Cargando…

A novel QA phantom based on scintillating fiber ribbons with implementation of 2D dose tomography for small‐field radiotherapy

PURPOSE: To develop a novel instrument for real‐time quality assurance (QA) procedures in radiotherapy. The system implements a scintillation‐based phantom and associated signal acquisition and processing modules and aims to monitor two‐dimensional (2D) dose distributions of small fields. MATERIALS...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Esteves, Josué, Pivot, Odran, Ribouton, Julien, Jalade, Patrice, Zouaoui, Abdelaali, Desbat, Laurent, Rit, Simon, Blanc, Frédéric, Haefeli, Guido, Hopchev, Plamen, Galvan, Jean‐Marc, Lu, Guo‐Neng, Pittet, Patrick
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10087208/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35933612
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/mp.15902
_version_ 1785022294345646080
author Esteves, Josué
Pivot, Odran
Ribouton, Julien
Jalade, Patrice
Zouaoui, Abdelaali
Desbat, Laurent
Rit, Simon
Blanc, Frédéric
Haefeli, Guido
Hopchev, Plamen
Galvan, Jean‐Marc
Lu, Guo‐Neng
Pittet, Patrick
author_facet Esteves, Josué
Pivot, Odran
Ribouton, Julien
Jalade, Patrice
Zouaoui, Abdelaali
Desbat, Laurent
Rit, Simon
Blanc, Frédéric
Haefeli, Guido
Hopchev, Plamen
Galvan, Jean‐Marc
Lu, Guo‐Neng
Pittet, Patrick
author_sort Esteves, Josué
collection PubMed
description PURPOSE: To develop a novel instrument for real‐time quality assurance (QA) procedures in radiotherapy. The system implements a scintillation‐based phantom and associated signal acquisition and processing modules and aims to monitor two‐dimensional (2D) dose distributions of small fields. MATERIALS AND METHODS: For the proposed phantom, we have designed and realized a prototype implementing six high‐resolution tissue‐equivalent scintillating fiber ribbons stacked with in‐plane 30° rotated orientations from each other. Each ribbon output is coupled to a silicon photodiode linear array (with an element pitch of 400 μm) to detect scintillating signal, which represents the projected irradiation profile perpendicular to the ribbon's orientation. For the system providing six acquired projected dose profiles at different orientations, we have developed a two‐step signal processing method to perform 2D dose reconstruction. The first step is to determine irradiation field geometry parameters using a tomographic geometry approach, and the second one is to perform specific penumbra estimation. The QA system prototype has been tested on a Novalis TrueBeam STX with a 6‐MV photon beam for small elliptic fields defined by 5‐ and 10‐mm cone collimators and for 10 × 10‐ and 20 × 10‐mm(2) rectangular fields defined by the micro‐multileaf collimator. Gamma index analysis using EBT3 films as reference has been carried out with tight 2%‐dose‐difference (DD)/700‐μm‐distance‐to‐agreement (DTA) as well as 1%‐DD/1‐mm‐DTA criteria for evaluating the system performances. The testing also includes an evaluation of the proposed two‐step field reconstruction method in comparison with two conventional methods: filtered back projection (FBP) and simultaneous iterative reconstruction technique (SIRT). RESULTS: The reconstructed 2D dose distributions have gamma index pass rates higher than 95% for all the tested configurations as compared with EBT3 film measurements with both 2%‐DD/700‐μm‐DTA and 1%‐DD/1‐mm criteria. 2D global gamma analysis shows that the two‐step and FBP radiation field reconstruction methods systematically outperform the SIRT approach. Moreover, higher gamma index success rates are obtained with the two‐step method than with FBP in the case of the fields defined with the stereotactic cones. CONCLUSIONS: The proposed small‐field QA system makes a use of six water‐equivalent scintillating detectors (fiber ribbons) to acquire dose distribution. The developed two‐step signal processing method performs tomographic 2D dose reconstruction. A system prototype has been built and tested using hospital facilities with small rectangular and elliptic fields. Testing results show 2D reconstructed dose distributions with high accuracy and resolution. Such a system could potentially be an alternative approach to film dosimetry for small‐field QA, which is still widely used as reference in clinical practice.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10087208
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-100872082023-04-12 A novel QA phantom based on scintillating fiber ribbons with implementation of 2D dose tomography for small‐field radiotherapy Esteves, Josué Pivot, Odran Ribouton, Julien Jalade, Patrice Zouaoui, Abdelaali Desbat, Laurent Rit, Simon Blanc, Frédéric Haefeli, Guido Hopchev, Plamen Galvan, Jean‐Marc Lu, Guo‐Neng Pittet, Patrick Med Phys COMPUTATIONAL AND EXPERIMENTAL DOSIMETRY PURPOSE: To develop a novel instrument for real‐time quality assurance (QA) procedures in radiotherapy. The system implements a scintillation‐based phantom and associated signal acquisition and processing modules and aims to monitor two‐dimensional (2D) dose distributions of small fields. MATERIALS AND METHODS: For the proposed phantom, we have designed and realized a prototype implementing six high‐resolution tissue‐equivalent scintillating fiber ribbons stacked with in‐plane 30° rotated orientations from each other. Each ribbon output is coupled to a silicon photodiode linear array (with an element pitch of 400 μm) to detect scintillating signal, which represents the projected irradiation profile perpendicular to the ribbon's orientation. For the system providing six acquired projected dose profiles at different orientations, we have developed a two‐step signal processing method to perform 2D dose reconstruction. The first step is to determine irradiation field geometry parameters using a tomographic geometry approach, and the second one is to perform specific penumbra estimation. The QA system prototype has been tested on a Novalis TrueBeam STX with a 6‐MV photon beam for small elliptic fields defined by 5‐ and 10‐mm cone collimators and for 10 × 10‐ and 20 × 10‐mm(2) rectangular fields defined by the micro‐multileaf collimator. Gamma index analysis using EBT3 films as reference has been carried out with tight 2%‐dose‐difference (DD)/700‐μm‐distance‐to‐agreement (DTA) as well as 1%‐DD/1‐mm‐DTA criteria for evaluating the system performances. The testing also includes an evaluation of the proposed two‐step field reconstruction method in comparison with two conventional methods: filtered back projection (FBP) and simultaneous iterative reconstruction technique (SIRT). RESULTS: The reconstructed 2D dose distributions have gamma index pass rates higher than 95% for all the tested configurations as compared with EBT3 film measurements with both 2%‐DD/700‐μm‐DTA and 1%‐DD/1‐mm criteria. 2D global gamma analysis shows that the two‐step and FBP radiation field reconstruction methods systematically outperform the SIRT approach. Moreover, higher gamma index success rates are obtained with the two‐step method than with FBP in the case of the fields defined with the stereotactic cones. CONCLUSIONS: The proposed small‐field QA system makes a use of six water‐equivalent scintillating detectors (fiber ribbons) to acquire dose distribution. The developed two‐step signal processing method performs tomographic 2D dose reconstruction. A system prototype has been built and tested using hospital facilities with small rectangular and elliptic fields. Testing results show 2D reconstructed dose distributions with high accuracy and resolution. Such a system could potentially be an alternative approach to film dosimetry for small‐field QA, which is still widely used as reference in clinical practice. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2022-09-02 2023-01 /pmc/articles/PMC10087208/ /pubmed/35933612 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/mp.15902 Text en © 2022 The Authors. Medical Physics published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of American Association of Physicists in Medicine. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited and is not used for commercial purposes.
spellingShingle COMPUTATIONAL AND EXPERIMENTAL DOSIMETRY
Esteves, Josué
Pivot, Odran
Ribouton, Julien
Jalade, Patrice
Zouaoui, Abdelaali
Desbat, Laurent
Rit, Simon
Blanc, Frédéric
Haefeli, Guido
Hopchev, Plamen
Galvan, Jean‐Marc
Lu, Guo‐Neng
Pittet, Patrick
A novel QA phantom based on scintillating fiber ribbons with implementation of 2D dose tomography for small‐field radiotherapy
title A novel QA phantom based on scintillating fiber ribbons with implementation of 2D dose tomography for small‐field radiotherapy
title_full A novel QA phantom based on scintillating fiber ribbons with implementation of 2D dose tomography for small‐field radiotherapy
title_fullStr A novel QA phantom based on scintillating fiber ribbons with implementation of 2D dose tomography for small‐field radiotherapy
title_full_unstemmed A novel QA phantom based on scintillating fiber ribbons with implementation of 2D dose tomography for small‐field radiotherapy
title_short A novel QA phantom based on scintillating fiber ribbons with implementation of 2D dose tomography for small‐field radiotherapy
title_sort novel qa phantom based on scintillating fiber ribbons with implementation of 2d dose tomography for small‐field radiotherapy
topic COMPUTATIONAL AND EXPERIMENTAL DOSIMETRY
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10087208/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35933612
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/mp.15902
work_keys_str_mv AT estevesjosue anovelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT pivotodran anovelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT riboutonjulien anovelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT jaladepatrice anovelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT zouaouiabdelaali anovelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT desbatlaurent anovelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT ritsimon anovelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT blancfrederic anovelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT haefeliguido anovelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT hopchevplamen anovelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT galvanjeanmarc anovelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT luguoneng anovelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT pittetpatrick anovelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT estevesjosue novelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT pivotodran novelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT riboutonjulien novelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT jaladepatrice novelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT zouaouiabdelaali novelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT desbatlaurent novelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT ritsimon novelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT blancfrederic novelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT haefeliguido novelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT hopchevplamen novelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT galvanjeanmarc novelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT luguoneng novelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy
AT pittetpatrick novelqaphantombasedonscintillatingfiberribbonswithimplementationof2ddosetomographyforsmallfieldradiotherapy