Cargando…
The Health Effects of 72 Hours of Simulated Wind Turbine Infrasound: A Double-Blind Randomized Crossover Study in Noise-Sensitive, Healthy Adults
BACKGROUND: Large electricity-generating wind turbines emit both audible sound and inaudible infrasound at very low frequencies that are outside of the normal human range of hearing. Sufferers of wind turbine syndrome (WTS) have attributed their ill-health and particularly their sleep disturbance to...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Environmental Health Perspectives
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10032045/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36946580 http://dx.doi.org/10.1289/EHP10757 |
_version_ | 1784910715716370432 |
---|---|
author | Marshall, Nathaniel S. Cho, Garry Toelle, Brett G. Tonin, Renzo Bartlett, Delwyn J. D’Rozario, Angela L. Evans, Carla A. Cowie, Christine T. Janev, Oliver Whitfeld, Christopher R. Glozier, Nick Walker, Bruce E. Killick, Roo Welgampola, Miriam S. Phillips, Craig L. Marks, Guy B. Grunstein, Ronald R. |
author_facet | Marshall, Nathaniel S. Cho, Garry Toelle, Brett G. Tonin, Renzo Bartlett, Delwyn J. D’Rozario, Angela L. Evans, Carla A. Cowie, Christine T. Janev, Oliver Whitfeld, Christopher R. Glozier, Nick Walker, Bruce E. Killick, Roo Welgampola, Miriam S. Phillips, Craig L. Marks, Guy B. Grunstein, Ronald R. |
author_sort | Marshall, Nathaniel S. |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: Large electricity-generating wind turbines emit both audible sound and inaudible infrasound at very low frequencies that are outside of the normal human range of hearing. Sufferers of wind turbine syndrome (WTS) have attributed their ill-health and particularly their sleep disturbance to the signature pattern of infrasound. Critics have argued that these symptoms are psychological in origin and are attributable to nocebo effects. OBJECTIVES: We aimed to test the effects of 72 h of infrasound (1.6–20 Hz at a sound level of [Formula: see text] dB pk re [Formula: see text] , simulating a wind turbine infrasound signature) exposure on human physiology, particularly sleep. METHODS: We conducted a randomized double-blind triple-arm crossover laboratory-based study of 72 h exposure with a [Formula: see text] washout conducted in a noise-insulated sleep laboratory in the style of a studio apartment. The exposures were infrasound ([Formula: see text] dB pk), sham infrasound (same speakers not generating infrasound), and traffic noise exposure [active control; at a sound pressure level of 40–50 dB [Formula: see text] and 70 dB [Formula: see text] transient maxima, night (2200 to 0700 hours)]. The following physiological and psychological measures and systems were tested for their sensitivity to infrasound: wake after sleep onset (WASO; primary outcome) and other measures of sleep physiology, wake electroencephalography, WTS symptoms, cardiovascular physiology, and neurobehavioral performance. RESULTS: We randomized 37 noise-sensitive but otherwise healthy adults (18–72 years of age; 51% female) into the study before a COVID19-related public health order forced the study to close. WASO was not affected by infrasound compared with sham infrasound ([Formula: see text] min; 95% CI: [Formula: see text] , 3.88, [Formula: see text]) but was worsened by the active control traffic exposure compared with sham by 6.07 min (95% CI: 0.75, 11.39, [Formula: see text]). Infrasound did not worsen any subjective or objective measures used. DISCUSSION: Our findings did not support the idea that infrasound causes WTS. High level, but inaudible, infrasound did not appear to perturb any physiological or psychological measure tested in these study participants. https://doi.org/10.1289/EHP10757 |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-10032045 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | Environmental Health Perspectives |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-100320452023-03-23 The Health Effects of 72 Hours of Simulated Wind Turbine Infrasound: A Double-Blind Randomized Crossover Study in Noise-Sensitive, Healthy Adults Marshall, Nathaniel S. Cho, Garry Toelle, Brett G. Tonin, Renzo Bartlett, Delwyn J. D’Rozario, Angela L. Evans, Carla A. Cowie, Christine T. Janev, Oliver Whitfeld, Christopher R. Glozier, Nick Walker, Bruce E. Killick, Roo Welgampola, Miriam S. Phillips, Craig L. Marks, Guy B. Grunstein, Ronald R. Environ Health Perspect Research BACKGROUND: Large electricity-generating wind turbines emit both audible sound and inaudible infrasound at very low frequencies that are outside of the normal human range of hearing. Sufferers of wind turbine syndrome (WTS) have attributed their ill-health and particularly their sleep disturbance to the signature pattern of infrasound. Critics have argued that these symptoms are psychological in origin and are attributable to nocebo effects. OBJECTIVES: We aimed to test the effects of 72 h of infrasound (1.6–20 Hz at a sound level of [Formula: see text] dB pk re [Formula: see text] , simulating a wind turbine infrasound signature) exposure on human physiology, particularly sleep. METHODS: We conducted a randomized double-blind triple-arm crossover laboratory-based study of 72 h exposure with a [Formula: see text] washout conducted in a noise-insulated sleep laboratory in the style of a studio apartment. The exposures were infrasound ([Formula: see text] dB pk), sham infrasound (same speakers not generating infrasound), and traffic noise exposure [active control; at a sound pressure level of 40–50 dB [Formula: see text] and 70 dB [Formula: see text] transient maxima, night (2200 to 0700 hours)]. The following physiological and psychological measures and systems were tested for their sensitivity to infrasound: wake after sleep onset (WASO; primary outcome) and other measures of sleep physiology, wake electroencephalography, WTS symptoms, cardiovascular physiology, and neurobehavioral performance. RESULTS: We randomized 37 noise-sensitive but otherwise healthy adults (18–72 years of age; 51% female) into the study before a COVID19-related public health order forced the study to close. WASO was not affected by infrasound compared with sham infrasound ([Formula: see text] min; 95% CI: [Formula: see text] , 3.88, [Formula: see text]) but was worsened by the active control traffic exposure compared with sham by 6.07 min (95% CI: 0.75, 11.39, [Formula: see text]). Infrasound did not worsen any subjective or objective measures used. DISCUSSION: Our findings did not support the idea that infrasound causes WTS. High level, but inaudible, infrasound did not appear to perturb any physiological or psychological measure tested in these study participants. https://doi.org/10.1289/EHP10757 Environmental Health Perspectives 2023-03-22 /pmc/articles/PMC10032045/ /pubmed/36946580 http://dx.doi.org/10.1289/EHP10757 Text en https://ehp.niehs.nih.gov/about-ehp/licenseEHP is an open-access journal published with support from the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, National Institutes of Health. All content is public domain unless otherwise noted. |
spellingShingle | Research Marshall, Nathaniel S. Cho, Garry Toelle, Brett G. Tonin, Renzo Bartlett, Delwyn J. D’Rozario, Angela L. Evans, Carla A. Cowie, Christine T. Janev, Oliver Whitfeld, Christopher R. Glozier, Nick Walker, Bruce E. Killick, Roo Welgampola, Miriam S. Phillips, Craig L. Marks, Guy B. Grunstein, Ronald R. The Health Effects of 72 Hours of Simulated Wind Turbine Infrasound: A Double-Blind Randomized Crossover Study in Noise-Sensitive, Healthy Adults |
title | The Health Effects of 72 Hours of Simulated Wind Turbine Infrasound: A Double-Blind Randomized Crossover Study in Noise-Sensitive, Healthy Adults |
title_full | The Health Effects of 72 Hours of Simulated Wind Turbine Infrasound: A Double-Blind Randomized Crossover Study in Noise-Sensitive, Healthy Adults |
title_fullStr | The Health Effects of 72 Hours of Simulated Wind Turbine Infrasound: A Double-Blind Randomized Crossover Study in Noise-Sensitive, Healthy Adults |
title_full_unstemmed | The Health Effects of 72 Hours of Simulated Wind Turbine Infrasound: A Double-Blind Randomized Crossover Study in Noise-Sensitive, Healthy Adults |
title_short | The Health Effects of 72 Hours of Simulated Wind Turbine Infrasound: A Double-Blind Randomized Crossover Study in Noise-Sensitive, Healthy Adults |
title_sort | health effects of 72 hours of simulated wind turbine infrasound: a double-blind randomized crossover study in noise-sensitive, healthy adults |
topic | Research |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10032045/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36946580 http://dx.doi.org/10.1289/EHP10757 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT marshallnathaniels thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT chogarry thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT toellebrettg thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT toninrenzo thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT bartlettdelwynj thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT drozarioangelal thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT evanscarlaa thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT cowiechristinet thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT janevoliver thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT whitfeldchristopherr thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT gloziernick thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT walkerbrucee thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT killickroo thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT welgampolamiriams thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT phillipscraigl thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT marksguyb thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT grunsteinronaldr thehealtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT marshallnathaniels healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT chogarry healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT toellebrettg healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT toninrenzo healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT bartlettdelwynj healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT drozarioangelal healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT evanscarlaa healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT cowiechristinet healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT janevoliver healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT whitfeldchristopherr healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT gloziernick healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT walkerbrucee healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT killickroo healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT welgampolamiriams healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT phillipscraigl healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT marksguyb healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults AT grunsteinronaldr healtheffectsof72hoursofsimulatedwindturbineinfrasoundadoubleblindrandomizedcrossoverstudyinnoisesensitivehealthyadults |