Cargando…

Field assessment of BinaxNOW antigen tests as COVID-19 treatment entry point at a community testing site in San Francisco during evolving omicron surges

COVID-19 oral treatments require initiation within 5 days of symptom onset. Although antigen tests are less sensitive than RT-PCR, rapid results could facilitate entry to treatment. We collected anterior nasal swabs for BinaxNOW and RT-PCR testing and clinical data at a walk-up, community site in Sa...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Schrom, John, Marquez, Carina, Wang, Chung-Yu, Saxena, Aditi, Mitchell, Anthea M., Ribeiro, Salu, Pilarowski, Genay, Nakamura, Robert, Rojas, Susana, Black, Douglas, Contreras Oseguera, Maria G., Diaz, Edgar Castellanos, Payan, Joselin, Rojas, Susy, Jones, Diane, Tulier-Laiwa, Valerie, Zavaleta, Aleks, Martinez, Jacqueline, Chamie, Gabriel, Glaser, Carol, Jacobson, Kathy, Petersen, Maya, DeRisi, Joseph, Havlir, Diane V.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10038282/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36961855
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0283576
_version_ 1784912045785743360
author Schrom, John
Marquez, Carina
Wang, Chung-Yu
Saxena, Aditi
Mitchell, Anthea M.
Ribeiro, Salu
Pilarowski, Genay
Nakamura, Robert
Rojas, Susana
Black, Douglas
Contreras Oseguera, Maria G.
Diaz, Edgar Castellanos
Payan, Joselin
Rojas, Susy
Jones, Diane
Tulier-Laiwa, Valerie
Zavaleta, Aleks
Martinez, Jacqueline
Chamie, Gabriel
Glaser, Carol
Jacobson, Kathy
Petersen, Maya
DeRisi, Joseph
Havlir, Diane V.
author_facet Schrom, John
Marquez, Carina
Wang, Chung-Yu
Saxena, Aditi
Mitchell, Anthea M.
Ribeiro, Salu
Pilarowski, Genay
Nakamura, Robert
Rojas, Susana
Black, Douglas
Contreras Oseguera, Maria G.
Diaz, Edgar Castellanos
Payan, Joselin
Rojas, Susy
Jones, Diane
Tulier-Laiwa, Valerie
Zavaleta, Aleks
Martinez, Jacqueline
Chamie, Gabriel
Glaser, Carol
Jacobson, Kathy
Petersen, Maya
DeRisi, Joseph
Havlir, Diane V.
author_sort Schrom, John
collection PubMed
description COVID-19 oral treatments require initiation within 5 days of symptom onset. Although antigen tests are less sensitive than RT-PCR, rapid results could facilitate entry to treatment. We collected anterior nasal swabs for BinaxNOW and RT-PCR testing and clinical data at a walk-up, community site in San Francisco, California between January and June 2022. SARS-CoV-2 genomic sequences were generated from positive samples and classified according to subtype and variant. Monte Carlo simulations were conducted to estimate the expected proportion of SARS-CoV-2 infected persons who would have been diagnosed within 5 days of symptom onset using RT-PCR versus BinaxNOW testing. Among 25,309 persons tested with BinaxNOW, 2,799 had concomitant RT-PCR. 1137/2799 (40.6%) were SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR positive. We identified waves of predominant omicron BA.1, BA.2, BA.2.12, BA.4, and BA.5 among 720 sequenced samples. Among 1,137 RT-PCR positive samples, 788/1137 (69%) were detected by BinaxNOW; 94% (669/711) of those with Ct value <30 were detected by BinaxNOW. BinaxNOW detection was consistent over lineages. In analyses to evaluate entry to treatment, BinaxNOW detected 81.7% (361/442, 95% CI: 77–85%) of persons with COVID-19 within 5 days of symptom onset. In comparison, RT-PCR (24-hour turnaround) detected 84.2% (372/442, 95% CI: 80–87%) and RT-PCR (48-hour turnaround) detected 67.0% (296/442, 95% CI: 62–71%) of persons with COVID-19 within 5 days of symptom onset. BinaxNOW detected high viral load from anterior nasal swabs consistently across omicron sublineages emerging between January and June of 2022. Simulations support BinaxNOW as an entry point for COVID-19 treatment in a community field setting.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10038282
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-100382822023-03-25 Field assessment of BinaxNOW antigen tests as COVID-19 treatment entry point at a community testing site in San Francisco during evolving omicron surges Schrom, John Marquez, Carina Wang, Chung-Yu Saxena, Aditi Mitchell, Anthea M. Ribeiro, Salu Pilarowski, Genay Nakamura, Robert Rojas, Susana Black, Douglas Contreras Oseguera, Maria G. Diaz, Edgar Castellanos Payan, Joselin Rojas, Susy Jones, Diane Tulier-Laiwa, Valerie Zavaleta, Aleks Martinez, Jacqueline Chamie, Gabriel Glaser, Carol Jacobson, Kathy Petersen, Maya DeRisi, Joseph Havlir, Diane V. PLoS One Research Article COVID-19 oral treatments require initiation within 5 days of symptom onset. Although antigen tests are less sensitive than RT-PCR, rapid results could facilitate entry to treatment. We collected anterior nasal swabs for BinaxNOW and RT-PCR testing and clinical data at a walk-up, community site in San Francisco, California between January and June 2022. SARS-CoV-2 genomic sequences were generated from positive samples and classified according to subtype and variant. Monte Carlo simulations were conducted to estimate the expected proportion of SARS-CoV-2 infected persons who would have been diagnosed within 5 days of symptom onset using RT-PCR versus BinaxNOW testing. Among 25,309 persons tested with BinaxNOW, 2,799 had concomitant RT-PCR. 1137/2799 (40.6%) were SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR positive. We identified waves of predominant omicron BA.1, BA.2, BA.2.12, BA.4, and BA.5 among 720 sequenced samples. Among 1,137 RT-PCR positive samples, 788/1137 (69%) were detected by BinaxNOW; 94% (669/711) of those with Ct value <30 were detected by BinaxNOW. BinaxNOW detection was consistent over lineages. In analyses to evaluate entry to treatment, BinaxNOW detected 81.7% (361/442, 95% CI: 77–85%) of persons with COVID-19 within 5 days of symptom onset. In comparison, RT-PCR (24-hour turnaround) detected 84.2% (372/442, 95% CI: 80–87%) and RT-PCR (48-hour turnaround) detected 67.0% (296/442, 95% CI: 62–71%) of persons with COVID-19 within 5 days of symptom onset. BinaxNOW detected high viral load from anterior nasal swabs consistently across omicron sublineages emerging between January and June of 2022. Simulations support BinaxNOW as an entry point for COVID-19 treatment in a community field setting. Public Library of Science 2023-03-24 /pmc/articles/PMC10038282/ /pubmed/36961855 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0283576 Text en https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/This is an open access article, free of all copyright, and may be freely reproduced, distributed, transmitted, modified, built upon, or otherwise used by anyone for any lawful purpose. The work is made available under the Creative Commons CC0 (https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) public domain dedication.
spellingShingle Research Article
Schrom, John
Marquez, Carina
Wang, Chung-Yu
Saxena, Aditi
Mitchell, Anthea M.
Ribeiro, Salu
Pilarowski, Genay
Nakamura, Robert
Rojas, Susana
Black, Douglas
Contreras Oseguera, Maria G.
Diaz, Edgar Castellanos
Payan, Joselin
Rojas, Susy
Jones, Diane
Tulier-Laiwa, Valerie
Zavaleta, Aleks
Martinez, Jacqueline
Chamie, Gabriel
Glaser, Carol
Jacobson, Kathy
Petersen, Maya
DeRisi, Joseph
Havlir, Diane V.
Field assessment of BinaxNOW antigen tests as COVID-19 treatment entry point at a community testing site in San Francisco during evolving omicron surges
title Field assessment of BinaxNOW antigen tests as COVID-19 treatment entry point at a community testing site in San Francisco during evolving omicron surges
title_full Field assessment of BinaxNOW antigen tests as COVID-19 treatment entry point at a community testing site in San Francisco during evolving omicron surges
title_fullStr Field assessment of BinaxNOW antigen tests as COVID-19 treatment entry point at a community testing site in San Francisco during evolving omicron surges
title_full_unstemmed Field assessment of BinaxNOW antigen tests as COVID-19 treatment entry point at a community testing site in San Francisco during evolving omicron surges
title_short Field assessment of BinaxNOW antigen tests as COVID-19 treatment entry point at a community testing site in San Francisco during evolving omicron surges
title_sort field assessment of binaxnow antigen tests as covid-19 treatment entry point at a community testing site in san francisco during evolving omicron surges
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10038282/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36961855
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0283576
work_keys_str_mv AT schromjohn fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT marquezcarina fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT wangchungyu fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT saxenaaditi fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT mitchellantheam fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT ribeirosalu fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT pilarowskigenay fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT nakamurarobert fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT rojassusana fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT blackdouglas fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT contrerasosegueramariag fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT diazedgarcastellanos fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT payanjoselin fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT rojassusy fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT jonesdiane fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT tulierlaiwavalerie fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT zavaletaaleks fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT martinezjacqueline fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT chamiegabriel fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT glasercarol fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT jacobsonkathy fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT petersenmaya fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT derisijoseph fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges
AT havlirdianev fieldassessmentofbinaxnowantigentestsascovid19treatmententrypointatacommunitytestingsiteinsanfranciscoduringevolvingomicronsurges