Cargando…
Use of drugs not listed in the National List of Essential Medicines: Findings from a prescription analysis by the Indian Council of Medical Research-Rational Use of Medicines Centres Network in tertiary care hospitals across India
BACKGROUND: The concept of listing essential medicines can lead to improved supply and access, more rational prescribing, and lower costs of drugs. However, these benefits hinge on the prescription of drugs from an Essential Medicines List (EML). Several studies have highlighted the problem of under...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Wolters Kluwer - Medknow
2022
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10043816/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36722552 http://dx.doi.org/10.4103/ijp.ijp_878_21 |
_version_ | 1784913233999560704 |
---|---|
author | Jhaj, Ratinder Banerjee, Aditya Kshirsagar, Nilima Arun Sadasivam, Balakrishnan Chandy, Sujith J Bright, Heber Rew Chugh, Preetha Kaur Tripathi, CD Badyal, Dinesh Kumar Samuel, Madhulika Peter Medhi, Bikash Prakash, Ajay Joshi, Rupa Kamat, Sandhya Tripathi, Raakhi Parmar, Urwashi Indrakumar Dikshit, Harihar Mishra, Hitesh Roy, Sukalyan Saha Trivedi, Niyati Chauhan, Janki Chatterjee, Suparna Bhattacharya, Manjari Desai, Chetna K Sheth, Shamil Gupta, Pooja Roy, Atanu Raveendran, Ramasamy Mathaiyan, Jayanthi Jeevitha, G Kaushal, Sandeep Gupta, Kanchan Jain, Samriti Kaul, Rajni |
author_facet | Jhaj, Ratinder Banerjee, Aditya Kshirsagar, Nilima Arun Sadasivam, Balakrishnan Chandy, Sujith J Bright, Heber Rew Chugh, Preetha Kaur Tripathi, CD Badyal, Dinesh Kumar Samuel, Madhulika Peter Medhi, Bikash Prakash, Ajay Joshi, Rupa Kamat, Sandhya Tripathi, Raakhi Parmar, Urwashi Indrakumar Dikshit, Harihar Mishra, Hitesh Roy, Sukalyan Saha Trivedi, Niyati Chauhan, Janki Chatterjee, Suparna Bhattacharya, Manjari Desai, Chetna K Sheth, Shamil Gupta, Pooja Roy, Atanu Raveendran, Ramasamy Mathaiyan, Jayanthi Jeevitha, G Kaushal, Sandeep Gupta, Kanchan Jain, Samriti Kaul, Rajni |
author_sort | Jhaj, Ratinder |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: The concept of listing essential medicines can lead to improved supply and access, more rational prescribing, and lower costs of drugs. However, these benefits hinge on the prescription of drugs from an Essential Medicines List (EML). Several studies have highlighted the problem of underutilization of EMLs by prescribers. Therefore, as part of prescription research by the Indian Council of Medical Research-Rational Use of Medicines Centres Network, we evaluated the extent of prescription of drugs not listed in the National List of Essential Medicines (NLEM). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Prescriptions of outpatients from participating centers were included after obtaining verbal/written informed consent as approved by the Ethics Committee, and evaluated for prescription of drugs from the NLEM 2015. RESULTS: Analysis of 4838 prescriptions from 13 tertiary health-care institutes revealed that 2677 (55.33%) prescriptions had at least one non-NLEM drug prescribed. In all, 5215 (31.12%) of the total 16,758 drugs prescribed were not in NLEM. Of these, 2722 (16.24%) were single drugs and 2493 (14.88%) were fixed-dose combinations (FDCs). These comprised 700 different drug products – 346 single drugs and 354 FDCs. The average number of non-NLEM drugs prescribed per prescription was 1.08, while the average number of all drugs prescribed was 3.35 per prescription. It was also found that some of the non-NLEM drugs prescribed had the potential to result in increased cost (for example, levocetirizine), increased adverse effects (dextromethorphan), and less effectiveness (losartan) when compared to their NLEM counterparts. Nonavailability of an essential drug (oral hydroxocobalamin) was another important finding of our study. CONCLUSION: This study highlights the extent and pattern of drugs prescribed from outside the NLEM at the tertiary health-care level and the need for training and enhanced awareness among prescribers for greater utilization of the NLEM. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-10043816 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2022 |
publisher | Wolters Kluwer - Medknow |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-100438162023-03-29 Use of drugs not listed in the National List of Essential Medicines: Findings from a prescription analysis by the Indian Council of Medical Research-Rational Use of Medicines Centres Network in tertiary care hospitals across India Jhaj, Ratinder Banerjee, Aditya Kshirsagar, Nilima Arun Sadasivam, Balakrishnan Chandy, Sujith J Bright, Heber Rew Chugh, Preetha Kaur Tripathi, CD Badyal, Dinesh Kumar Samuel, Madhulika Peter Medhi, Bikash Prakash, Ajay Joshi, Rupa Kamat, Sandhya Tripathi, Raakhi Parmar, Urwashi Indrakumar Dikshit, Harihar Mishra, Hitesh Roy, Sukalyan Saha Trivedi, Niyati Chauhan, Janki Chatterjee, Suparna Bhattacharya, Manjari Desai, Chetna K Sheth, Shamil Gupta, Pooja Roy, Atanu Raveendran, Ramasamy Mathaiyan, Jayanthi Jeevitha, G Kaushal, Sandeep Gupta, Kanchan Jain, Samriti Kaul, Rajni Indian J Pharmacol Original Research Article BACKGROUND: The concept of listing essential medicines can lead to improved supply and access, more rational prescribing, and lower costs of drugs. However, these benefits hinge on the prescription of drugs from an Essential Medicines List (EML). Several studies have highlighted the problem of underutilization of EMLs by prescribers. Therefore, as part of prescription research by the Indian Council of Medical Research-Rational Use of Medicines Centres Network, we evaluated the extent of prescription of drugs not listed in the National List of Essential Medicines (NLEM). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Prescriptions of outpatients from participating centers were included after obtaining verbal/written informed consent as approved by the Ethics Committee, and evaluated for prescription of drugs from the NLEM 2015. RESULTS: Analysis of 4838 prescriptions from 13 tertiary health-care institutes revealed that 2677 (55.33%) prescriptions had at least one non-NLEM drug prescribed. In all, 5215 (31.12%) of the total 16,758 drugs prescribed were not in NLEM. Of these, 2722 (16.24%) were single drugs and 2493 (14.88%) were fixed-dose combinations (FDCs). These comprised 700 different drug products – 346 single drugs and 354 FDCs. The average number of non-NLEM drugs prescribed per prescription was 1.08, while the average number of all drugs prescribed was 3.35 per prescription. It was also found that some of the non-NLEM drugs prescribed had the potential to result in increased cost (for example, levocetirizine), increased adverse effects (dextromethorphan), and less effectiveness (losartan) when compared to their NLEM counterparts. Nonavailability of an essential drug (oral hydroxocobalamin) was another important finding of our study. CONCLUSION: This study highlights the extent and pattern of drugs prescribed from outside the NLEM at the tertiary health-care level and the need for training and enhanced awareness among prescribers for greater utilization of the NLEM. Wolters Kluwer - Medknow 2022 2023-01-31 /pmc/articles/PMC10043816/ /pubmed/36722552 http://dx.doi.org/10.4103/ijp.ijp_878_21 Text en Copyright: © 2023 Indian Journal of Pharmacology https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/This is an open access journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms. |
spellingShingle | Original Research Article Jhaj, Ratinder Banerjee, Aditya Kshirsagar, Nilima Arun Sadasivam, Balakrishnan Chandy, Sujith J Bright, Heber Rew Chugh, Preetha Kaur Tripathi, CD Badyal, Dinesh Kumar Samuel, Madhulika Peter Medhi, Bikash Prakash, Ajay Joshi, Rupa Kamat, Sandhya Tripathi, Raakhi Parmar, Urwashi Indrakumar Dikshit, Harihar Mishra, Hitesh Roy, Sukalyan Saha Trivedi, Niyati Chauhan, Janki Chatterjee, Suparna Bhattacharya, Manjari Desai, Chetna K Sheth, Shamil Gupta, Pooja Roy, Atanu Raveendran, Ramasamy Mathaiyan, Jayanthi Jeevitha, G Kaushal, Sandeep Gupta, Kanchan Jain, Samriti Kaul, Rajni Use of drugs not listed in the National List of Essential Medicines: Findings from a prescription analysis by the Indian Council of Medical Research-Rational Use of Medicines Centres Network in tertiary care hospitals across India |
title | Use of drugs not listed in the National List of Essential Medicines: Findings from a prescription analysis by the Indian Council of Medical Research-Rational Use of Medicines Centres Network in tertiary care hospitals across India |
title_full | Use of drugs not listed in the National List of Essential Medicines: Findings from a prescription analysis by the Indian Council of Medical Research-Rational Use of Medicines Centres Network in tertiary care hospitals across India |
title_fullStr | Use of drugs not listed in the National List of Essential Medicines: Findings from a prescription analysis by the Indian Council of Medical Research-Rational Use of Medicines Centres Network in tertiary care hospitals across India |
title_full_unstemmed | Use of drugs not listed in the National List of Essential Medicines: Findings from a prescription analysis by the Indian Council of Medical Research-Rational Use of Medicines Centres Network in tertiary care hospitals across India |
title_short | Use of drugs not listed in the National List of Essential Medicines: Findings from a prescription analysis by the Indian Council of Medical Research-Rational Use of Medicines Centres Network in tertiary care hospitals across India |
title_sort | use of drugs not listed in the national list of essential medicines: findings from a prescription analysis by the indian council of medical research-rational use of medicines centres network in tertiary care hospitals across india |
topic | Original Research Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10043816/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36722552 http://dx.doi.org/10.4103/ijp.ijp_878_21 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT jhajratinder useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT banerjeeaditya useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT kshirsagarnilimaarun useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT sadasivambalakrishnan useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT chandysujithj useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT brightheberrew useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT chughpreethakaur useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT tripathicd useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT badyaldineshkumar useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT samuelmadhulikapeter useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT medhibikash useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT prakashajay useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT joshirupa useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT kamatsandhya useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT tripathiraakhi useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT parmarurwashiindrakumar useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT dikshitharihar useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT mishrahitesh useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT roysukalyansaha useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT trivediniyati useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT chauhanjanki useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT chatterjeesuparna useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT bhattacharyamanjari useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT desaichetnak useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT shethshamil useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT guptapooja useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT royatanu useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT raveendranramasamy useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT mathaiyanjayanthi useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT jeevithag useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT kaushalsandeep useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT guptakanchan useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT jainsamriti useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia AT kaulrajni useofdrugsnotlistedinthenationallistofessentialmedicinesfindingsfromaprescriptionanalysisbytheindiancouncilofmedicalresearchrationaluseofmedicinescentresnetworkintertiarycarehospitalsacrossindia |