Extensive fibrosis in mediastinal seminoma is a diagnostic pitfall in small biopsies: two case reports

BACKGROUND: In mediastinal biopsies that show fibrosis, the differential diagnosis includes fibrosing mediastinitis, immunoglobulin G subclass 4-related disease, Hodgkin lymphoma, as well as reactive fibrotic and inflammatory changes adjacent to other processes including neoplasms. CASES DESCRIPTION: We report two cases of incidentally detected mediastinal seminoma that contained extensive areas of paucicellular fibrosis, which precluded accurate preoperative biopsy diagnosis. The fibrosis consisted of mildly inflamed, densely scarred tissue with thin dilated vessels, and was present to a significant extent that is suggestive of spontaneous regression. These features are not currently described in the World Health Organization Classification of Thoracic Tumors. In both patients, needle and open biopsies sampled only the fibrotic areas of the tumors, and the final diagnosis was not achieved until surgical excision was performed. After surgery, both patients received chemotherapy, and were alive without evidence of disease at 3.4 years and 1 year post-operatively, respectively. Tumor fibrosis composed approximately 95% and 50% of each patient’s tumor, respectively. In one of the patients, correlation of the needle biopsy position with the positron emission tomography (PET) scan revealed that the biopsy needle had sampled a non-metabolically active portion of the tumor. CONCLUSIONS: While pathologic spontaneous regression is well-described in gonadal germ cell tumors, it is not well-reported in extragonadal locations. Prospective knowledge of this diagnostic pitfall and targeting PET-avid regions of the tumor may increase the diagnostic yield and help to avoid non-indicated surgical interventions.