Cargando…
Schistosomiasis screening in non-endemic countries from a cost perspective: Knowledge gaps and research priorities. The case of African long-term residents in a Metropolitan Area, Spain
BACKGROUND: Imported schistosomiasis is an emerging issue in European countries as a result of growing global migration from schistosomiasis-endemic countries, mainly in sub-Saharan Africa. Undetected infection may lead to serious long-term complications with an associated high cost for public healt...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Public Library of Science
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10104311/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37014919 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0011221 |
_version_ | 1785026013975019520 |
---|---|
author | Roure, Sílvia López, Francesc Oliva, Irene Pérez-Quílez, Olga March, Oriol Chamorro, Anna Abad, Elena Muñoz, Israel López Castillo, Amaia Soldevila, Laura Valerio, Lluís Lozano, Manolo Masnou, Helena Oliveira, Mario Cañas, Laura Gibrat, Mireia Chuecos, Marta Montero, Juan José Colmenares, Karen Falguera, Gemma Bonet, Josep Maria Isnard, Mar Prat, Núria Estrada, Oriol Clotet, Bonaventura Vallès, Xavier |
author_facet | Roure, Sílvia López, Francesc Oliva, Irene Pérez-Quílez, Olga March, Oriol Chamorro, Anna Abad, Elena Muñoz, Israel López Castillo, Amaia Soldevila, Laura Valerio, Lluís Lozano, Manolo Masnou, Helena Oliveira, Mario Cañas, Laura Gibrat, Mireia Chuecos, Marta Montero, Juan José Colmenares, Karen Falguera, Gemma Bonet, Josep Maria Isnard, Mar Prat, Núria Estrada, Oriol Clotet, Bonaventura Vallès, Xavier |
author_sort | Roure, Sílvia |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: Imported schistosomiasis is an emerging issue in European countries as a result of growing global migration from schistosomiasis-endemic countries, mainly in sub-Saharan Africa. Undetected infection may lead to serious long-term complications with an associated high cost for public healthcare systems especially among long-term migrants. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate from a health economics perspective the introduction of schistosomiasis screening programs in non-endemic countries with high prevalence of long-term migrants. METHODOLOGY: We calculated the costs associated with three approaches—presumptive treatment, test-and-treat and watchful waiting—under different scenarios of prevalence, treatment efficacy and the cost of care resulting from long-term morbidity. Costs were estimated for our study area, in which there are reported to reside 74,000 individuals who have been exposed to the infection. Additionally, we methodically reviewed the potential factors that could affect the cost/benefit ratio of a schistosomiasis screening program and need therefore to be ascertained. RESULTS: Assuming a 24% prevalence of schistosomiasis in the exposed population and 100% treatment efficacy, the estimated associated cost per infected person of a watchful waiting strategy would be €2,424, that of a presumptive treatment strategy would be €970 and that of a test-and-treat strategy would be €360. The difference in averted costs between test-and-treat and watchful waiting strategies ranges from nearly €60 million in scenarios of high prevalence and treatment efficacy, to a neutral costs ratio when these parameters are halved. However, there are important gaps in our understanding of issues such as the efficacy of treatment in infected long-term residents, the natural history of schistosomiasis in long-term migrants and the feasibility of screening programs. CONCLUSION: Our results support the roll-out of a schistosomiasis screening program based on a test-and-treat strategy from a health economics perspective under the most likely projected scenarios, but important knowledge gaps should be addressed for a more accurate estimations among long-term migrants. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-10104311 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | Public Library of Science |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-101043112023-04-15 Schistosomiasis screening in non-endemic countries from a cost perspective: Knowledge gaps and research priorities. The case of African long-term residents in a Metropolitan Area, Spain Roure, Sílvia López, Francesc Oliva, Irene Pérez-Quílez, Olga March, Oriol Chamorro, Anna Abad, Elena Muñoz, Israel López Castillo, Amaia Soldevila, Laura Valerio, Lluís Lozano, Manolo Masnou, Helena Oliveira, Mario Cañas, Laura Gibrat, Mireia Chuecos, Marta Montero, Juan José Colmenares, Karen Falguera, Gemma Bonet, Josep Maria Isnard, Mar Prat, Núria Estrada, Oriol Clotet, Bonaventura Vallès, Xavier PLoS Negl Trop Dis Research Article BACKGROUND: Imported schistosomiasis is an emerging issue in European countries as a result of growing global migration from schistosomiasis-endemic countries, mainly in sub-Saharan Africa. Undetected infection may lead to serious long-term complications with an associated high cost for public healthcare systems especially among long-term migrants. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate from a health economics perspective the introduction of schistosomiasis screening programs in non-endemic countries with high prevalence of long-term migrants. METHODOLOGY: We calculated the costs associated with three approaches—presumptive treatment, test-and-treat and watchful waiting—under different scenarios of prevalence, treatment efficacy and the cost of care resulting from long-term morbidity. Costs were estimated for our study area, in which there are reported to reside 74,000 individuals who have been exposed to the infection. Additionally, we methodically reviewed the potential factors that could affect the cost/benefit ratio of a schistosomiasis screening program and need therefore to be ascertained. RESULTS: Assuming a 24% prevalence of schistosomiasis in the exposed population and 100% treatment efficacy, the estimated associated cost per infected person of a watchful waiting strategy would be €2,424, that of a presumptive treatment strategy would be €970 and that of a test-and-treat strategy would be €360. The difference in averted costs between test-and-treat and watchful waiting strategies ranges from nearly €60 million in scenarios of high prevalence and treatment efficacy, to a neutral costs ratio when these parameters are halved. However, there are important gaps in our understanding of issues such as the efficacy of treatment in infected long-term residents, the natural history of schistosomiasis in long-term migrants and the feasibility of screening programs. CONCLUSION: Our results support the roll-out of a schistosomiasis screening program based on a test-and-treat strategy from a health economics perspective under the most likely projected scenarios, but important knowledge gaps should be addressed for a more accurate estimations among long-term migrants. Public Library of Science 2023-04-04 /pmc/articles/PMC10104311/ /pubmed/37014919 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0011221 Text en © 2023 Roure et al https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. |
spellingShingle | Research Article Roure, Sílvia López, Francesc Oliva, Irene Pérez-Quílez, Olga March, Oriol Chamorro, Anna Abad, Elena Muñoz, Israel López Castillo, Amaia Soldevila, Laura Valerio, Lluís Lozano, Manolo Masnou, Helena Oliveira, Mario Cañas, Laura Gibrat, Mireia Chuecos, Marta Montero, Juan José Colmenares, Karen Falguera, Gemma Bonet, Josep Maria Isnard, Mar Prat, Núria Estrada, Oriol Clotet, Bonaventura Vallès, Xavier Schistosomiasis screening in non-endemic countries from a cost perspective: Knowledge gaps and research priorities. The case of African long-term residents in a Metropolitan Area, Spain |
title | Schistosomiasis screening in non-endemic countries from a cost perspective: Knowledge gaps and research priorities. The case of African long-term residents in a Metropolitan Area, Spain |
title_full | Schistosomiasis screening in non-endemic countries from a cost perspective: Knowledge gaps and research priorities. The case of African long-term residents in a Metropolitan Area, Spain |
title_fullStr | Schistosomiasis screening in non-endemic countries from a cost perspective: Knowledge gaps and research priorities. The case of African long-term residents in a Metropolitan Area, Spain |
title_full_unstemmed | Schistosomiasis screening in non-endemic countries from a cost perspective: Knowledge gaps and research priorities. The case of African long-term residents in a Metropolitan Area, Spain |
title_short | Schistosomiasis screening in non-endemic countries from a cost perspective: Knowledge gaps and research priorities. The case of African long-term residents in a Metropolitan Area, Spain |
title_sort | schistosomiasis screening in non-endemic countries from a cost perspective: knowledge gaps and research priorities. the case of african long-term residents in a metropolitan area, spain |
topic | Research Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10104311/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37014919 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0011221 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT rouresilvia schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT lopezfrancesc schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT olivairene schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT perezquilezolga schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT marchoriol schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT chamorroanna schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT abadelena schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT munozisraellopez schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT castilloamaia schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT soldevilalaura schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT valeriolluis schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT lozanomanolo schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT masnouhelena schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT oliveiramario schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT canaslaura schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT gibratmireia schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT chuecosmarta schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT monterojuanjose schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT colmenareskaren schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT falgueragemma schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT bonetjosepmaria schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT isnardmar schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT pratnuria schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT estradaoriol schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT clotetbonaventura schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain AT vallesxavier schistosomiasisscreeninginnonendemiccountriesfromacostperspectiveknowledgegapsandresearchprioritiesthecaseofafricanlongtermresidentsinametropolitanareaspain |