Cargando…

A Method for Increasing the Robustness of Stable Feature Selection for Biomarker Discovery in Molecular Medicine Developed Using Serum Small Extracellular Vesicle Associated miRNAs and the Barrett’s Oesophagus Disease Spectrum

The biomarker development field within molecular medicine remains limited by the methods that are available for building predictive models. We developed an efficient method for conservatively estimating confidence intervals for the cross validation-derived prediction errors of biomarker models. This...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Mayne, George C., Woodman, Richard J., Watson, David I., Bright, Tim, Gan, Susan, Lord, Reginald V., Bourke, Michael J., Levert-Mignon, Angelique, Bastian, Isabell, Irvine, Tanya, Schloithe, Ann, Martin, Marian, Sheehan-Hennessy, Lorraine, Hussey, Damian J.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10139127/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37108236
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ijms24087068
_version_ 1785032871836123136
author Mayne, George C.
Woodman, Richard J.
Watson, David I.
Bright, Tim
Gan, Susan
Lord, Reginald V.
Bourke, Michael J.
Levert-Mignon, Angelique
Bastian, Isabell
Irvine, Tanya
Schloithe, Ann
Martin, Marian
Sheehan-Hennessy, Lorraine
Hussey, Damian J.
author_facet Mayne, George C.
Woodman, Richard J.
Watson, David I.
Bright, Tim
Gan, Susan
Lord, Reginald V.
Bourke, Michael J.
Levert-Mignon, Angelique
Bastian, Isabell
Irvine, Tanya
Schloithe, Ann
Martin, Marian
Sheehan-Hennessy, Lorraine
Hussey, Damian J.
author_sort Mayne, George C.
collection PubMed
description The biomarker development field within molecular medicine remains limited by the methods that are available for building predictive models. We developed an efficient method for conservatively estimating confidence intervals for the cross validation-derived prediction errors of biomarker models. This new method was investigated for its ability to improve the capacity of our previously developed method, StaVarSel, for selecting stable biomarkers. Compared with the standard cross validation method, StaVarSel markedly improved the estimated generalisable predictive capacity of serum miRNA biomarkers for the detection of disease states that are at increased risk of progressing to oesophageal adenocarcinoma. The incorporation of our new method for conservatively estimating confidence intervals into StaVarSel resulted in the selection of less complex models with increased stability and improved or similar predictive capacities. The methods developed in this study have the potential to improve progress from biomarker discovery to biomarker driven translational research.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10139127
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-101391272023-04-28 A Method for Increasing the Robustness of Stable Feature Selection for Biomarker Discovery in Molecular Medicine Developed Using Serum Small Extracellular Vesicle Associated miRNAs and the Barrett’s Oesophagus Disease Spectrum Mayne, George C. Woodman, Richard J. Watson, David I. Bright, Tim Gan, Susan Lord, Reginald V. Bourke, Michael J. Levert-Mignon, Angelique Bastian, Isabell Irvine, Tanya Schloithe, Ann Martin, Marian Sheehan-Hennessy, Lorraine Hussey, Damian J. Int J Mol Sci Article The biomarker development field within molecular medicine remains limited by the methods that are available for building predictive models. We developed an efficient method for conservatively estimating confidence intervals for the cross validation-derived prediction errors of biomarker models. This new method was investigated for its ability to improve the capacity of our previously developed method, StaVarSel, for selecting stable biomarkers. Compared with the standard cross validation method, StaVarSel markedly improved the estimated generalisable predictive capacity of serum miRNA biomarkers for the detection of disease states that are at increased risk of progressing to oesophageal adenocarcinoma. The incorporation of our new method for conservatively estimating confidence intervals into StaVarSel resulted in the selection of less complex models with increased stability and improved or similar predictive capacities. The methods developed in this study have the potential to improve progress from biomarker discovery to biomarker driven translational research. MDPI 2023-04-11 /pmc/articles/PMC10139127/ /pubmed/37108236 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ijms24087068 Text en © 2023 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Mayne, George C.
Woodman, Richard J.
Watson, David I.
Bright, Tim
Gan, Susan
Lord, Reginald V.
Bourke, Michael J.
Levert-Mignon, Angelique
Bastian, Isabell
Irvine, Tanya
Schloithe, Ann
Martin, Marian
Sheehan-Hennessy, Lorraine
Hussey, Damian J.
A Method for Increasing the Robustness of Stable Feature Selection for Biomarker Discovery in Molecular Medicine Developed Using Serum Small Extracellular Vesicle Associated miRNAs and the Barrett’s Oesophagus Disease Spectrum
title A Method for Increasing the Robustness of Stable Feature Selection for Biomarker Discovery in Molecular Medicine Developed Using Serum Small Extracellular Vesicle Associated miRNAs and the Barrett’s Oesophagus Disease Spectrum
title_full A Method for Increasing the Robustness of Stable Feature Selection for Biomarker Discovery in Molecular Medicine Developed Using Serum Small Extracellular Vesicle Associated miRNAs and the Barrett’s Oesophagus Disease Spectrum
title_fullStr A Method for Increasing the Robustness of Stable Feature Selection for Biomarker Discovery in Molecular Medicine Developed Using Serum Small Extracellular Vesicle Associated miRNAs and the Barrett’s Oesophagus Disease Spectrum
title_full_unstemmed A Method for Increasing the Robustness of Stable Feature Selection for Biomarker Discovery in Molecular Medicine Developed Using Serum Small Extracellular Vesicle Associated miRNAs and the Barrett’s Oesophagus Disease Spectrum
title_short A Method for Increasing the Robustness of Stable Feature Selection for Biomarker Discovery in Molecular Medicine Developed Using Serum Small Extracellular Vesicle Associated miRNAs and the Barrett’s Oesophagus Disease Spectrum
title_sort method for increasing the robustness of stable feature selection for biomarker discovery in molecular medicine developed using serum small extracellular vesicle associated mirnas and the barrett’s oesophagus disease spectrum
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10139127/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37108236
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ijms24087068
work_keys_str_mv AT maynegeorgec amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT woodmanrichardj amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT watsondavidi amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT brighttim amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT gansusan amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT lordreginaldv amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT bourkemichaelj amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT levertmignonangelique amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT bastianisabell amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT irvinetanya amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT schloitheann amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT martinmarian amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT sheehanhennessylorraine amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT husseydamianj amethodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT maynegeorgec methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT woodmanrichardj methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT watsondavidi methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT brighttim methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT gansusan methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT lordreginaldv methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT bourkemichaelj methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT levertmignonangelique methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT bastianisabell methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT irvinetanya methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT schloitheann methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT martinmarian methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT sheehanhennessylorraine methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum
AT husseydamianj methodforincreasingtherobustnessofstablefeatureselectionforbiomarkerdiscoveryinmolecularmedicinedevelopedusingserumsmallextracellularvesicleassociatedmirnasandthebarrettsoesophagusdiseasespectrum