Cargando…

A Fifteen-Year Survey for Orthopedic Malpractice Claims in the Criminal Court of Rome

The number of legal disputes in the field of medical liability has increased exponentially in the last decades. The aim of this study is to investigate the outcomes of criminal cases against healthcare professionals in Italian criminal courts. The hypothesis is that the majority of cases are dismiss...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Bernardinangeli, Camilla, Giannace, Carolina, Cerciello, Simone, Grassi, Vincenzo M., Lodise, Maria, Vetrugno, Giuseppe, De-Giorgio, Fabio
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10093963/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37046888
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/healthcare11070962
_version_ 1785023723761303552
author Bernardinangeli, Camilla
Giannace, Carolina
Cerciello, Simone
Grassi, Vincenzo M.
Lodise, Maria
Vetrugno, Giuseppe
De-Giorgio, Fabio
author_facet Bernardinangeli, Camilla
Giannace, Carolina
Cerciello, Simone
Grassi, Vincenzo M.
Lodise, Maria
Vetrugno, Giuseppe
De-Giorgio, Fabio
author_sort Bernardinangeli, Camilla
collection PubMed
description The number of legal disputes in the field of medical liability has increased exponentially in the last decades. The aim of this study is to investigate the outcomes of criminal cases against healthcare professionals in Italian criminal courts. The hypothesis is that the majority of cases are dismissed and/or most professionals in these cases are acquitted. This retrospective analysis considers criminal proceedings related to medical professional liability registered with the general register of crime reports of the Public Prosecutor’s Office of Rome in the time interval between 1 January 2000 and 31 December 2015. A total of 4793 criminal proceedings were ultimately identified. Proceedings related to the field of orthopedic trauma were then examined and identified. A complete analysis of 132 of the identified files (76.7%) was carried out. The field with the highest risk of disputes was determined to be the field of trauma. The most frequent complaint was found to arise from unsatisfactory surgical outcomes following elective surgery. The most affected anatomical district is the lower limb in both elective and trauma cases, followed by the upper limb in traumatology and spine cases. The surgeon is the most frequently quoted role of the professional involved. The number of physicians actually convicted (3.93%) and for whom liability was thus recognized, i.e., the existence of a causal link between their conduct and the event that took place was established, appears to be extremely small when compared with the far more significant values related to dismissals (53%) and acquittals (14.2%). Adequate legal reform aiming to reduce this disproportion is necessary to ensure physicians experience a more relaxed daily profession and to restore the original connotations of the doctor–patient relationship with the abolition of defensive medicine.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10093963
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-100939632023-04-13 A Fifteen-Year Survey for Orthopedic Malpractice Claims in the Criminal Court of Rome Bernardinangeli, Camilla Giannace, Carolina Cerciello, Simone Grassi, Vincenzo M. Lodise, Maria Vetrugno, Giuseppe De-Giorgio, Fabio Healthcare (Basel) Article The number of legal disputes in the field of medical liability has increased exponentially in the last decades. The aim of this study is to investigate the outcomes of criminal cases against healthcare professionals in Italian criminal courts. The hypothesis is that the majority of cases are dismissed and/or most professionals in these cases are acquitted. This retrospective analysis considers criminal proceedings related to medical professional liability registered with the general register of crime reports of the Public Prosecutor’s Office of Rome in the time interval between 1 January 2000 and 31 December 2015. A total of 4793 criminal proceedings were ultimately identified. Proceedings related to the field of orthopedic trauma were then examined and identified. A complete analysis of 132 of the identified files (76.7%) was carried out. The field with the highest risk of disputes was determined to be the field of trauma. The most frequent complaint was found to arise from unsatisfactory surgical outcomes following elective surgery. The most affected anatomical district is the lower limb in both elective and trauma cases, followed by the upper limb in traumatology and spine cases. The surgeon is the most frequently quoted role of the professional involved. The number of physicians actually convicted (3.93%) and for whom liability was thus recognized, i.e., the existence of a causal link between their conduct and the event that took place was established, appears to be extremely small when compared with the far more significant values related to dismissals (53%) and acquittals (14.2%). Adequate legal reform aiming to reduce this disproportion is necessary to ensure physicians experience a more relaxed daily profession and to restore the original connotations of the doctor–patient relationship with the abolition of defensive medicine. MDPI 2023-03-28 /pmc/articles/PMC10093963/ /pubmed/37046888 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/healthcare11070962 Text en © 2023 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Bernardinangeli, Camilla
Giannace, Carolina
Cerciello, Simone
Grassi, Vincenzo M.
Lodise, Maria
Vetrugno, Giuseppe
De-Giorgio, Fabio
A Fifteen-Year Survey for Orthopedic Malpractice Claims in the Criminal Court of Rome
title A Fifteen-Year Survey for Orthopedic Malpractice Claims in the Criminal Court of Rome
title_full A Fifteen-Year Survey for Orthopedic Malpractice Claims in the Criminal Court of Rome
title_fullStr A Fifteen-Year Survey for Orthopedic Malpractice Claims in the Criminal Court of Rome
title_full_unstemmed A Fifteen-Year Survey for Orthopedic Malpractice Claims in the Criminal Court of Rome
title_short A Fifteen-Year Survey for Orthopedic Malpractice Claims in the Criminal Court of Rome
title_sort fifteen-year survey for orthopedic malpractice claims in the criminal court of rome
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10093963/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37046888
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/healthcare11070962
work_keys_str_mv AT bernardinangelicamilla afifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome
AT giannacecarolina afifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome
AT cerciellosimone afifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome
AT grassivincenzom afifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome
AT lodisemaria afifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome
AT vetrugnogiuseppe afifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome
AT degiorgiofabio afifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome
AT bernardinangelicamilla fifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome
AT giannacecarolina fifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome
AT cerciellosimone fifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome
AT grassivincenzom fifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome
AT lodisemaria fifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome
AT vetrugnogiuseppe fifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome
AT degiorgiofabio fifteenyearsurveyfororthopedicmalpracticeclaimsinthecriminalcourtofrome