Cargando…
The International Pulsar Timing Array second data release: Search for an isotropic Gravitational Wave Background
We searched for an isotropic stochastic gravitational wave background in the second data release of the International Pulsar Timing Array, a global collaboration synthesizing decadal-length pulsar-timing campaigns in North America, Europe, and Australia. In our reference search for a power-law strai...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Lenguaje: | eng |
Publicado: |
2022
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://dx.doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stab3418 http://cds.cern.ch/record/2802680 |
_version_ | 1780972754875449344 |
---|---|
author | Antoniadis, J. Arzoumanian, Z. Babak, S. Bailes, M. Nielsen, A.-S. Bak Baker, P.T. Bassa, C.G. Becsy, B. Berthereau, A. Bonetti, M. Brazier, A. Brook, P.R. Burgay, M. Burke-Spolaor, S. Caballero, R.N. Casey-Clyde, J.A. Chalumeau, A. Champion, D.J. Charisi, M. Chatterjee, S. Chen, S. Cognard, I. Cordes, J.M. Cornish, N.J. Crawford, F. Cromartie, H.T. Crowter, K. Dai, S. DeCesar, M.E. Demorest, P.B. Desvignes, G. Dolch, T. Drachler, B. Falxa, M. Ferrara, E.C. Fiore, W. Fonseca, E. Gair, J.R. Garver-Daniels, N. Goncharov, B. Good, D.C. Graikou, E. Guillemot, L. Guo, Y.J. Hazboun, J.S. Hobbs, G. Hu, H. Islo, K. Janssen, G.H. Jennings, R.J. Johnson, A.D. Jones, M.L. Kaiser, A.R. Kaplan, D.L. Karuppusamy, R. Keith, M.J. Kelley, L.Z. Kerr, M. Key, J.S. Kramer, M. Lam, M.T. Lamb, W.G. Lazio, T.J.W. Lee, K.J. Lentati, L. Liu, K. Luo, J. Lynch, R.S. Lyne, A.G. Madison, D.R. Main, R.A. Manchester, R.N. McEwen, A. McKee, J.W. McLaughlin, M.A. Mickaliger, M.B. Mingarelli, C.M.F. Ng, C. Nice, D.J. Oslowski, S. Parthasarathy, A. Pennucci, T.T. Perera, B.B.P. Perrodin, D. Petiteau, A. Pol, N.S. Porayko, N.K. Possenti, A. Ransom, S.M. Ray, P.S. Reardon, D.J. Russell, C.J. Samajdar, A. Sampson, L.M. Sanidas, S. Sarkissian, J.M. Schmitz, K. Schult, L. Sesana, A. Shaifullah, G. Shannon, R.M. Shapiro-Albert, B.J. Siemens, X. Simon, J. Smith, T.L. Speri, L. Spiewak, R. Stairs, I.H. Stappers, B.W. Stinebring, D.R. Swiggum, J.K. Taylor, S.R. Theureau, G. Tiburzi, C. Vallisneri, M. van der Wateren, E. Vecchio, A. Verbiest, J.P.W. Vigeland, S.J. Wahl, H. Wang, J.B. Wang, J. Wang, L. Witt, C.A. Zhang, S. Zhu, X.J. |
author_facet | Antoniadis, J. Arzoumanian, Z. Babak, S. Bailes, M. Nielsen, A.-S. Bak Baker, P.T. Bassa, C.G. Becsy, B. Berthereau, A. Bonetti, M. Brazier, A. Brook, P.R. Burgay, M. Burke-Spolaor, S. Caballero, R.N. Casey-Clyde, J.A. Chalumeau, A. Champion, D.J. Charisi, M. Chatterjee, S. Chen, S. Cognard, I. Cordes, J.M. Cornish, N.J. Crawford, F. Cromartie, H.T. Crowter, K. Dai, S. DeCesar, M.E. Demorest, P.B. Desvignes, G. Dolch, T. Drachler, B. Falxa, M. Ferrara, E.C. Fiore, W. Fonseca, E. Gair, J.R. Garver-Daniels, N. Goncharov, B. Good, D.C. Graikou, E. Guillemot, L. Guo, Y.J. Hazboun, J.S. Hobbs, G. Hu, H. Islo, K. Janssen, G.H. Jennings, R.J. Johnson, A.D. Jones, M.L. Kaiser, A.R. Kaplan, D.L. Karuppusamy, R. Keith, M.J. Kelley, L.Z. Kerr, M. Key, J.S. Kramer, M. Lam, M.T. Lamb, W.G. Lazio, T.J.W. Lee, K.J. Lentati, L. Liu, K. Luo, J. Lynch, R.S. Lyne, A.G. Madison, D.R. Main, R.A. Manchester, R.N. McEwen, A. McKee, J.W. McLaughlin, M.A. Mickaliger, M.B. Mingarelli, C.M.F. Ng, C. Nice, D.J. Oslowski, S. Parthasarathy, A. Pennucci, T.T. Perera, B.B.P. Perrodin, D. Petiteau, A. Pol, N.S. Porayko, N.K. Possenti, A. Ransom, S.M. Ray, P.S. Reardon, D.J. Russell, C.J. Samajdar, A. Sampson, L.M. Sanidas, S. Sarkissian, J.M. Schmitz, K. Schult, L. Sesana, A. Shaifullah, G. Shannon, R.M. Shapiro-Albert, B.J. Siemens, X. Simon, J. Smith, T.L. Speri, L. Spiewak, R. Stairs, I.H. Stappers, B.W. Stinebring, D.R. Swiggum, J.K. Taylor, S.R. Theureau, G. Tiburzi, C. Vallisneri, M. van der Wateren, E. Vecchio, A. Verbiest, J.P.W. Vigeland, S.J. Wahl, H. Wang, J.B. Wang, J. Wang, L. Witt, C.A. Zhang, S. Zhu, X.J. |
author_sort | Antoniadis, J. |
collection | CERN |
description | We searched for an isotropic stochastic gravitational wave background in the second data release of the International Pulsar Timing Array, a global collaboration synthesizing decadal-length pulsar-timing campaigns in North America, Europe, and Australia. In our reference search for a power-law strain spectrum of the form hc=A(f/1yr−1)α, we found strong evidence for a spectrally similar low-frequency stochastic process of amplitude A=3.8+6.3−2.5×10−15 and spectral index α = −0.5 ± 0.5, where the uncertainties represent 95 per cent credible regions, using information from the auto- and cross-correlation terms between the pulsars in the array. For a spectral index of α = −2/3, as expected from a population of inspiralling supermassive black hole binaries, the recovered amplitude is A=2.8+1.2−0.8×10−15. None the less, no significant evidence of the Hellings–Downs correlations that would indicate a gravitational-wave origin was found. We also analysed the constituent data from the individual pulsar timing arrays in a consistent way, and clearly demonstrate that the combined international data set is more sensitive. Furthermore, we demonstrate that this combined data set produces comparable constraints to recent single-array data sets which have more data than the constituent parts of the combination. Future international data releases will deliver increased sensitivity to gravitational wave radiation, and significantly increase the detection probability. |
id | cern-2802680 |
institution | Organización Europea para la Investigación Nuclear |
language | eng |
publishDate | 2022 |
record_format | invenio |
spelling | cern-28026802023-08-22T03:51:20Zdoi:10.1093/mnras/stab3418http://cds.cern.ch/record/2802680engAntoniadis, J.Arzoumanian, Z.Babak, S.Bailes, M.Nielsen, A.-S. BakBaker, P.T.Bassa, C.G.Becsy, B.Berthereau, A.Bonetti, M.Brazier, A.Brook, P.R.Burgay, M.Burke-Spolaor, S.Caballero, R.N.Casey-Clyde, J.A.Chalumeau, A.Champion, D.J.Charisi, M.Chatterjee, S.Chen, S.Cognard, I.Cordes, J.M.Cornish, N.J.Crawford, F.Cromartie, H.T.Crowter, K.Dai, S.DeCesar, M.E.Demorest, P.B.Desvignes, G.Dolch, T.Drachler, B.Falxa, M.Ferrara, E.C.Fiore, W.Fonseca, E.Gair, J.R.Garver-Daniels, N.Goncharov, B.Good, D.C.Graikou, E.Guillemot, L.Guo, Y.J.Hazboun, J.S.Hobbs, G.Hu, H.Islo, K.Janssen, G.H.Jennings, R.J.Johnson, A.D.Jones, M.L.Kaiser, A.R.Kaplan, D.L.Karuppusamy, R.Keith, M.J.Kelley, L.Z.Kerr, M.Key, J.S.Kramer, M.Lam, M.T.Lamb, W.G.Lazio, T.J.W.Lee, K.J.Lentati, L.Liu, K.Luo, J.Lynch, R.S.Lyne, A.G.Madison, D.R.Main, R.A.Manchester, R.N.McEwen, A.McKee, J.W.McLaughlin, M.A.Mickaliger, M.B.Mingarelli, C.M.F.Ng, C.Nice, D.J.Oslowski, S.Parthasarathy, A.Pennucci, T.T.Perera, B.B.P.Perrodin, D.Petiteau, A.Pol, N.S.Porayko, N.K.Possenti, A.Ransom, S.M.Ray, P.S.Reardon, D.J.Russell, C.J.Samajdar, A.Sampson, L.M.Sanidas, S.Sarkissian, J.M.Schmitz, K.Schult, L.Sesana, A.Shaifullah, G.Shannon, R.M.Shapiro-Albert, B.J.Siemens, X.Simon, J.Smith, T.L.Speri, L.Spiewak, R.Stairs, I.H.Stappers, B.W.Stinebring, D.R.Swiggum, J.K.Taylor, S.R.Theureau, G.Tiburzi, C.Vallisneri, M.van der Wateren, E.Vecchio, A.Verbiest, J.P.W.Vigeland, S.J.Wahl, H.Wang, J.B.Wang, J.Wang, L.Witt, C.A.Zhang, S.Zhu, X.J.The International Pulsar Timing Array second data release: Search for an isotropic Gravitational Wave Backgroundastro-ph.IMAstrophysics and Astronomyastro-ph.HEAstrophysics and AstronomyWe searched for an isotropic stochastic gravitational wave background in the second data release of the International Pulsar Timing Array, a global collaboration synthesizing decadal-length pulsar-timing campaigns in North America, Europe, and Australia. In our reference search for a power-law strain spectrum of the form hc=A(f/1yr−1)α, we found strong evidence for a spectrally similar low-frequency stochastic process of amplitude A=3.8+6.3−2.5×10−15 and spectral index α = −0.5 ± 0.5, where the uncertainties represent 95 per cent credible regions, using information from the auto- and cross-correlation terms between the pulsars in the array. For a spectral index of α = −2/3, as expected from a population of inspiralling supermassive black hole binaries, the recovered amplitude is A=2.8+1.2−0.8×10−15. None the less, no significant evidence of the Hellings–Downs correlations that would indicate a gravitational-wave origin was found. We also analysed the constituent data from the individual pulsar timing arrays in a consistent way, and clearly demonstrate that the combined international data set is more sensitive. Furthermore, we demonstrate that this combined data set produces comparable constraints to recent single-array data sets which have more data than the constituent parts of the combination. Future international data releases will deliver increased sensitivity to gravitational wave radiation, and significantly increase the detection probability.We searched for an isotropic stochastic gravitational wave background in the second data release of the International Pulsar Timing Array, a global collaboration synthesizing decadal-length pulsar-timing campaigns in North America, Europe, and Australia. In our reference search for a power law strain spectrum of the form $h_c = A(f/1\,\mathrm{yr}^{-1})^{\alpha}$, we found strong evidence for a spectrally-similar low-frequency stochastic process of amplitude $A = 3.8^{+6.3}_{-2.5}\times10^{-15}$ and spectral index $\alpha = -0.5 \pm 0.5$, where the uncertainties represent 95% credible regions, using information from the auto- and cross-correlation terms between the pulsars in the array. For a spectral index of $\alpha = -2/3$, as expected from a population of inspiralling supermassive black hole binaries, the recovered amplitude is $A = 2.8^{+1.2}_{-0.8}\times10^{-15}$. Nonetheless, no significant evidence of the Hellings-Downs correlations that would indicate a gravitational-wave origin was found. We also analyzed the constituent data from the individual pulsar timing arrays in a consistent way, and clearly demonstrate that the combined international data set is more sensitive. Furthermore, we demonstrate that this combined data set produces comparable constraints to recent single-array data sets which have more data than the constituent parts of the combination. Future international data releases will deliver increased sensitivity to gravitational wave radiation, and significantly increase the detection probability.arXiv:2201.03980oai:cds.cern.ch:28026802022-01-11 |
spellingShingle | astro-ph.IM Astrophysics and Astronomy astro-ph.HE Astrophysics and Astronomy Antoniadis, J. Arzoumanian, Z. Babak, S. Bailes, M. Nielsen, A.-S. Bak Baker, P.T. Bassa, C.G. Becsy, B. Berthereau, A. Bonetti, M. Brazier, A. Brook, P.R. Burgay, M. Burke-Spolaor, S. Caballero, R.N. Casey-Clyde, J.A. Chalumeau, A. Champion, D.J. Charisi, M. Chatterjee, S. Chen, S. Cognard, I. Cordes, J.M. Cornish, N.J. Crawford, F. Cromartie, H.T. Crowter, K. Dai, S. DeCesar, M.E. Demorest, P.B. Desvignes, G. Dolch, T. Drachler, B. Falxa, M. Ferrara, E.C. Fiore, W. Fonseca, E. Gair, J.R. Garver-Daniels, N. Goncharov, B. Good, D.C. Graikou, E. Guillemot, L. Guo, Y.J. Hazboun, J.S. Hobbs, G. Hu, H. Islo, K. Janssen, G.H. Jennings, R.J. Johnson, A.D. Jones, M.L. Kaiser, A.R. Kaplan, D.L. Karuppusamy, R. Keith, M.J. Kelley, L.Z. Kerr, M. Key, J.S. Kramer, M. Lam, M.T. Lamb, W.G. Lazio, T.J.W. Lee, K.J. Lentati, L. Liu, K. Luo, J. Lynch, R.S. Lyne, A.G. Madison, D.R. Main, R.A. Manchester, R.N. McEwen, A. McKee, J.W. McLaughlin, M.A. Mickaliger, M.B. Mingarelli, C.M.F. Ng, C. Nice, D.J. Oslowski, S. Parthasarathy, A. Pennucci, T.T. Perera, B.B.P. Perrodin, D. Petiteau, A. Pol, N.S. Porayko, N.K. Possenti, A. Ransom, S.M. Ray, P.S. Reardon, D.J. Russell, C.J. Samajdar, A. Sampson, L.M. Sanidas, S. Sarkissian, J.M. Schmitz, K. Schult, L. Sesana, A. Shaifullah, G. Shannon, R.M. Shapiro-Albert, B.J. Siemens, X. Simon, J. Smith, T.L. Speri, L. Spiewak, R. Stairs, I.H. Stappers, B.W. Stinebring, D.R. Swiggum, J.K. Taylor, S.R. Theureau, G. Tiburzi, C. Vallisneri, M. van der Wateren, E. Vecchio, A. Verbiest, J.P.W. Vigeland, S.J. Wahl, H. Wang, J.B. Wang, J. Wang, L. Witt, C.A. Zhang, S. Zhu, X.J. The International Pulsar Timing Array second data release: Search for an isotropic Gravitational Wave Background |
title | The International Pulsar Timing Array second data release: Search for an isotropic Gravitational Wave Background |
title_full | The International Pulsar Timing Array second data release: Search for an isotropic Gravitational Wave Background |
title_fullStr | The International Pulsar Timing Array second data release: Search for an isotropic Gravitational Wave Background |
title_full_unstemmed | The International Pulsar Timing Array second data release: Search for an isotropic Gravitational Wave Background |
title_short | The International Pulsar Timing Array second data release: Search for an isotropic Gravitational Wave Background |
title_sort | international pulsar timing array second data release: search for an isotropic gravitational wave background |
topic | astro-ph.IM Astrophysics and Astronomy astro-ph.HE Astrophysics and Astronomy |
url | https://dx.doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stab3418 http://cds.cern.ch/record/2802680 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT antoniadisj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT arzoumanianz theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT babaks theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT bailesm theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT nielsenasbak theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT bakerpt theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT bassacg theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT becsyb theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT berthereaua theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT bonettim theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT braziera theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT brookpr theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT burgaym theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT burkespolaors theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT caballerorn theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT caseyclydeja theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT chalumeaua theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT championdj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT charisim theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT chatterjees theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT chens theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT cognardi theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT cordesjm theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT cornishnj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT crawfordf theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT cromartieht theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT crowterk theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT dais theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT decesarme theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT demorestpb theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT desvignesg theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT dolcht theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT drachlerb theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT falxam theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT ferraraec theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT fiorew theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT fonsecae theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT gairjr theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT garverdanielsn theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT goncharovb theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT gooddc theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT graikoue theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT guillemotl theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT guoyj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT hazbounjs theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT hobbsg theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT huh theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT islok theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT janssengh theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT jenningsrj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT johnsonad theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT jonesml theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT kaiserar theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT kaplandl theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT karuppusamyr theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT keithmj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT kelleylz theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT kerrm theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT keyjs theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT kramerm theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT lammt theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT lambwg theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT laziotjw theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT leekj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT lentatil theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT liuk theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT luoj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT lynchrs theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT lyneag theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT madisondr theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT mainra theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT manchesterrn theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT mcewena theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT mckeejw theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT mclaughlinma theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT mickaligermb theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT mingarellicmf theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT ngc theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT nicedj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT oslowskis theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT parthasarathya theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT pennuccitt theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT pererabbp theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT perrodind theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT petiteaua theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT polns theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT poraykonk theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT possentia theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT ransomsm theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT rayps theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT reardondj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT russellcj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT samajdara theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT sampsonlm theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT sanidass theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT sarkissianjm theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT schmitzk theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT schultl theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT sesanaa theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT shaifullahg theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT shannonrm theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT shapiroalbertbj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT siemensx theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT simonj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT smithtl theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT speril theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT spiewakr theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT stairsih theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT stappersbw theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT stinebringdr theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT swiggumjk theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT taylorsr theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT theureaug theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT tiburzic theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT vallisnerim theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT vanderwaterene theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT vecchioa theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT verbiestjpw theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT vigelandsj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT wahlh theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT wangjb theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT wangj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT wangl theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT wittca theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT zhangs theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT zhuxj theinternationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT antoniadisj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT arzoumanianz internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT babaks internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT bailesm internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT nielsenasbak internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT bakerpt internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT bassacg internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT becsyb internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT berthereaua internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT bonettim internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT braziera internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT brookpr internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT burgaym internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT burkespolaors internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT caballerorn internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT caseyclydeja internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT chalumeaua internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT championdj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT charisim internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT chatterjees internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT chens internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT cognardi internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT cordesjm internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT cornishnj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT crawfordf internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT cromartieht internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT crowterk internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT dais internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT decesarme internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT demorestpb internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT desvignesg internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT dolcht internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT drachlerb internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT falxam internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT ferraraec internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT fiorew internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT fonsecae internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT gairjr internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT garverdanielsn internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT goncharovb internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT gooddc internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT graikoue internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT guillemotl internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT guoyj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT hazbounjs internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT hobbsg internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT huh internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT islok internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT janssengh internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT jenningsrj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT johnsonad internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT jonesml internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT kaiserar internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT kaplandl internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT karuppusamyr internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT keithmj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT kelleylz internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT kerrm internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT keyjs internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT kramerm internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT lammt internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT lambwg internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT laziotjw internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT leekj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT lentatil internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT liuk internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT luoj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT lynchrs internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT lyneag internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT madisondr internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT mainra internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT manchesterrn internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT mcewena internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT mckeejw internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT mclaughlinma internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT mickaligermb internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT mingarellicmf internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT ngc internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT nicedj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT oslowskis internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT parthasarathya internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT pennuccitt internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT pererabbp internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT perrodind internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT petiteaua internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT polns internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT poraykonk internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT possentia internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT ransomsm internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT rayps internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT reardondj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT russellcj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT samajdara internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT sampsonlm internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT sanidass internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT sarkissianjm internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT schmitzk internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT schultl internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT sesanaa internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT shaifullahg internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT shannonrm internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT shapiroalbertbj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT siemensx internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT simonj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT smithtl internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT speril internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT spiewakr internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT stairsih internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT stappersbw internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT stinebringdr internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT swiggumjk internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT taylorsr internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT theureaug internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT tiburzic internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT vallisnerim internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT vanderwaterene internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT vecchioa internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT verbiestjpw internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT vigelandsj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT wahlh internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT wangjb internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT wangj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT wangl internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT wittca internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT zhangs internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground AT zhuxj internationalpulsartimingarrayseconddatareleasesearchforanisotropicgravitationalwavebackground |