Influence of oversimplifying the head anatomy on cerebral blood flow measurements with diffuse correlation spectroscopy

SIGNIFICANCE: Diffuse correlation spectroscopy (DCS) is an emerging optical modality for non-invasive assessment of an index of regional cerebral blood flow. By the nature of this noninvasive measurement, light must pass through extracerebral layers (i.e., skull, scalp, and cerebral spinal fluid) before detection at the tissue surface. To minimize the contribution of these extracerebral layers to the measured signal, an analytical model has been developed that treats the head as a series of three parallel and infinitely extending slabs (mimicking scalp, skull, and brain). The three-layer model has been shown to provide a significant improvement in cerebral blood flow estimation over the typically used model that treats the head as a bulk homogenous medium. However, the three-layer model is still a gross oversimplification of the head geometry that ignores head curvature, the presence of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), and heterogeneity in layer thickness. AIM: Determine the influence of oversimplifying the head geometry on cerebral blood flow estimated with the three-layer model. APPROACH: Data were simulated with Monte Carlo in a four-layer slab medium and a three-layer sphere medium to isolate the influence of CSF and curvature, respectively. Additionally, simulations were performed on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) head templates spanning a wide-range of ages. Simulated data were fit to both the homogenous and three-layer model for CBF. Finally, to mitigate the errors in potential CBF estimation due to the difficulty in defining layer thickness, we investigated an approach to identify an equivalent, “optimized” thickness via a pressure modulation. RESULTS: Both head curvature and failing to account for CSF lead to significant errors in the estimation of CBF. However, the effect of curvature and CSF on relative changes in CBF is minimal. Further, we found that CBF was underestimated in all MRI-templates, although the magnitude of these underestimations was highly influenced by small variations in the source and detector optode positioning. The optimized thickness obtained from pressure modulation did not improve estimation accuracy of CBF, although it did significantly improve the estimation accuracy of relative changes in CBF. CONCLUSIONS: In sum, these findings suggest that the three-layer model holds promise for improving estimation of relative changes in cerebral blood flow; however, estimations of absolute cerebral blood flow with the approach should be viewed with caution given that it is difficult to account for appreciable sources of error, such as curvature and CSF.