Cargando…

The utility of the ‘Arable Weeds and Management in Europe’ database: Challenges and opportunities of combining weed survey data at a European scale

Over the last 30 years, many studies have surveyed weed vegetation on arable land. The ‘Arable Weeds and Management in Europe’ (AWME) database is a collection of 36 of these surveys and the associated management data. Here, we review the challenges associated with combining disparate datasets and ex...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Metcalfe, Helen, Bürger, Jana, von Redwitz, Christoph, Cirujeda, Alicia, Fogliatto, Silvia, Dostatny, Denise F., Gerowitt, Bärbel, Glemnitz, Michael, González‐Andújar, José L., Hernández Plaza, Eva, Izquierdo, Jordi, Kolářová, Michaela, Ņečajeva, Jevgenija, Petit, Sandrine, Pinke, Gyula, Schumacher, Matthias, Ulber, Lena, Vidotto, Francesco, Fried, Guillaume
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10108295/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37082111
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/wre.12562
_version_ 1785026821824184320
author Metcalfe, Helen
Bürger, Jana
von Redwitz, Christoph
Cirujeda, Alicia
Fogliatto, Silvia
Dostatny, Denise F.
Gerowitt, Bärbel
Glemnitz, Michael
González‐Andújar, José L.
Hernández Plaza, Eva
Izquierdo, Jordi
Kolářová, Michaela
Ņečajeva, Jevgenija
Petit, Sandrine
Pinke, Gyula
Schumacher, Matthias
Ulber, Lena
Vidotto, Francesco
Fried, Guillaume
author_facet Metcalfe, Helen
Bürger, Jana
von Redwitz, Christoph
Cirujeda, Alicia
Fogliatto, Silvia
Dostatny, Denise F.
Gerowitt, Bärbel
Glemnitz, Michael
González‐Andújar, José L.
Hernández Plaza, Eva
Izquierdo, Jordi
Kolářová, Michaela
Ņečajeva, Jevgenija
Petit, Sandrine
Pinke, Gyula
Schumacher, Matthias
Ulber, Lena
Vidotto, Francesco
Fried, Guillaume
author_sort Metcalfe, Helen
collection PubMed
description Over the last 30 years, many studies have surveyed weed vegetation on arable land. The ‘Arable Weeds and Management in Europe’ (AWME) database is a collection of 36 of these surveys and the associated management data. Here, we review the challenges associated with combining disparate datasets and explore some of the opportunities for future research that present themselves thanks to the AWME database. We present three case studies repeating previously published national scale analyses with data from a larger spatial extent. The case studies, originally done in France, Germany and the UK, explore various aspects of weed ecology (community composition, management and environmental effects and within‐field distributions) and use a range of statistical techniques (canonical correspondence analysis, redundancy analysis and generalised linear mixed models) to demonstrate the utility and versatility of the AWME database. We demonstrate that (i) the standardisation of abundance data to a common measure, before the analysis of the combined dataset, has little impact on the outcome of the analyses, (ii) the increased extent of environmental or management gradients allows for greater confidence in conclusions and (iii) the main conclusions of analyses done at different spatial scales remain consistent. These case studies demonstrate the utility of a Europe‐wide weed survey database, for clarifying or extending results obtained from studies at smaller scales. This Europe‐wide data collection offers many more opportunities for analysis that could not be addressed in smaller datasets; including questions about the effects of climate change, macro‐ecological and biogeographical issues related to weed diversity as well as the dominance or rarity of specific weeds in Europe.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10108295
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-101082952023-04-18 The utility of the ‘Arable Weeds and Management in Europe’ database: Challenges and opportunities of combining weed survey data at a European scale Metcalfe, Helen Bürger, Jana von Redwitz, Christoph Cirujeda, Alicia Fogliatto, Silvia Dostatny, Denise F. Gerowitt, Bärbel Glemnitz, Michael González‐Andújar, José L. Hernández Plaza, Eva Izquierdo, Jordi Kolářová, Michaela Ņečajeva, Jevgenija Petit, Sandrine Pinke, Gyula Schumacher, Matthias Ulber, Lena Vidotto, Francesco Fried, Guillaume Weed Res Editor's Choice Over the last 30 years, many studies have surveyed weed vegetation on arable land. The ‘Arable Weeds and Management in Europe’ (AWME) database is a collection of 36 of these surveys and the associated management data. Here, we review the challenges associated with combining disparate datasets and explore some of the opportunities for future research that present themselves thanks to the AWME database. We present three case studies repeating previously published national scale analyses with data from a larger spatial extent. The case studies, originally done in France, Germany and the UK, explore various aspects of weed ecology (community composition, management and environmental effects and within‐field distributions) and use a range of statistical techniques (canonical correspondence analysis, redundancy analysis and generalised linear mixed models) to demonstrate the utility and versatility of the AWME database. We demonstrate that (i) the standardisation of abundance data to a common measure, before the analysis of the combined dataset, has little impact on the outcome of the analyses, (ii) the increased extent of environmental or management gradients allows for greater confidence in conclusions and (iii) the main conclusions of analyses done at different spatial scales remain consistent. These case studies demonstrate the utility of a Europe‐wide weed survey database, for clarifying or extending results obtained from studies at smaller scales. This Europe‐wide data collection offers many more opportunities for analysis that could not be addressed in smaller datasets; including questions about the effects of climate change, macro‐ecological and biogeographical issues related to weed diversity as well as the dominance or rarity of specific weeds in Europe. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2022-12-08 2023-02 /pmc/articles/PMC10108295/ /pubmed/37082111 http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/wre.12562 Text en © 2022 The Authors. Weed Research published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of European Weed Research Society. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Editor's Choice
Metcalfe, Helen
Bürger, Jana
von Redwitz, Christoph
Cirujeda, Alicia
Fogliatto, Silvia
Dostatny, Denise F.
Gerowitt, Bärbel
Glemnitz, Michael
González‐Andújar, José L.
Hernández Plaza, Eva
Izquierdo, Jordi
Kolářová, Michaela
Ņečajeva, Jevgenija
Petit, Sandrine
Pinke, Gyula
Schumacher, Matthias
Ulber, Lena
Vidotto, Francesco
Fried, Guillaume
The utility of the ‘Arable Weeds and Management in Europe’ database: Challenges and opportunities of combining weed survey data at a European scale
title The utility of the ‘Arable Weeds and Management in Europe’ database: Challenges and opportunities of combining weed survey data at a European scale
title_full The utility of the ‘Arable Weeds and Management in Europe’ database: Challenges and opportunities of combining weed survey data at a European scale
title_fullStr The utility of the ‘Arable Weeds and Management in Europe’ database: Challenges and opportunities of combining weed survey data at a European scale
title_full_unstemmed The utility of the ‘Arable Weeds and Management in Europe’ database: Challenges and opportunities of combining weed survey data at a European scale
title_short The utility of the ‘Arable Weeds and Management in Europe’ database: Challenges and opportunities of combining weed survey data at a European scale
title_sort utility of the ‘arable weeds and management in europe’ database: challenges and opportunities of combining weed survey data at a european scale
topic Editor's Choice
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10108295/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37082111
http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/wre.12562
work_keys_str_mv AT metcalfehelen theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT burgerjana theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT vonredwitzchristoph theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT cirujedaalicia theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT fogliattosilvia theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT dostatnydenisef theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT gerowittbarbel theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT glemnitzmichael theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT gonzalezandujarjosel theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT hernandezplazaeva theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT izquierdojordi theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT kolarovamichaela theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT necajevajevgenija theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT petitsandrine theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT pinkegyula theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT schumachermatthias theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT ulberlena theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT vidottofrancesco theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT friedguillaume theutilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT metcalfehelen utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT burgerjana utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT vonredwitzchristoph utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT cirujedaalicia utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT fogliattosilvia utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT dostatnydenisef utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT gerowittbarbel utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT glemnitzmichael utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT gonzalezandujarjosel utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT hernandezplazaeva utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT izquierdojordi utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT kolarovamichaela utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT necajevajevgenija utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT petitsandrine utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT pinkegyula utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT schumachermatthias utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT ulberlena utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT vidottofrancesco utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale
AT friedguillaume utilityofthearableweedsandmanagementineuropedatabasechallengesandopportunitiesofcombiningweedsurveydataataeuropeanscale