keihanen, E.Keskitalo, R.Kim, J.Kisner, T.S.Knoche, J.Knox, L.Kunz, M.Kurki-Suonio, H.Lagache, G.Lahteenmaki, A.Lamarre, J.M.Lasenby, A.Laureijs, R.J.Lawrence, C.R.Leahy, J.P.Leonardi, R.Leroy, C.Lesgourgues, J.Liguori, M.Lilje, P.B.Linden-Vornle, M.Lopez-Caniego, M.Lubin, P.M.Macias-Perez, J.F.Maffei, B.Maino, D.Mandolesi, N.Mangilli, A.Marinucci, D.Maris, M.Marshall, D.J.Martin, P.G.Martinez-Gonzalez, E.Masi, S.Matarrese, S.Matthai, F.Mazzotta, P.McEwen, J.D.Meinhold, P.R.Melchiorri, A.Mendes, L.Mennella, A.Migliaccio, M.Mikkelsen, K.Mitra, S.Miville-Deschenes, M.A.Molinari, D.Moneti, A.Montier, L.Morgante, G.Mortlock, D.Moss, A.Munshi, D.Naselsky, P.Nati, F.Natoli, P.Netterfield, C.B.Norgaard-Nielsen, H.U.Noviello, F.Novikov, D.Novikov, I.Osborne, S.Oxborrow, C.A.Paci, F.Pagano, L.Pajot, F.Paoletti, D.Pasian, F.Patanchon, G.Peiris, H.V.Perdereau, O.Perotto, L.Perrotta, F.Piacentini, F.Piat, M.Pierpaoli, E.Pietrobon, D.Plaszczynski, S.Pointecouteau, E.Pogosyan, D.Polenta, G.Ponthieu, N.Popa, L.Poutanen, T.Pratt, G.W.Prezeau, G.Prunet, S.Puget, J.L.Rachen, J.P.Rath, C.Rebolo, R.Reinecke, M.Remazeilles, M.Renault, C.Renzi, A.Ricciardi, S.Riller, T.Ristorcelli, I.Rocha, G.Rosset, C.Rotti, A.Roudier, G.Rubino-Martin, J.A.Rusholme, B.Sandri, M.Santos, D.Savini, G.Scott, D.Seiffert, M.D.Shellard, E.P.S.Souradeep, T.Spencer, L.D.Starck, J.L.Stolyarov, V.Stompor, R.Sudiwala, R.Sureau, F.Sutter, P.Sutton, D.Suur-Uski, A.S.Sygnet, J.F.Tauber, J.A.Tavagnacco, D.Terenzi, L.Toffolatti, L.Tomasi, M.Tristram, M.Tucci, M.Tuovinen, J.Turler, M.Valenziano, L.Valiviita, J.Van Tent, B.Varis, J.Vielva, P.Villa, F.Vittorio, N.Wade, L.A.Wandelt, B.D.Wehus, I.K.White, M.Wilkinson, A.Yvon, D.Zacchei, A.Zonca, A.Planck 2013 results. XXIII. Isotropy and Statistics of the CMBAstrophysics and AstronomyThe two fundamental assumptions of the standard cosmological model - that the initial fluctuations are statistically isotropic and Gaussian - are rigorously tested using maps of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropy from the Planck satellite. Deviations from isotropy have been found and demonstrated to be robust against component separation algorithm, mask choice and frequency dependence. Many of these anomalies were previously observed in the WMAP data, and are now confirmed at similar levels of significance (about 3 sigma). However, we find little evidence for non-Gaussianity, with the exception of a few statistical signatures that seem to be associated with specific anomalies. In particular, we find that the quadrupole-octopole alignment is also connected to a low observed variance of the CMB signal. A power asymmetry is now found to persist to scales corresponding to about l=600, and can be described in the low-l regime by a phenomenological dipole modulation model. However, any primordial power asymmetry is strongly scale-dependent and does not extend to arbitrarily small angular scales. Finally, it is plausible that some of these features may be reflected in the angular power spectrum of the data, which shows a deficit of power on similar scales. Indeed, when the power spectra of two hemispheres defined by a preferred direction are considered separately, one shows evidence for a deficit in power, while its opposite contains oscillations between odd and even modes that may be related to the parity violation and phase correlations also detected in the data. Although these analyses represent a step forward in building an understanding of the anomalies, a satisfactory explanation based on physically motivated models is still lacking.The two fundamental assumptions of the standard cosmological model - that the initial fluctuations are statistically isotropic and Gaussian - are rigorously tested using maps of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropy from the Planck satellite. Deviations from isotropy have been found and demonstrated to be robust against component separation algorithm, mask choice and frequency dependence. Many of these anomalies were previously observed in the WMAP data, and are now confirmed at similar levels of significance (about 3 sigma). However, we find little evidence for non-Gaussianity, with the exception of a few statistical signatures that seem to be associated with specific anomalies. In particular, we find that the quadrupole-octopole alignment is also connected to a low observed variance of the CMB signal. A power asymmetry is now found to persist to scales corresponding to about l=600, and can be described in the low-l regime by a phenomenological dipole modulation model. However, any primordial power asymmetry is strongly scale-dependent and does not extend to arbitrarily small angular scales. Finally, it is plausible that some of these features may be reflected in the angular power spectrum of the data, which shows a deficit of power on similar scales. Indeed, when the power spectra of two hemispheres defined by a preferred direction are considered separately, one shows evidence for a deficit in power, while its opposite contains oscillations between odd and even modes that may be related to the parity violation and phase correlations also detected in the data. Although these analyses represent a step forward in building an understanding of the anomalies, a satisfactory explanation based on physically motivated models is still lacking.arXiv:1303.5083CERN-PH-TH-2013-136CERN-PH-TH-2013-136oai:cds.cern.ch:15306932013-03-22
spellingShingle Astrophysics and Astronomy
Ade, P.A.R.
Aghanim, N.
Armitage-Caplan, C.
Arnaud, M.
Ashdown, M.
Atrio-Barandela, F.
Aumont, J.
Baccigalupi, C.
Banday, A.J.
Barreiro, R.B.
Bartlett, J.G.
Bartolo, N.
Battaner, E.
Battye, R.
Benabed, K.
Benoit, A.
Benoit-Levy, A.
Bernard, J.P.
Bersanelli, M.
Bielewicz, P.
Bobin, J.
Bock, J.J.
Bonaldi, A.
Bonavera, L.
Bond, J.R.
Borrill, J.
Bouchet, F.R.
Bridges, M.
Bucher, M.
Burigana, C.
Butler, R.C.
Cardoso, J.F.
Catalano, A.
Challinor, A.
Chamballu, A.
Chary, R.R.
Chiang, L.Y.
Chiang, H.C.
Christensen, P.R.
Church, S.
Clements, D.L.
Colombi, S.
Colombo, L.P.L.
Couchot, F.
Coulais, A.
Crill, B.P.
Cruz, M.
Curto, A.
Cuttaia, F.
Danese, L.
Davies, R.D.
Davis, R.J.
de Bernardis, P.
de Rosa, A.
de Zotti, G.
Delabrouille, J.
Delouis, J.M.
Desert, F.X.
Diego, J.M.
Dole, H.
Donzelli, S.
Dore, O.
Douspis, M.
Ducout, A.
Dupac, X.
Efstathiou, G.
Elsner, F.
Ensslin, T.A.
Eriksen, H.K.
Fantaye, Y.
Fergusson, J.
Finelli, F.
Forni, O.
Frailis, M.
Franceschi, E.
Frommert, M.
Galeotta, S.
Ganga, K.
Giard, M.
Giardino, G.
Giraud-Heraud, Y.
Gonzalez-Nuevo, J.
Gorski, K.M.
Gratton, S.
Gregorio, A.
Gruppuso, A.
Hansen, M.
Hansen, F.K.
Hanson, D.
Harrison, D.
Helou, G.
Henrot-Versille, S.
Hernandez-Monteagudo, C.
Herranz, D.
Hildebrandt, S.R.
Hivon, E.
Hobson, M.
Holmes, W.A.
Hornstrup, A.
Hovest, W.
Huffenberger, K.M.
Jaffe, T.R.
Jaffe, A.H.
Jones, W.C.
Juvela, M.
Keihanen, E.
Keskitalo, R.
Kim, J.
Kisner, T.S.
Knoche, J.
Knox, L.
Kunz, M.
Kurki-Suonio, H.
Lagache, G.
Lahteenmaki, A.
Lamarre, J.M.
Lasenby, A.
Laureijs, R.J.
Lawrence, C.R.
Leahy, J.P.
Leonardi, R.
Leroy, C.
Lesgourgues, J.
Liguori, M.
Lilje, P.B.
Linden-Vornle, M.
Lopez-Caniego, M.
Lubin, P.M.
Macias-Perez, J.F.
Maffei, B.
Maino, D.
Mandolesi, N.
Mangilli, A.
Marinucci, D.
Maris, M.
Marshall, D.J.
Martin, P.G.
Martinez-Gonzalez, E.
Masi, S.
Matarrese, S.
Matthai, F.
Mazzotta, P.
McEwen, J.D.
Meinhold, P.R.
Melchiorri, A.
Mendes, L.
Mennella, A.
Migliaccio, M.
Mikkelsen, K.
Mitra, S.
Miville-Deschenes, M.A.
Molinari, D.
Moneti, A.
Montier, L.
Morgante, G.
Mortlock, D.
Moss, A.
Munshi, D.
Naselsky, P.
Nati, F.
Natoli, P.
Netterfield, C.B.
Norgaard-Nielsen, H.U.
Noviello, F.
Novikov, D.
Novikov, I.
Osborne, S.
Oxborrow, C.A.
Paci, F.
Pagano, L.
Pajot, F.
Paoletti, D.
Pasian, F.
Patanchon, G.
Peiris, H.V.
Perdereau, O.
Perotto, L.
Perrotta, F.
Piacentini, F.
Piat, M.
Pierpaoli, E.
Pietrobon, D.
Plaszczynski, S.
Pointecouteau, E.
Pogosyan, D.
Polenta, G.
Ponthieu, N.
Popa, L.
Poutanen, T.
Pratt, G.W.
Prezeau, G.
Prunet, S.
Puget, J.L.
Rachen, J.P.
Rath, C.
Rebolo, R.
Reinecke, M.
Remazeilles, M.
Renault, C.
Renzi, A.
Ricciardi, S.
Riller, T.
Ristorcelli, I.
Rocha, G.
Rosset, C.
Rotti, A.
Roudier, G.
Rubino-Martin, J.A.
Rusholme, B.
Sandri, M.
Santos, D.
Savini, G.
Scott, D.
Seiffert, M.D.
Shellard, E.P.S.
Souradeep, T.
Spencer, L.D.
Starck, J.L.
Stolyarov, V.
Stompor, R.
Sudiwala, R.
Sureau, F.
Sutter, P.
Sutton, D.
Suur-Uski, A.S.
Sygnet, J.F.
Tauber, J.A.
Tavagnacco, D.
Terenzi, L.
Toffolatti, L.
Tomasi, M.
Tristram, M.
Tucci, M.
Tuovinen, J.
Turler, M.
Valenziano, L.
Valiviita, J.
Van Tent, B.
Varis, J.
Vielva, P.
Villa, F.
Vittorio, N.
Wade, L.A.
Wandelt, B.D.
Wehus, I.K.
White, M.
Wilkinson, A.
Yvon, D.
Zacchei, A.
Zonca, A.
Planck 2013 results. XXIII. Isotropy and Statistics of the CMB
title Planck 2013 results. XXIII. Isotropy and Statistics of the CMB
title_full Planck 2013 results. XXIII. Isotropy and Statistics of the CMB
title_fullStr Planck 2013 results. XXIII. Isotropy and Statistics of the CMB
title_full_unstemmed Planck 2013 results. XXIII. Isotropy and Statistics of the CMB
title_short Planck 2013 results. XXIII. Isotropy and Statistics of the CMB
title_sort planck 2013 results. xxiii. isotropy and statistics of the cmb
topic Astrophysics and Astronomy
url https://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201321534
http://cds.cern.ch/record/1530693
work_keys_str_mv AT adepar planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT aghanimn planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT armitagecaplanc planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT arnaudm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT ashdownm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT atriobarandelaf planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT aumontj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT baccigalupic planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bandayaj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT barreirorb planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bartlettjg planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bartolon planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT battanere planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT battyer planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT benabedk planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT benoita planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT benoitlevya planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bernardjp planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bersanellim planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bielewiczp planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bobinj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bockjj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bonaldia planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bonaveral planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bondjr planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT borrillj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bouchetfr planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bridgesm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT bucherm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT buriganac planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT butlerrc planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT cardosojf planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT catalanoa planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT challinora planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT chamballua planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT charyrr planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT chiangly planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT chianghc planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT christensenpr planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT churchs planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT clementsdl planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT colombis planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT colombolpl planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT couchotf planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT coulaisa planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT crillbp planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT cruzm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT curtoa planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT cuttaiaf planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT danesel planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT daviesrd planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT davisrj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT debernardisp planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT derosaa planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT dezottig planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT delabrouillej planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT delouisjm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT desertfx planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT diegojm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT doleh planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT donzellis planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT doreo planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT douspism planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT ducouta planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT dupacx planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT efstathioug planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT elsnerf planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT ensslinta planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT eriksenhk planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT fantayey planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT fergussonj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT finellif planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT fornio planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT frailism planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT franceschie planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT frommertm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT galeottas planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT gangak planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT giardm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT giardinog planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT giraudheraudy planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT gonzaleznuevoj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT gorskikm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT grattons planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT gregorioa planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT gruppusoa planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT hansenm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT hansenfk planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT hansond planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT harrisond planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT heloug planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT henrotversilles planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT hernandezmonteagudoc planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT herranzd planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT hildebrandtsr planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT hivone planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT hobsonm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT holmeswa planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT hornstrupa planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT hovestw planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT huffenbergerkm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT jaffetr planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT jaffeah planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT joneswc planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT juvelam planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT keihanene planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT keskitalor planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT kimj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT kisnerts planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT knochej planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT knoxl planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT kunzm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT kurkisuonioh planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT lagacheg planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT lahteenmakia planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT lamarrejm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT lasenbya planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT laureijsrj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT lawrencecr planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT leahyjp planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT leonardir planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT leroyc planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT lesgourguesj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT liguorim planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT liljepb planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT lindenvornlem planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT lopezcaniegom planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT lubinpm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT maciasperezjf planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT maffeib planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT mainod planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT mandolesin planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT mangillia planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT marinuccid planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT marism planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT marshalldj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT martinpg planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT martinezgonzaleze planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT masis planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT matarreses planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT matthaif planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT mazzottap planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT mcewenjd planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT meinholdpr planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT melchiorria planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT mendesl planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT mennellaa planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT migliacciom planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT mikkelsenk planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT mitras planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT mivilledeschenesma planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT molinarid planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT monetia planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT montierl planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT morganteg planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT mortlockd planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT mossa planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT munshid planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT naselskyp planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT natif planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT natolip planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT netterfieldcb planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT norgaardnielsenhu planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT noviellof planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT novikovd planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT novikovi planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT osbornes planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT oxborrowca planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT pacif planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT paganol planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT pajotf planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT paolettid planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT pasianf planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT patanchong planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT peirishv planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT perdereauo planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT perottol planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT perrottaf planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT piacentinif planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT piatm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT pierpaolie planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT pietrobond planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT plaszczynskis planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT pointecouteaue planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT pogosyand planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT polentag planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT ponthieun planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT popal planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT poutanent planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT prattgw planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT prezeaug planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT prunets planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT pugetjl planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT rachenjp planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT rathc planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT rebolor planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT reineckem planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT remazeillesm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT renaultc planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT renzia planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT ricciardis planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT rillert planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT ristorcellii planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT rochag planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT rossetc planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT rottia planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT roudierg planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT rubinomartinja planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT rusholmeb planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT sandrim planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT santosd planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT savinig planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT scottd planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT seiffertmd planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT shellardeps planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT souradeept planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT spencerld planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT starckjl planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT stolyarovv planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT stomporr planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT sudiwalar planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT sureauf planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT sutterp planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT suttond planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT suuruskias planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT sygnetjf planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT tauberja planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT tavagnaccod planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT terenzil planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT toffolattil planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT tomasim planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT tristramm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT tuccim planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT tuovinenj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT turlerm planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT valenzianol planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT valiviitaj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT vantentb planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT varisj planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT vielvap planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT villaf planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT vittorion planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT wadela planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT wandeltbd planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT wehusik planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT whitem planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT wilkinsona planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT yvond planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT zaccheia planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb
AT zoncaa planck2013resultsxxiiiisotropyandstatisticsofthecmb