Cargando…
Towards a robust and compact deep learning system for primary detection of early Barrett’s neoplasia: Initial image‐based results of training on a multi‐center retrospectively collected data set
INTRODUCTION: Endoscopic detection of early neoplasia in Barrett's esophagus is difficult. Computer Aided Detection (CADe) systems may assist in neoplasia detection. The aim of this study was to report the first steps in the development of a CADe system for Barrett's neoplasia and to evalu...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
John Wiley and Sons Inc.
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10165317/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37095718 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ueg2.12363 |
_version_ | 1785038244416585728 |
---|---|
author | Fockens, Kiki N. Jukema, Jelmer B. Boers, Tim Jong, Martijn R. van der Putten, Joost A. Pouw, Roos E. Weusten, Bas L. A. M. Alvarez Herrero, Lorenza Houben, Martin H. M. G. Nagengast, Wouter B. Westerhof, Jessie Alkhalaf, Alaa Mallant, Rosalie Ragunath, Krish Seewald, Stefan Elbe, Peter Barret, Maximilien Ortiz Fernández‐Sordo, Jacobo Pech, Oliver Beyna, Torsten van der Sommen, Fons de With, Peter H. de Groof, A. Jeroen Bergman, Jacques J. |
author_facet | Fockens, Kiki N. Jukema, Jelmer B. Boers, Tim Jong, Martijn R. van der Putten, Joost A. Pouw, Roos E. Weusten, Bas L. A. M. Alvarez Herrero, Lorenza Houben, Martin H. M. G. Nagengast, Wouter B. Westerhof, Jessie Alkhalaf, Alaa Mallant, Rosalie Ragunath, Krish Seewald, Stefan Elbe, Peter Barret, Maximilien Ortiz Fernández‐Sordo, Jacobo Pech, Oliver Beyna, Torsten van der Sommen, Fons de With, Peter H. de Groof, A. Jeroen Bergman, Jacques J. |
author_sort | Fockens, Kiki N. |
collection | PubMed |
description | INTRODUCTION: Endoscopic detection of early neoplasia in Barrett's esophagus is difficult. Computer Aided Detection (CADe) systems may assist in neoplasia detection. The aim of this study was to report the first steps in the development of a CADe system for Barrett's neoplasia and to evaluate its performance when compared with endoscopists. METHODS: This CADe system was developed by a consortium, consisting of the Amsterdam University Medical Center, Eindhoven University of Technology, and 15 international hospitals. After pretraining, the system was trained and validated using 1.713 neoplastic (564 patients) and 2.707 non‐dysplastic Barrett's esophagus (NDBE; 665 patients) images. Neoplastic lesions were delineated by 14 experts. The performance of the CADe system was tested on three independent test sets. Test set 1 (50 neoplastic and 150 NDBE images) contained subtle neoplastic lesions representing challenging cases and was benchmarked by 52 general endoscopists. Test set 2 (50 neoplastic and 50 NDBE images) contained a heterogeneous case‐mix of neoplastic lesions, representing distribution in clinical practice. Test set 3 (50 neoplastic and 150 NDBE images) contained prospectively collected imagery. The main outcome was correct classification of the images in terms of sensitivity. RESULTS: The sensitivity of the CADe system on test set 1 was 84%. For general endoscopists, sensitivity was 63%, corresponding to a neoplasia miss‐rate of one‐third of neoplastic lesions and a potential relative increase in neoplasia detection of 33% for CADe‐assisted detection. The sensitivity of the CADe system on test sets 2 and 3 was 100% and 88%, respectively. The specificity of the CADe system varied for the three test sets between 64% and 66%. CONCLUSION: This study describes the first steps towards the establishment of an unprecedented data infrastructure for using machine learning to improve the endoscopic detection of Barrett's neoplasia. The CADe system detected neoplasia reliably and outperformed a large group of endoscopists in terms of sensitivity. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-10165317 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | John Wiley and Sons Inc. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-101653172023-05-09 Towards a robust and compact deep learning system for primary detection of early Barrett’s neoplasia: Initial image‐based results of training on a multi‐center retrospectively collected data set Fockens, Kiki N. Jukema, Jelmer B. Boers, Tim Jong, Martijn R. van der Putten, Joost A. Pouw, Roos E. Weusten, Bas L. A. M. Alvarez Herrero, Lorenza Houben, Martin H. M. G. Nagengast, Wouter B. Westerhof, Jessie Alkhalaf, Alaa Mallant, Rosalie Ragunath, Krish Seewald, Stefan Elbe, Peter Barret, Maximilien Ortiz Fernández‐Sordo, Jacobo Pech, Oliver Beyna, Torsten van der Sommen, Fons de With, Peter H. de Groof, A. Jeroen Bergman, Jacques J. United European Gastroenterol J Endoscopy INTRODUCTION: Endoscopic detection of early neoplasia in Barrett's esophagus is difficult. Computer Aided Detection (CADe) systems may assist in neoplasia detection. The aim of this study was to report the first steps in the development of a CADe system for Barrett's neoplasia and to evaluate its performance when compared with endoscopists. METHODS: This CADe system was developed by a consortium, consisting of the Amsterdam University Medical Center, Eindhoven University of Technology, and 15 international hospitals. After pretraining, the system was trained and validated using 1.713 neoplastic (564 patients) and 2.707 non‐dysplastic Barrett's esophagus (NDBE; 665 patients) images. Neoplastic lesions were delineated by 14 experts. The performance of the CADe system was tested on three independent test sets. Test set 1 (50 neoplastic and 150 NDBE images) contained subtle neoplastic lesions representing challenging cases and was benchmarked by 52 general endoscopists. Test set 2 (50 neoplastic and 50 NDBE images) contained a heterogeneous case‐mix of neoplastic lesions, representing distribution in clinical practice. Test set 3 (50 neoplastic and 150 NDBE images) contained prospectively collected imagery. The main outcome was correct classification of the images in terms of sensitivity. RESULTS: The sensitivity of the CADe system on test set 1 was 84%. For general endoscopists, sensitivity was 63%, corresponding to a neoplasia miss‐rate of one‐third of neoplastic lesions and a potential relative increase in neoplasia detection of 33% for CADe‐assisted detection. The sensitivity of the CADe system on test sets 2 and 3 was 100% and 88%, respectively. The specificity of the CADe system varied for the three test sets between 64% and 66%. CONCLUSION: This study describes the first steps towards the establishment of an unprecedented data infrastructure for using machine learning to improve the endoscopic detection of Barrett's neoplasia. The CADe system detected neoplasia reliably and outperformed a large group of endoscopists in terms of sensitivity. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2023-04-24 /pmc/articles/PMC10165317/ /pubmed/37095718 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ueg2.12363 Text en © 2023 The Authors. United European Gastroenterology Journal published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of United European Gastroenterology. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) License, which permits use and distribution in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non‐commercial and no modifications or adaptations are made. |
spellingShingle | Endoscopy Fockens, Kiki N. Jukema, Jelmer B. Boers, Tim Jong, Martijn R. van der Putten, Joost A. Pouw, Roos E. Weusten, Bas L. A. M. Alvarez Herrero, Lorenza Houben, Martin H. M. G. Nagengast, Wouter B. Westerhof, Jessie Alkhalaf, Alaa Mallant, Rosalie Ragunath, Krish Seewald, Stefan Elbe, Peter Barret, Maximilien Ortiz Fernández‐Sordo, Jacobo Pech, Oliver Beyna, Torsten van der Sommen, Fons de With, Peter H. de Groof, A. Jeroen Bergman, Jacques J. Towards a robust and compact deep learning system for primary detection of early Barrett’s neoplasia: Initial image‐based results of training on a multi‐center retrospectively collected data set |
title | Towards a robust and compact deep learning system for primary detection of early Barrett’s neoplasia: Initial image‐based results of training on a multi‐center retrospectively collected data set |
title_full | Towards a robust and compact deep learning system for primary detection of early Barrett’s neoplasia: Initial image‐based results of training on a multi‐center retrospectively collected data set |
title_fullStr | Towards a robust and compact deep learning system for primary detection of early Barrett’s neoplasia: Initial image‐based results of training on a multi‐center retrospectively collected data set |
title_full_unstemmed | Towards a robust and compact deep learning system for primary detection of early Barrett’s neoplasia: Initial image‐based results of training on a multi‐center retrospectively collected data set |
title_short | Towards a robust and compact deep learning system for primary detection of early Barrett’s neoplasia: Initial image‐based results of training on a multi‐center retrospectively collected data set |
title_sort | towards a robust and compact deep learning system for primary detection of early barrett’s neoplasia: initial image‐based results of training on a multi‐center retrospectively collected data set |
topic | Endoscopy |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10165317/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37095718 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ueg2.12363 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT fockenskikin towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT jukemajelmerb towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT boerstim towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT jongmartijnr towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT vanderputtenjoosta towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT pouwroose towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT weustenbaslam towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT alvarezherrerolorenza towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT houbenmartinhmg towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT nagengastwouterb towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT westerhofjessie towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT alkhalafalaa towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT mallantrosalie towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT ragunathkrish towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT seewaldstefan towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT elbepeter towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT barretmaximilien towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT ortizfernandezsordojacobo towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT pecholiver towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT beynatorsten towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT vandersommenfons towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT dewithpeterh towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT degroofajeroen towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset AT bergmanjacquesj towardsarobustandcompactdeeplearningsystemforprimarydetectionofearlybarrettsneoplasiainitialimagebasedresultsoftrainingonamulticenterretrospectivelycollecteddataset |