Cargando…

An Upper Bound Visualization of Design Trade‐Offs in Adsorbent Materials for Gas Separations: CO(2), N(2), CH(4), H(2), O(2), Xe, Kr, and Ar Adsorbents

The last 20 years have seen many publications investigating porous solids for gas adsorption and separation. The abundance of adsorbent materials (this work identifies 1608 materials for CO(2)/N(2) separation alone) provides a challenge to obtaining a comprehensive view of the field, identifying lea...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Edens, Samuel J., McGrath, Michael J., Guo, Siyu, Du, Zijuan, Zhou, Hemin, Zhong, Lingshan, Shi, Zuhao, Wan, Jieshuo, Bennett, Thomas D., Qiao, Ang, Tao, Haizheng, Li, Neng, Cowan, Matthew G.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10015871/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36646499
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/advs.202206437
_version_ 1784907289273040896
author Edens, Samuel J.
McGrath, Michael J.
Guo, Siyu
Du, Zijuan
Zhou, Hemin
Zhong, Lingshan
Shi, Zuhao
Wan, Jieshuo
Bennett, Thomas D.
Qiao, Ang
Tao, Haizheng
Li, Neng
Cowan, Matthew G.
author_facet Edens, Samuel J.
McGrath, Michael J.
Guo, Siyu
Du, Zijuan
Zhou, Hemin
Zhong, Lingshan
Shi, Zuhao
Wan, Jieshuo
Bennett, Thomas D.
Qiao, Ang
Tao, Haizheng
Li, Neng
Cowan, Matthew G.
author_sort Edens, Samuel J.
collection PubMed
description The last 20 years have seen many publications investigating porous solids for gas adsorption and separation. The abundance of adsorbent materials (this work identifies 1608 materials for CO(2)/N(2) separation alone) provides a challenge to obtaining a comprehensive view of the field, identifying leading design strategies, and selecting materials for process modeling. In 2021, the empirical bound visualization technique was applied, analogous to the Robeson upper bound from membrane science, to alkane/alkene adsorbents. These bound visualizations reveal that adsorbent materials are limited by design trade‐offs between capacity, selectivity, and heat of adsorption. The current work applies the bound visualization to adsorbents for a wider range of gas pairs, including CO(2), N(2), CH(4), H(2), Xe, O(2), and Kr. How this visual tool can identify leading materials and place new material discoveries in the context of the wider field is presented. The most promising current strategies for breaking design trade‐offs are discussed, along with reproducibility of published adsorption literature, and the limitations of bound visualizations. It is hoped that this work inspires new materials that push the bounds of traditional trade‐offs while also considering practical aspects critical to the use of materials on an industrial scale such as cost, stability, and sustainability.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10015871
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-100158712023-03-16 An Upper Bound Visualization of Design Trade‐Offs in Adsorbent Materials for Gas Separations: CO(2), N(2), CH(4), H(2), O(2), Xe, Kr, and Ar Adsorbents Edens, Samuel J. McGrath, Michael J. Guo, Siyu Du, Zijuan Zhou, Hemin Zhong, Lingshan Shi, Zuhao Wan, Jieshuo Bennett, Thomas D. Qiao, Ang Tao, Haizheng Li, Neng Cowan, Matthew G. Adv Sci (Weinh) Reviews The last 20 years have seen many publications investigating porous solids for gas adsorption and separation. The abundance of adsorbent materials (this work identifies 1608 materials for CO(2)/N(2) separation alone) provides a challenge to obtaining a comprehensive view of the field, identifying leading design strategies, and selecting materials for process modeling. In 2021, the empirical bound visualization technique was applied, analogous to the Robeson upper bound from membrane science, to alkane/alkene adsorbents. These bound visualizations reveal that adsorbent materials are limited by design trade‐offs between capacity, selectivity, and heat of adsorption. The current work applies the bound visualization to adsorbents for a wider range of gas pairs, including CO(2), N(2), CH(4), H(2), Xe, O(2), and Kr. How this visual tool can identify leading materials and place new material discoveries in the context of the wider field is presented. The most promising current strategies for breaking design trade‐offs are discussed, along with reproducibility of published adsorption literature, and the limitations of bound visualizations. It is hoped that this work inspires new materials that push the bounds of traditional trade‐offs while also considering practical aspects critical to the use of materials on an industrial scale such as cost, stability, and sustainability. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2023-01-16 /pmc/articles/PMC10015871/ /pubmed/36646499 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/advs.202206437 Text en © 2023 The Authors. Advanced Science published by Wiley‐VCH GmbH https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Reviews
Edens, Samuel J.
McGrath, Michael J.
Guo, Siyu
Du, Zijuan
Zhou, Hemin
Zhong, Lingshan
Shi, Zuhao
Wan, Jieshuo
Bennett, Thomas D.
Qiao, Ang
Tao, Haizheng
Li, Neng
Cowan, Matthew G.
An Upper Bound Visualization of Design Trade‐Offs in Adsorbent Materials for Gas Separations: CO(2), N(2), CH(4), H(2), O(2), Xe, Kr, and Ar Adsorbents
title An Upper Bound Visualization of Design Trade‐Offs in Adsorbent Materials for Gas Separations: CO(2), N(2), CH(4), H(2), O(2), Xe, Kr, and Ar Adsorbents
title_full An Upper Bound Visualization of Design Trade‐Offs in Adsorbent Materials for Gas Separations: CO(2), N(2), CH(4), H(2), O(2), Xe, Kr, and Ar Adsorbents
title_fullStr An Upper Bound Visualization of Design Trade‐Offs in Adsorbent Materials for Gas Separations: CO(2), N(2), CH(4), H(2), O(2), Xe, Kr, and Ar Adsorbents
title_full_unstemmed An Upper Bound Visualization of Design Trade‐Offs in Adsorbent Materials for Gas Separations: CO(2), N(2), CH(4), H(2), O(2), Xe, Kr, and Ar Adsorbents
title_short An Upper Bound Visualization of Design Trade‐Offs in Adsorbent Materials for Gas Separations: CO(2), N(2), CH(4), H(2), O(2), Xe, Kr, and Ar Adsorbents
title_sort upper bound visualization of design trade‐offs in adsorbent materials for gas separations: co(2), n(2), ch(4), h(2), o(2), xe, kr, and ar adsorbents
topic Reviews
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10015871/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36646499
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/advs.202206437
work_keys_str_mv AT edenssamuelj anupperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT mcgrathmichaelj anupperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT guosiyu anupperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT duzijuan anupperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT zhouhemin anupperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT zhonglingshan anupperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT shizuhao anupperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT wanjieshuo anupperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT bennettthomasd anupperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT qiaoang anupperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT taohaizheng anupperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT lineng anupperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT cowanmatthewg anupperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT edenssamuelj upperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT mcgrathmichaelj upperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT guosiyu upperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT duzijuan upperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT zhouhemin upperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT zhonglingshan upperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT shizuhao upperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT wanjieshuo upperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT bennettthomasd upperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT qiaoang upperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT taohaizheng upperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT lineng upperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents
AT cowanmatthewg upperboundvisualizationofdesigntradeoffsinadsorbentmaterialsforgasseparationsco2n2ch4h2o2xekrandaradsorbents