Cargando…

Planck 2015 results. XIV. Dark energy and modified gravity

We study the implications of Planck data for models of dark energy (DE) and modified gravity (MG), beyond the cosmological constant scenario. We start with cases where the DE only directly affects the background evolution, considering Taylor expansions of the equation of state, principal component a...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Ade, P.A.R., Aghanim, N., Arnaud, M., Ashdown, M., Aumont, J., Baccigalupi, C., Banday, A.J., Barreiro, R.B., Bartolo, N., Battaner, E., Battye, R., Benabed, K., Benoit, A., Benoit-Levy, A., Bernard, J.P., Bersanelli, M., Bielewicz, P., Bonaldi, A., Bonavera, L., Bond, J.R., Borrill, J., Bouchet, F.R., Bucher, M., Burigana, C., Butler, R.C., Calabrese, E., Cardoso, J.F., Catalano, A., Challinor, A., Chamballu, A., Chiang, H.C., Christensen, P.R., Church, S., Clements, D.L., Colombi, S., Colombo, L.P.L., Combet, C., Couchot, F., Coulais, A., Crill, B.P., Curto, A., Cuttaia, F., Danese, L., Davies, R.D., Davis, R.J., de Bernardis, P., de Rosa, A., de Zotti, G., Delabrouille, J., Desert, F.X., Diego, J.M., Dole, H., Donzelli, S., Dore, O., Douspis, M., Ducout, A., Dupac, X., Efstathiou, G., Elsner, F., Ensslin, T.A., Eriksen, H.K., Fergusson, J., Finelli, F., Forni, O., Frailis, M., Fraisse, A.A., Franceschi, E., Frejsel, A., Galeotta, S., Galli, S., Ganga, K., Giard, M., Giraud-Heraud, Y., Gjerlow, E., Gonzalez-Nuevo, J., Gorski, K.M., Gratton, S., Gregorio, A., Gruppuso, A., Gudmundsson, J.E., Hansen, F.K., Hanson, D., Harrison, D.L., Heavens, A., Helou, G., Henrot-Versille, S., Hernandez-Monteagudo, C., Herranz, D., Hildebrandt, S.R., Hivon, E., Hobson, M., Holmes, W.A., Hornstrup, A., Hovest, W., Huang, Z., Huffenberger, K.M., Hurier, G., Jaffe, A.H., Jaffe, T.R., Jones, W.C., Juvela, M., Keihanen, E., Keskitalo, R., Kisner, T.S., Knoche, J., Kunz, M., Kurki-Suonio, H., Lagache, G., Lahteenmaki, A., Lamarre, J.M., Lasenby, A., Lattanzi, M., Lawrence, C.R., Leonardi, R., Lesgourgues, J., Levrier, F., Lewis, A., Liguori, M., Lilje, P.B., Linden-Vornle, M., Lopez-Caniego, M., Lubin, P.M., Ma, Y.Z., Macias-Perez, J.F., Maggio, G., Maino, D., Mandolesi, N., Mangilli, A., Marchini, A., Martin, P.G., Martinelli, M., Martinez-Gonzalez, E., Masi, S., Matarrese, S., Mazzotta, P., McGehee, P., Meinhold, P.R., Melchiorri, A., Mendes, L., Mennella, A., Migliaccio, M., Mitra, S., Miville-Deschenes, M.A., Moneti, A., Montier, L., Morgante, G., Mortlock, D., Moss, A., Munshi, D., Murphy, J.A., Narimani, A., Naselsky, P., Nati, F., Natoli, P., Netterfield, C.B., Norgaard-Nielsen, H.U., Noviello, F., Novikov, D., Novikov, I., Oxborrow, C.A., Paci, F., Pagano, L., Pajot, F., Paoletti, D., Pasian, F., Patanchon, G., Pearson, T.J., Perdereau, O., Perotto, L., Perrotta, F., Pettorino, V., Piacentini, F., Piat, M., Pierpaoli, E., Pietrobon, D., Plaszczynski, S., Pointecouteau, E., Polenta, G., Popa, L., Pratt, G.W., Prezeau, G., Prunet, S., Puget, J.L., Rachen, J.P., Reach, W.T., Rebolo, R., Reinecke, M., Remazeilles, M., Renault, C., Renzi, A., Ristorcelli, I., Rocha, G., Rosset, C., Rossetti, M., Roudier, G., Rowan-Robinson, M., Rubino-Martin, J.A., Rusholme, B., Salvatelli, V., Sandri, M., Santos, D., Savelainen, M., Savini, G., Schaefer, B.M., Scott, D., Seiffert, M.D., Shellard, E.P.S., Spencer, L.D., Stolyarov, V., Stompor, R., Sudiwala, R., Sunyaev, R., Sutton, D., Suur-Uski, A.S., Sygnet, J.F., Tauber, J.A., Terenzi, L., Toffolatti, L., Tomasi, M., Tristram, M., Tucci, M., Tuovinen, J., Valenziano, L., Valiviita, J., Van Tent, B., Viel, M., Vielva, P., Villa, F., Wade, L.A., Wandelt, B.D., Wehus, I.K., White, M., Yvon, D., Zacchei, A., Zonca, A.
Lenguaje:eng
Publicado: 2015
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201525814
http://cds.cern.ch/record/1987167
_version_ 1780945481592995840
author Ade, P.A.R.
Aghanim, N.
Arnaud, M.
Ashdown, M.
Aumont, J.
Baccigalupi, C.
Banday, A.J.
Barreiro, R.B.
Bartolo, N.
Battaner, E.
Battye, R.
Benabed, K.
Benoit, A.
Benoit-Levy, A.
Bernard, J.P.
Bersanelli, M.
Bielewicz, P.
Bonaldi, A.
Bonavera, L.
Bond, J.R.
Borrill, J.
Bouchet, F.R.
Bucher, M.
Burigana, C.
Butler, R.C.
Calabrese, E.
Cardoso, J.F.
Catalano, A.
Challinor, A.
Chamballu, A.
Chiang, H.C.
Christensen, P.R.
Church, S.
Clements, D.L.
Colombi, S.
Colombo, L.P.L.
Combet, C.
Couchot, F.
Coulais, A.
Crill, B.P.
Curto, A.
Cuttaia, F.
Danese, L.
Davies, R.D.
Davis, R.J.
de Bernardis, P.
de Rosa, A.
de Zotti, G.
Delabrouille, J.
Desert, F.X.
Diego, J.M.
Dole, H.
Donzelli, S.
Dore, O.
Douspis, M.
Ducout, A.
Dupac, X.
Efstathiou, G.
Elsner, F.
Ensslin, T.A.
Eriksen, H.K.
Fergusson, J.
Finelli, F.
Forni, O.
Frailis, M.
Fraisse, A.A.
Franceschi, E.
Frejsel, A.
Galeotta, S.
Galli, S.
Ganga, K.
Giard, M.
Giraud-Heraud, Y.
Gjerlow, E.
Gonzalez-Nuevo, J.
Gorski, K.M.
Gratton, S.
Gregorio, A.
Gruppuso, A.
Gudmundsson, J.E.
Hansen, F.K.
Hanson, D.
Harrison, D.L.
Heavens, A.
Helou, G.
Henrot-Versille, S.
Hernandez-Monteagudo, C.
Herranz, D.
Hildebrandt, S.R.
Hivon, E.
Hobson, M.
Holmes, W.A.
Hornstrup, A.
Hovest, W.
Huang, Z.
Huffenberger, K.M.
Hurier, G.
Jaffe, A.H.
Jaffe, T.R.
Jones, W.C.
Juvela, M.
Keihanen, E.
Keskitalo, R.
Kisner, T.S.
Knoche, J.
Kunz, M.
Kurki-Suonio, H.
Lagache, G.
Lahteenmaki, A.
Lamarre, J.M.
Lasenby, A.
Lattanzi, M.
Lawrence, C.R.
Leonardi, R.
Lesgourgues, J.
Levrier, F.
Lewis, A.
Liguori, M.
Lilje, P.B.
Linden-Vornle, M.
Lopez-Caniego, M.
Lubin, P.M.
Ma, Y.Z.
Macias-Perez, J.F.
Maggio, G.
Maino, D.
Mandolesi, N.
Mangilli, A.
Marchini, A.
Martin, P.G.
Martinelli, M.
Martinez-Gonzalez, E.
Masi, S.
Matarrese, S.
Mazzotta, P.
McGehee, P.
Meinhold, P.R.
Melchiorri, A.
Mendes, L.
Mennella, A.
Migliaccio, M.
Mitra, S.
Miville-Deschenes, M.A.
Moneti, A.
Montier, L.
Morgante, G.
Mortlock, D.
Moss, A.
Munshi, D.
Murphy, J.A.
Narimani, A.
Naselsky, P.
Nati, F.
Natoli, P.
Netterfield, C.B.
Norgaard-Nielsen, H.U.
Noviello, F.
Novikov, D.
Novikov, I.
Oxborrow, C.A.
Paci, F.
Pagano, L.
Pajot, F.
Paoletti, D.
Pasian, F.
Patanchon, G.
Pearson, T.J.
Perdereau, O.
Perotto, L.
Perrotta, F.
Pettorino, V.
Piacentini, F.
Piat, M.
Pierpaoli, E.
Pietrobon, D.
Plaszczynski, S.
Pointecouteau, E.
Polenta, G.
Popa, L.
Pratt, G.W.
Prezeau, G.
Prunet, S.
Puget, J.L.
Rachen, J.P.
Reach, W.T.
Rebolo, R.
Reinecke, M.
Remazeilles, M.
Renault, C.
Renzi, A.
Ristorcelli, I.
Rocha, G.
Rosset, C.
Rossetti, M.
Roudier, G.
Rowan-Robinson, M.
Rubino-Martin, J.A.
Rusholme, B.
Salvatelli, V.
Sandri, M.
Santos, D.
Savelainen, M.
Savini, G.
Schaefer, B.M.
Scott, D.
Seiffert, M.D.
Shellard, E.P.S.
Spencer, L.D.
Stolyarov, V.
Stompor, R.
Sudiwala, R.
Sunyaev, R.
Sutton, D.
Suur-Uski, A.S.
Sygnet, J.F.
Tauber, J.A.
Terenzi, L.
Toffolatti, L.
Tomasi, M.
Tristram, M.
Tucci, M.
Tuovinen, J.
Valenziano, L.
Valiviita, J.
Van Tent, B.
Viel, M.
Vielva, P.
Villa, F.
Wade, L.A.
Wandelt, B.D.
Wehus, I.K.
White, M.
Yvon, D.
Zacchei, A.
Zonca, A.
author_facet Ade, P.A.R.
Aghanim, N.
Arnaud, M.
Ashdown, M.
Aumont, J.
Baccigalupi, C.
Banday, A.J.
Barreiro, R.B.
Bartolo, N.
Battaner, E.
Battye, R.
Benabed, K.
Benoit, A.
Benoit-Levy, A.
Bernard, J.P.
Bersanelli, M.
Bielewicz, P.
Bonaldi, A.
Bonavera, L.
Bond, J.R.
Borrill, J.
Bouchet, F.R.
Bucher, M.
Burigana, C.
Butler, R.C.
Calabrese, E.
Cardoso, J.F.
Catalano, A.
Challinor, A.
Chamballu, A.
Chiang, H.C.
Christensen, P.R.
Church, S.
Clements, D.L.
Colombi, S.
Colombo, L.P.L.
Combet, C.
Couchot, F.
Coulais, A.
Crill, B.P.
Curto, A.
Cuttaia, F.
Danese, L.
Davies, R.D.
Davis, R.J.
de Bernardis, P.
de Rosa, A.
de Zotti, G.
Delabrouille, J.
Desert, F.X.
Diego, J.M.
Dole, H.
Donzelli, S.
Dore, O.
Douspis, M.
Ducout, A.
Dupac, X.
Efstathiou, G.
Elsner, F.
Ensslin, T.A.
Eriksen, H.K.
Fergusson, J.
Finelli, F.
Forni, O.
Frailis, M.
Fraisse, A.A.
Franceschi, E.
Frejsel, A.
Galeotta, S.
Galli, S.
Ganga, K.
Giard, M.
Giraud-Heraud, Y.
Gjerlow, E.
Gonzalez-Nuevo, J.
Gorski, K.M.
Gratton, S.
Gregorio, A.
Gruppuso, A.
Gudmundsson, J.E.
Hansen, F.K.
Hanson, D.
Harrison, D.L.
Heavens, A.
Helou, G.
Henrot-Versille, S.
Hernandez-Monteagudo, C.
Herranz, D.
Hildebrandt, S.R.
Hivon, E.
Hobson, M.
Holmes, W.A.
Hornstrup, A.
Hovest, W.
Huang, Z.
Huffenberger, K.M.
Hurier, G.
Jaffe, A.H.
Jaffe, T.R.
Jones, W.C.
Juvela, M.
Keihanen, E.
Keskitalo, R.
Kisner, T.S.
Knoche, J.
Kunz, M.
Kurki-Suonio, H.
Lagache, G.
Lahteenmaki, A.
Lamarre, J.M.
Lasenby, A.
Lattanzi, M.
Lawrence, C.R.
Leonardi, R.
Lesgourgues, J.
Levrier, F.
Lewis, A.
Liguori, M.
Lilje, P.B.
Linden-Vornle, M.
Lopez-Caniego, M.
Lubin, P.M.
Ma, Y.Z.
Macias-Perez, J.F.
Maggio, G.
Maino, D.
Mandolesi, N.
Mangilli, A.
Marchini, A.
Martin, P.G.
Martinelli, M.
Martinez-Gonzalez, E.
Masi, S.
Matarrese, S.
Mazzotta, P.
McGehee, P.
Meinhold, P.R.
Melchiorri, A.
Mendes, L.
Mennella, A.
Migliaccio, M.
Mitra, S.
Miville-Deschenes, M.A.
Moneti, A.
Montier, L.
Morgante, G.
Mortlock, D.
Moss, A.
Munshi, D.
Murphy, J.A.
Narimani, A.
Naselsky, P.
Nati, F.
Natoli, P.
Netterfield, C.B.
Norgaard-Nielsen, H.U.
Noviello, F.
Novikov, D.
Novikov, I.
Oxborrow, C.A.
Paci, F.
Pagano, L.
Pajot, F.
Paoletti, D.
Pasian, F.
Patanchon, G.
Pearson, T.J.
Perdereau, O.
Perotto, L.
Perrotta, F.
Pettorino, V.
Piacentini, F.
Piat, M.
Pierpaoli, E.
Pietrobon, D.
Plaszczynski, S.
Pointecouteau, E.
Polenta, G.
Popa, L.
Pratt, G.W.
Prezeau, G.
Prunet, S.
Puget, J.L.
Rachen, J.P.
Reach, W.T.
Rebolo, R.
Reinecke, M.
Remazeilles, M.
Renault, C.
Renzi, A.
Ristorcelli, I.
Rocha, G.
Rosset, C.
Rossetti, M.
Roudier, G.
Rowan-Robinson, M.
Rubino-Martin, J.A.
Rusholme, B.
Salvatelli, V.
Sandri, M.
Santos, D.
Savelainen, M.
Savini, G.
Schaefer, B.M.
Scott, D.
Seiffert, M.D.
Shellard, E.P.S.
Spencer, L.D.
Stolyarov, V.
Stompor, R.
Sudiwala, R.
Sunyaev, R.
Sutton, D.
Suur-Uski, A.S.
Sygnet, J.F.
Tauber, J.A.
Terenzi, L.
Toffolatti, L.
Tomasi, M.
Tristram, M.
Tucci, M.
Tuovinen, J.
Valenziano, L.
Valiviita, J.
Van Tent, B.
Viel, M.
Vielva, P.
Villa, F.
Wade, L.A.
Wandelt, B.D.
Wehus, I.K.
White, M.
Yvon, D.
Zacchei, A.
Zonca, A.
author_sort Ade, P.A.R.
collection CERN
description We study the implications of Planck data for models of dark energy (DE) and modified gravity (MG), beyond the cosmological constant scenario. We start with cases where the DE only directly affects the background evolution, considering Taylor expansions of the equation of state, principal component analysis and parameterizations related to the potential of a minimally coupled DE scalar field. When estimating the density of DE at early times, we significantly improve present constraints. We then move to general parameterizations of the DE or MG perturbations that encompass both effective field theories and the phenomenology of gravitational potentials in MG models. Lastly, we test a range of specific models, such as k-essence, f(R) theories and coupled DE. In addition to the latest Planck data, for our main analyses we use baryonic acoustic oscillations, type-Ia supernovae and local measurements of the Hubble constant. We further show the impact of measurements of the cosmological perturbations, such as redshift-space distortions and weak gravitational lensing. These additional probes are important tools for testing MG models and for breaking degeneracies that are still present in the combination of Planck and background data sets. All results that include only background parameterizations are in agreement with LCDM. When testing models that also change perturbations (even when the background is fixed to LCDM), some tensions appear in a few scenarios: the maximum one found is \sim 2 sigma for Planck TT+lowP when parameterizing observables related to the gravitational potentials with a chosen time dependence; the tension increases to at most 3 sigma when external data sets are included. It however disappears when including CMB lensing.
id cern-1987167
institution Organización Europea para la Investigación Nuclear
language eng
publishDate 2015
record_format invenio
spelling cern-19871672022-01-12T03:04:38Zdoi:10.1051/0004-6361/201525814http://cds.cern.ch/record/1987167engAde, P.A.R.Aghanim, N.Arnaud, M.Ashdown, M.Aumont, J.Baccigalupi, C.Banday, A.J.Barreiro, R.B.Bartolo, N.Battaner, E.Battye, R.Benabed, K.Benoit, A.Benoit-Levy, A.Bernard, J.P.Bersanelli, M.Bielewicz, P.Bonaldi, A.Bonavera, L.Bond, J.R.Borrill, J.Bouchet, F.R.Bucher, M.Burigana, C.Butler, R.C.Calabrese, E.Cardoso, J.F.Catalano, A.Challinor, A.Chamballu, A.Chiang, H.C.Christensen, P.R.Church, S.Clements, D.L.Colombi, S.Colombo, L.P.L.Combet, C.Couchot, F.Coulais, A.Crill, B.P.Curto, A.Cuttaia, F.Danese, L.Davies, R.D.Davis, R.J.de Bernardis, P.de Rosa, A.de Zotti, G.Delabrouille, J.Desert, F.X.Diego, J.M.Dole, H.Donzelli, S.Dore, O.Douspis, M.Ducout, A.Dupac, X.Efstathiou, G.Elsner, F.Ensslin, T.A.Eriksen, H.K.Fergusson, J.Finelli, F.Forni, O.Frailis, M.Fraisse, A.A.Franceschi, E.Frejsel, A.Galeotta, S.Galli, S.Ganga, K.Giard, M.Giraud-Heraud, Y.Gjerlow, E.Gonzalez-Nuevo, J.Gorski, K.M.Gratton, S.Gregorio, A.Gruppuso, A.Gudmundsson, J.E.Hansen, F.K.Hanson, D.Harrison, D.L.Heavens, A.Helou, G.Henrot-Versille, S.Hernandez-Monteagudo, C.Herranz, D.Hildebrandt, S.R.Hivon, E.Hobson, M.Holmes, W.A.Hornstrup, A.Hovest, W.Huang, Z.Huffenberger, K.M.Hurier, G.Jaffe, A.H.Jaffe, T.R.Jones, W.C.Juvela, M.Keihanen, E.Keskitalo, R.Kisner, T.S.Knoche, J.Kunz, M.Kurki-Suonio, H.Lagache, G.Lahteenmaki, A.Lamarre, J.M.Lasenby, A.Lattanzi, M.Lawrence, C.R.Leonardi, R.Lesgourgues, J.Levrier, F.Lewis, A.Liguori, M.Lilje, P.B.Linden-Vornle, M.Lopez-Caniego, M.Lubin, P.M.Ma, Y.Z.Macias-Perez, J.F.Maggio, G.Maino, D.Mandolesi, N.Mangilli, A.Marchini, A.Martin, P.G.Martinelli, M.Martinez-Gonzalez, E.Masi, S.Matarrese, S.Mazzotta, P.McGehee, P.Meinhold, P.R.Melchiorri, A.Mendes, L.Mennella, A.Migliaccio, M.Mitra, S.Miville-Deschenes, M.A.Moneti, A.Montier, L.Morgante, G.Mortlock, D.Moss, A.Munshi, D.Murphy, J.A.Narimani, A.Naselsky, P.Nati, F.Natoli, P.Netterfield, C.B.Norgaard-Nielsen, H.U.Noviello, F.Novikov, D.Novikov, I.Oxborrow, C.A.Paci, F.Pagano, L.Pajot, F.Paoletti, D.Pasian, F.Patanchon, G.Pearson, T.J.Perdereau, O.Perotto, L.Perrotta, F.Pettorino, V.Piacentini, F.Piat, M.Pierpaoli, E.Pietrobon, D.Plaszczynski, S.Pointecouteau, E.Polenta, G.Popa, L.Pratt, G.W.Prezeau, G.Prunet, S.Puget, J.L.Rachen, J.P.Reach, W.T.Rebolo, R.Reinecke, M.Remazeilles, M.Renault, C.Renzi, A.Ristorcelli, I.Rocha, G.Rosset, C.Rossetti, M.Roudier, G.Rowan-Robinson, M.Rubino-Martin, J.A.Rusholme, B.Salvatelli, V.Sandri, M.Santos, D.Savelainen, M.Savini, G.Schaefer, B.M.Scott, D.Seiffert, M.D.Shellard, E.P.S.Spencer, L.D.Stolyarov, V.Stompor, R.Sudiwala, R.Sunyaev, R.Sutton, D.Suur-Uski, A.S.Sygnet, J.F.Tauber, J.A.Terenzi, L.Toffolatti, L.Tomasi, M.Tristram, M.Tucci, M.Tuovinen, J.Valenziano, L.Valiviita, J.Van Tent, B.Viel, M.Vielva, P.Villa, F.Wade, L.A.Wandelt, B.D.Wehus, I.K.White, M.Yvon, D.Zacchei, A.Zonca, A.Planck 2015 results. XIV. Dark energy and modified gravityAstrophysics and AstronomyWe study the implications of Planck data for models of dark energy (DE) and modified gravity (MG), beyond the cosmological constant scenario. We start with cases where the DE only directly affects the background evolution, considering Taylor expansions of the equation of state, principal component analysis and parameterizations related to the potential of a minimally coupled DE scalar field. When estimating the density of DE at early times, we significantly improve present constraints. We then move to general parameterizations of the DE or MG perturbations that encompass both effective field theories and the phenomenology of gravitational potentials in MG models. Lastly, we test a range of specific models, such as k-essence, f(R) theories and coupled DE. In addition to the latest Planck data, for our main analyses we use baryonic acoustic oscillations, type-Ia supernovae and local measurements of the Hubble constant. We further show the impact of measurements of the cosmological perturbations, such as redshift-space distortions and weak gravitational lensing. These additional probes are important tools for testing MG models and for breaking degeneracies that are still present in the combination of Planck and background data sets. All results that include only background parameterizations are in agreement with LCDM. When testing models that also change perturbations (even when the background is fixed to LCDM), some tensions appear in a few scenarios: the maximum one found is \sim 2 sigma for Planck TT+lowP when parameterizing observables related to the gravitational potentials with a chosen time dependence; the tension increases to at most 3 sigma when external data sets are included. It however disappears when including CMB lensing.We study the implications of Planck data for models of dark energy (DE) and modified gravity (MG) beyond the standard cosmological constant scenario. We start with cases where the DE only directly affects the background evolution, considering Taylor expansions of the equation of state w(a), as well as principal component analysis and parameterizations related to the potential of a minimally coupled DE scalar field. When estimating the density of DE at early times, we significantly improve present constraints and find that it has to be below ~2% (at 95% confidence) of the critical density, even when forced to play a role for z only. We then move to general parameterizations of the DE or MG perturbations that encompass both effective field theories and the phenomenology of gravitational potentials in MG models. Lastly, we test a range of specific models, such as k-essence, f(R) theories, and coupled DE. In addition to the latest Planck data, for our main analyses, we use background constraints from baryonic acoustic oscillations, type-Ia supernovae, and local measurements of the Hubble constant. We further show the impact of measurements of the cosmological perturbations, such as redshift-space distortions and weak gravitational lensing. These additional probes are important tools for testing MG models and for breaking degeneracies that are still present in the combination of Planck and background data sets. All results that include only background parameterizations (expansion of the equation of state, early DE, general potentials in minimally-coupled scalar fields or principal component analysis) are in agreement with LambdaCDM. When testing models that also change perturbations (even when the background is fixed to LambdaCDM), some tensions appear in a few scenarios: the maximum one found is ~2sigma for Planck TT+lowP when parameterizing observables related to the gravitational potentials with a chosen time dependence; the tension increases to, at most, 3sigma when external data sets are included. It however disappears when including CMB lensing.We study the implications of Planck data for models of dark energy (DE) and modified gravity (MG), beyond the cosmological constant scenario. We start with cases where the DE only directly affects the background evolution, considering Taylor expansions of the equation of state, principal component analysis and parameterizations related to the potential of a minimally coupled DE scalar field. When estimating the density of DE at early times, we significantly improve present constraints. We then move to general parameterizations of the DE or MG perturbations that encompass both effective field theories and the phenomenology of gravitational potentials in MG models. Lastly, we test a range of specific models, such as k-essence, f(R) theories and coupled DE. In addition to the latest Planck data, for our main analyses we use baryonic acoustic oscillations, type-Ia supernovae and local measurements of the Hubble constant. We further show the impact of measurements of the cosmological perturbations, such as redshift-space distortions and weak gravitational lensing. These additional probes are important tools for testing MG models and for breaking degeneracies that are still present in the combination of Planck and background data sets. All results that include only background parameterizations are in agreement with LCDM. When testing models that also change perturbations (even when the background is fixed to LCDM), some tensions appear in a few scenarios: the maximum one found is \sim 2 sigma for Planck TT+lowP when parameterizing observables related to the gravitational potentials with a chosen time dependence; the tension increases to at most 3 sigma when external data sets are included. It however disappears when including CMB lensing.arXiv:1502.01590oai:cds.cern.ch:19871672015-02-05
spellingShingle Astrophysics and Astronomy
Ade, P.A.R.
Aghanim, N.
Arnaud, M.
Ashdown, M.
Aumont, J.
Baccigalupi, C.
Banday, A.J.
Barreiro, R.B.
Bartolo, N.
Battaner, E.
Battye, R.
Benabed, K.
Benoit, A.
Benoit-Levy, A.
Bernard, J.P.
Bersanelli, M.
Bielewicz, P.
Bonaldi, A.
Bonavera, L.
Bond, J.R.
Borrill, J.
Bouchet, F.R.
Bucher, M.
Burigana, C.
Butler, R.C.
Calabrese, E.
Cardoso, J.F.
Catalano, A.
Challinor, A.
Chamballu, A.
Chiang, H.C.
Christensen, P.R.
Church, S.
Clements, D.L.
Colombi, S.
Colombo, L.P.L.
Combet, C.
Couchot, F.
Coulais, A.
Crill, B.P.
Curto, A.
Cuttaia, F.
Danese, L.
Davies, R.D.
Davis, R.J.
de Bernardis, P.
de Rosa, A.
de Zotti, G.
Delabrouille, J.
Desert, F.X.
Diego, J.M.
Dole, H.
Donzelli, S.
Dore, O.
Douspis, M.
Ducout, A.
Dupac, X.
Efstathiou, G.
Elsner, F.
Ensslin, T.A.
Eriksen, H.K.
Fergusson, J.
Finelli, F.
Forni, O.
Frailis, M.
Fraisse, A.A.
Franceschi, E.
Frejsel, A.
Galeotta, S.
Galli, S.
Ganga, K.
Giard, M.
Giraud-Heraud, Y.
Gjerlow, E.
Gonzalez-Nuevo, J.
Gorski, K.M.
Gratton, S.
Gregorio, A.
Gruppuso, A.
Gudmundsson, J.E.
Hansen, F.K.
Hanson, D.
Harrison, D.L.
Heavens, A.
Helou, G.
Henrot-Versille, S.
Hernandez-Monteagudo, C.
Herranz, D.
Hildebrandt, S.R.
Hivon, E.
Hobson, M.
Holmes, W.A.
Hornstrup, A.
Hovest, W.
Huang, Z.
Huffenberger, K.M.
Hurier, G.
Jaffe, A.H.
Jaffe, T.R.
Jones, W.C.
Juvela, M.
Keihanen, E.
Keskitalo, R.
Kisner, T.S.
Knoche, J.
Kunz, M.
Kurki-Suonio, H.
Lagache, G.
Lahteenmaki, A.
Lamarre, J.M.
Lasenby, A.
Lattanzi, M.
Lawrence, C.R.
Leonardi, R.
Lesgourgues, J.
Levrier, F.
Lewis, A.
Liguori, M.
Lilje, P.B.
Linden-Vornle, M.
Lopez-Caniego, M.
Lubin, P.M.
Ma, Y.Z.
Macias-Perez, J.F.
Maggio, G.
Maino, D.
Mandolesi, N.
Mangilli, A.
Marchini, A.
Martin, P.G.
Martinelli, M.
Martinez-Gonzalez, E.
Masi, S.
Matarrese, S.
Mazzotta, P.
McGehee, P.
Meinhold, P.R.
Melchiorri, A.
Mendes, L.
Mennella, A.
Migliaccio, M.
Mitra, S.
Miville-Deschenes, M.A.
Moneti, A.
Montier, L.
Morgante, G.
Mortlock, D.
Moss, A.
Munshi, D.
Murphy, J.A.
Narimani, A.
Naselsky, P.
Nati, F.
Natoli, P.
Netterfield, C.B.
Norgaard-Nielsen, H.U.
Noviello, F.
Novikov, D.
Novikov, I.
Oxborrow, C.A.
Paci, F.
Pagano, L.
Pajot, F.
Paoletti, D.
Pasian, F.
Patanchon, G.
Pearson, T.J.
Perdereau, O.
Perotto, L.
Perrotta, F.
Pettorino, V.
Piacentini, F.
Piat, M.
Pierpaoli, E.
Pietrobon, D.
Plaszczynski, S.
Pointecouteau, E.
Polenta, G.
Popa, L.
Pratt, G.W.
Prezeau, G.
Prunet, S.
Puget, J.L.
Rachen, J.P.
Reach, W.T.
Rebolo, R.
Reinecke, M.
Remazeilles, M.
Renault, C.
Renzi, A.
Ristorcelli, I.
Rocha, G.
Rosset, C.
Rossetti, M.
Roudier, G.
Rowan-Robinson, M.
Rubino-Martin, J.A.
Rusholme, B.
Salvatelli, V.
Sandri, M.
Santos, D.
Savelainen, M.
Savini, G.
Schaefer, B.M.
Scott, D.
Seiffert, M.D.
Shellard, E.P.S.
Spencer, L.D.
Stolyarov, V.
Stompor, R.
Sudiwala, R.
Sunyaev, R.
Sutton, D.
Suur-Uski, A.S.
Sygnet, J.F.
Tauber, J.A.
Terenzi, L.
Toffolatti, L.
Tomasi, M.
Tristram, M.
Tucci, M.
Tuovinen, J.
Valenziano, L.
Valiviita, J.
Van Tent, B.
Viel, M.
Vielva, P.
Villa, F.
Wade, L.A.
Wandelt, B.D.
Wehus, I.K.
White, M.
Yvon, D.
Zacchei, A.
Zonca, A.
Planck 2015 results. XIV. Dark energy and modified gravity
title Planck 2015 results. XIV. Dark energy and modified gravity
title_full Planck 2015 results. XIV. Dark energy and modified gravity
title_fullStr Planck 2015 results. XIV. Dark energy and modified gravity
title_full_unstemmed Planck 2015 results. XIV. Dark energy and modified gravity
title_short Planck 2015 results. XIV. Dark energy and modified gravity
title_sort planck 2015 results. xiv. dark energy and modified gravity
topic Astrophysics and Astronomy
url https://dx.doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201525814
http://cds.cern.ch/record/1987167
work_keys_str_mv AT adepar planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT aghanimn planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT arnaudm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT ashdownm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT aumontj planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT baccigalupic planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT bandayaj planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT barreirorb planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT bartolon planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT battanere planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT battyer planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT benabedk planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT benoita planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT benoitlevya planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT bernardjp planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT bersanellim planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT bielewiczp planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT bonaldia planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT bonaveral planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT bondjr planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT borrillj planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT bouchetfr planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT bucherm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT buriganac planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT butlerrc planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT calabresee planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT cardosojf planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT catalanoa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT challinora planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT chamballua planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT chianghc planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT christensenpr planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT churchs planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT clementsdl planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT colombis planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT colombolpl planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT combetc planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT couchotf planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT coulaisa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT crillbp planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT curtoa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT cuttaiaf planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT danesel planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT daviesrd planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT davisrj planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT debernardisp planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT derosaa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT dezottig planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT delabrouillej planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT desertfx planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT diegojm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT doleh planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT donzellis planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT doreo planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT douspism planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT ducouta planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT dupacx planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT efstathioug planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT elsnerf planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT ensslinta planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT eriksenhk planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT fergussonj planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT finellif planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT fornio planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT frailism planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT fraisseaa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT franceschie planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT frejsela planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT galeottas planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT gallis planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT gangak planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT giardm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT giraudheraudy planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT gjerlowe planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT gonzaleznuevoj planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT gorskikm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT grattons planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT gregorioa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT gruppusoa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT gudmundssonje planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT hansenfk planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT hansond planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT harrisondl planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT heavensa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT heloug planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT henrotversilles planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT hernandezmonteagudoc planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT herranzd planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT hildebrandtsr planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT hivone planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT hobsonm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT holmeswa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT hornstrupa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT hovestw planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT huangz planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT huffenbergerkm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT hurierg planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT jaffeah planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT jaffetr planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT joneswc planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT juvelam planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT keihanene planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT keskitalor planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT kisnerts planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT knochej planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT kunzm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT kurkisuonioh planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT lagacheg planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT lahteenmakia planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT lamarrejm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT lasenbya planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT lattanzim planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT lawrencecr planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT leonardir planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT lesgourguesj planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT levrierf planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT lewisa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT liguorim planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT liljepb planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT lindenvornlem planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT lopezcaniegom planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT lubinpm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT mayz planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT maciasperezjf planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT maggiog planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT mainod planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT mandolesin planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT mangillia planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT marchinia planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT martinpg planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT martinellim planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT martinezgonzaleze planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT masis planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT matarreses planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT mazzottap planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT mcgeheep planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT meinholdpr planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT melchiorria planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT mendesl planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT mennellaa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT migliacciom planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT mitras planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT mivilledeschenesma planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT monetia planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT montierl planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT morganteg planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT mortlockd planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT mossa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT munshid planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT murphyja planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT narimania planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT naselskyp planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT natif planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT natolip planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT netterfieldcb planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT norgaardnielsenhu planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT noviellof planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT novikovd planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT novikovi planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT oxborrowca planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT pacif planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT paganol planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT pajotf planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT paolettid planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT pasianf planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT patanchong planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT pearsontj planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT perdereauo planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT perottol planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT perrottaf planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT pettorinov planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT piacentinif planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT piatm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT pierpaolie planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT pietrobond planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT plaszczynskis planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT pointecouteaue planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT polentag planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT popal planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT prattgw planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT prezeaug planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT prunets planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT pugetjl planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT rachenjp planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT reachwt planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT rebolor planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT reineckem planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT remazeillesm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT renaultc planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT renzia planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT ristorcellii planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT rochag planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT rossetc planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT rossettim planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT roudierg planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT rowanrobinsonm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT rubinomartinja planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT rusholmeb planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT salvatelliv planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT sandrim planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT santosd planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT savelainenm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT savinig planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT schaeferbm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT scottd planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT seiffertmd planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT shellardeps planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT spencerld planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT stolyarovv planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT stomporr planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT sudiwalar planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT sunyaevr planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT suttond planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT suuruskias planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT sygnetjf planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT tauberja planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT terenzil planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT toffolattil planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT tomasim planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT tristramm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT tuccim planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT tuovinenj planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT valenzianol planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT valiviitaj planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT vantentb planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT vielm planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT vielvap planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT villaf planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT wadela planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT wandeltbd planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT wehusik planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT whitem planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT yvond planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT zaccheia planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity
AT zoncaa planck2015resultsxivdarkenergyandmodifiedgravity