THE GENERAL DECLARATION OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY: INCONGRUITY WITH THE CONTROL SYSTEM OF CONSTITUTIONALITY AND PROBLEMS IN THE PROTECTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS

The constitutional amendment of June 6, 2011 implied the modification of the relativity of the judgment of amparo, according to which it only protects the part that obtained the favorable resolution but without the effects about third parties unrelated to the dispute. On the other hand, the implemen...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autor principal: Gómez Marinero, Carlos Martín
Formato: Online Artículo
Lenguaje:spa
Publicado: Universidad Veracruzana 2022
Acceso en línea:https://universosjuridicos.uv.mx/index.php/univerjuridicos/article/view/2636
https://dx.doi.org/10.25009/uj.vi19.2636
_version_ 1780758782360420352
author Gómez Marinero, Carlos Martín
author_facet Gómez Marinero, Carlos Martín
author_sort Gómez Marinero, Carlos Martín
collection Universos Jurídicos. Revista de Derecho Público y diálogo multidisciplinar
description The constitutional amendment of June 6, 2011 implied the modification of the relativity of the judgment of amparo, according to which it only protects the part that obtained the favorable resolution but without the effects about third parties unrelated to the dispute. On the other hand, the implementation of the declaration of unconstitutionality was due to necessary modification of the principle of relativity was deemed unpostponable in order to avoid the violation of constitutional supremacy, equality under the law and other inconveniences. In this paper analyzes the relativity of the judgment of amparo principle from his development and idoneidad; likewise, we propose move to new general declaration of unconstitutionality with two components:  the protection of human rights and his compatibility with the current system of control of constitutionality.
format Online
Article
id oai_universosjuridicos-article-2636
institution Universidad Veracruzana
language spa
publishDate 2022
publisher Universidad Veracruzana
record_format ojs
spelling oai_universosjuridicos-article-26362022-11-16T19:24:38Z THE GENERAL DECLARATION OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY: INCONGRUITY WITH THE CONTROL SYSTEM OF CONSTITUTIONALITY AND PROBLEMS IN THE PROTECTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS LA DECLARATORIA GENERAL DE INCONSTITUCIONALIDAD: DESAFE CON EL SISTEMA DE CONTROL DE CONSTITUCIONALIDAD Y DIFICULTAD PARA LA PROTECCIÓN DE DERECHOS Gómez Marinero, Carlos Martín The constitutional amendment of June 6, 2011 implied the modification of the relativity of the judgment of amparo, according to which it only protects the part that obtained the favorable resolution but without the effects about third parties unrelated to the dispute. On the other hand, the implementation of the declaration of unconstitutionality was due to necessary modification of the principle of relativity was deemed unpostponable in order to avoid the violation of constitutional supremacy, equality under the law and other inconveniences. In this paper analyzes the relativity of the judgment of amparo principle from his development and idoneidad; likewise, we propose move to new general declaration of unconstitutionality with two components:  the protection of human rights and his compatibility with the current system of control of constitutionality. La reforma a la Constitución Política de los Estados Unidos Mexicanos de 6 de junio de 2011 significó la modificación del principio de relatividad de la sentencia que rige en el juicio de amparo, según el cual esta solo protege a la parte que obtuvo la resolución favorable a su interés sin que los efectos pudiesen extenderse en beneficio de terceros ajenos a la controversia. Por otra parte, la implementación de la declaratoria de inconstitucionalidad obedeció a que, en un momento, se estimó inaplazable la modificación del principio de relatividad a fin de evitar la vulneración a la supremacía constitucional e igualdad ante la ley, entre otros inconvenientes. En este sentido, en el presente estudio se analiza el principio de relatividad de la sentencia en el juicio de amparo a partir de su desarrollo e idoneidad; asimismo, se plantea la necesidad de transitar hacia una declaratoria general de inconstitucionalidad en que se considere su función dentro del actual sistema de control de constitucionalidad y el modelo de protección de derechos humanos. Universidad Veracruzana 2022-11-16 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf https://universosjuridicos.uv.mx/index.php/univerjuridicos/article/view/2636 10.25009/uj.vi19.2636 Universos Jurídicos; Núm. 19 (2022): AÑO 10, UNIVERSOS JURÍDICOS # 19, NOVIEMBRE 2021-ABRIL 2022; 74-99 2007-9125 spa https://universosjuridicos.uv.mx/index.php/univerjuridicos/article/view/2636/4518 Derechos de autor 2022 CARLOS MARTÍN GÓMEZ MARINERO https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0
spellingShingle Gómez Marinero, Carlos Martín
THE GENERAL DECLARATION OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY: INCONGRUITY WITH THE CONTROL SYSTEM OF CONSTITUTIONALITY AND PROBLEMS IN THE PROTECTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS
title THE GENERAL DECLARATION OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY: INCONGRUITY WITH THE CONTROL SYSTEM OF CONSTITUTIONALITY AND PROBLEMS IN THE PROTECTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS
title_alt LA DECLARATORIA GENERAL DE INCONSTITUCIONALIDAD: DESAFE CON EL SISTEMA DE CONTROL DE CONSTITUCIONALIDAD Y DIFICULTAD PARA LA PROTECCIÓN DE DERECHOS
title_full THE GENERAL DECLARATION OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY: INCONGRUITY WITH THE CONTROL SYSTEM OF CONSTITUTIONALITY AND PROBLEMS IN THE PROTECTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS
title_fullStr THE GENERAL DECLARATION OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY: INCONGRUITY WITH THE CONTROL SYSTEM OF CONSTITUTIONALITY AND PROBLEMS IN THE PROTECTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS
title_full_unstemmed THE GENERAL DECLARATION OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY: INCONGRUITY WITH THE CONTROL SYSTEM OF CONSTITUTIONALITY AND PROBLEMS IN THE PROTECTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS
title_short THE GENERAL DECLARATION OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY: INCONGRUITY WITH THE CONTROL SYSTEM OF CONSTITUTIONALITY AND PROBLEMS IN THE PROTECTION OF HUMAN RIGHTS
title_sort general declaration of unconstitutionality: incongruity with the control system of constitutionality and problems in the protection of human rights
url https://universosjuridicos.uv.mx/index.php/univerjuridicos/article/view/2636
https://dx.doi.org/10.25009/uj.vi19.2636
work_keys_str_mv AT gomezmarinerocarlosmartin thegeneraldeclarationofunconstitutionalityincongruitywiththecontrolsystemofconstitutionalityandproblemsintheprotectionofhumanrights
AT gomezmarinerocarlosmartin ladeclaratoriageneraldeinconstitucionalidaddesafeconelsistemadecontroldeconstitucionalidadydificultadparalaprotecciondederechos
AT gomezmarinerocarlosmartin generaldeclarationofunconstitutionalityincongruitywiththecontrolsystemofconstitutionalityandproblemsintheprotectionofhumanrights

Ejemplares similares