Effectiveness, efficiency, and apical extrusion of 2 rotaries and 2 reciprocating systems in removing filling material during endodontic retreatment. A systematic review

BACKGROUND: This systematic review investigated the effectiveness, efficiency and apical extrusion of the debris of two rotary and two reciprocating single-file systems used for the removal of filling material from straight root canals. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A literature search was performed in the Medline, ISI Web of Science, and Scopus databases for relevant articles matching the keyword search strategy. Effectiveness was determined with studies dealing with the ability of the instruments to remove filling material from root canals. Efficiency was assessed with studies dealing with the time needed to completely remove the root canal filling, and apical extrusion was determined with studies that measured the amount of filling material extruded through the apex. RESULTS: From the 424 articles initially found, 406 were excluded for being non-relevant or not fulfilling the selection criteria. Another 9 articles were excluded after methodology evaluation. Finally, 9 studies were included in the systematic review. CONCLUSIONS: None of the reviewed systems is effective to completely remove the filling materials from straight root canals, and all systems appear to be equally time-efficient, although this variable shows different results. In terms of apical extrusion, the analyzed reciprocating systems extrude more material toward the periapical tissues than the continuous rotation systems. Key words:Systematic review, rotary files, reciprocating files, apical extrusion, endodontic retreatment.