A Lesson of Immunosuppression in Renal Transplant: Retreat or Hold?

Background: Aiming at understanding whether there are cases of near-tolerance among long-term surviving kidney transplant recipients in our center, or even operant tolerance can be attempted based on their immune status, we analyzed changes of immune cell subsets and cytokines in various groups, and evaluated immune status of long-term survival recipients. Methods: A real-world, observational, retrospective cohort study was conducted in our hospital. Twenty-eight long-term recipients were selected as study subjects, 15 recent postoperative stable recipients, and 15 healthy subjects as controls. T and B lymphocyte subsets, MDSCs, and cytokines were detected and analyzed. Results: Treg/CD4 T cells, total B and B10 cells in long-term and recent renal recipients were lower than healthy controls (HC). The level of IFN-γ and IL-17A in long-term survival patients was obviously higher than that in recent postoperative stable recipients and HC, while TGF-β1 level was significantly lower in long-term survival group than in short-term postoperative group and HC. Notably, compared with short-term recipients, it has been found that the IL-6 level in both positive and negative HLA groups were obviously lower (all P<0.05). In the long-term survival group, 43% of recipients were positive for urinary protein and 50% were positive for HLA antibody. Conclusion: This “real-world” study validates the findings of real status of long-term survival recipients observed in clinical trials. Contrary to a state of proper tolerance as expected, the group recipients in long-term survival were accompanied by the increased indicators of immune response, while those related to immune tolerance were not significantly increased. Long-term survival recipients with stable renal function may be in an immune equilibrium state where immunosuppression and rejection coexist under the action of low-intensity immune agents. If immunosuppressive agents are reduced or even removed, rejection may occur.