Cargando…

An agile, data‐driven approach for target selection in rTMS therapy for anxiety symptoms: Proof of concept and preliminary data for two novel targets

INTRODUCTION: Data‐driven approaches to transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) might yield more consistent and symptom‐specific results based on individualized functional connectivity analyses compared to previous traditional approaches due to more precise targeting. We provide a proof of concept f...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Young, Isabella M., Taylor, Hugh M., Nicholas, Peter J., Mackenzie, Alana, Tanglay, Onur, Dadario, Nicholas B., Osipowicz, Karol, Davis, Ethan, Doyen, Stephane, Teo, Charles, Sughrue, Michael E.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10175990/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36949668
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/brb3.2914
_version_ 1785040336880402432
author Young, Isabella M.
Taylor, Hugh M.
Nicholas, Peter J.
Mackenzie, Alana
Tanglay, Onur
Dadario, Nicholas B.
Osipowicz, Karol
Davis, Ethan
Doyen, Stephane
Teo, Charles
Sughrue, Michael E.
author_facet Young, Isabella M.
Taylor, Hugh M.
Nicholas, Peter J.
Mackenzie, Alana
Tanglay, Onur
Dadario, Nicholas B.
Osipowicz, Karol
Davis, Ethan
Doyen, Stephane
Teo, Charles
Sughrue, Michael E.
author_sort Young, Isabella M.
collection PubMed
description INTRODUCTION: Data‐driven approaches to transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) might yield more consistent and symptom‐specific results based on individualized functional connectivity analyses compared to previous traditional approaches due to more precise targeting. We provide a proof of concept for an agile target selection paradigm based on using connectomic methods that can be used to detect patient‐specific abnormal functional connectivity, guide treatment aimed at the most abnormal regions, and optimize the rapid development of new hypotheses for future study. METHODS: We used the resting‐state functional MRI data of 28 patients with medically refractory generalized anxiety disorder to perform agile target selection based on abnormal functional connectivity patterns between the Default Mode Network (DMN) and Central Executive Network (CEN). The most abnormal areas of connectivity within these regions were selected for subsequent targeted TMS treatment by a machine learning based on an anomalous functional connectivity detection matrix. Areas with mostly hyperconnectivity were stimulated with continuous theta burst stimulation and the converse with intermittent theta burst stimulation. An image‐guided accelerated theta burst stimulation paradigm was used for treatment. RESULTS: Areas 8Av and PGs demonstrated consistent abnormalities, particularly in the left hemisphere. Significant improvements were demonstrated in anxiety symptoms, and few, minor complications were reported (fatigue (n = 2) and headache (n = 1)). CONCLUSIONS: Our study suggests that a left‐lateralized DMN is likely the primary functional network disturbed in anxiety‐related disorders, which can be improved by identifying and targeting abnormal regions with a rapid, data‐driven, agile aTBS treatment on an individualized basis.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10175990
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-101759902023-05-13 An agile, data‐driven approach for target selection in rTMS therapy for anxiety symptoms: Proof of concept and preliminary data for two novel targets Young, Isabella M. Taylor, Hugh M. Nicholas, Peter J. Mackenzie, Alana Tanglay, Onur Dadario, Nicholas B. Osipowicz, Karol Davis, Ethan Doyen, Stephane Teo, Charles Sughrue, Michael E. Brain Behav Original Articles INTRODUCTION: Data‐driven approaches to transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) might yield more consistent and symptom‐specific results based on individualized functional connectivity analyses compared to previous traditional approaches due to more precise targeting. We provide a proof of concept for an agile target selection paradigm based on using connectomic methods that can be used to detect patient‐specific abnormal functional connectivity, guide treatment aimed at the most abnormal regions, and optimize the rapid development of new hypotheses for future study. METHODS: We used the resting‐state functional MRI data of 28 patients with medically refractory generalized anxiety disorder to perform agile target selection based on abnormal functional connectivity patterns between the Default Mode Network (DMN) and Central Executive Network (CEN). The most abnormal areas of connectivity within these regions were selected for subsequent targeted TMS treatment by a machine learning based on an anomalous functional connectivity detection matrix. Areas with mostly hyperconnectivity were stimulated with continuous theta burst stimulation and the converse with intermittent theta burst stimulation. An image‐guided accelerated theta burst stimulation paradigm was used for treatment. RESULTS: Areas 8Av and PGs demonstrated consistent abnormalities, particularly in the left hemisphere. Significant improvements were demonstrated in anxiety symptoms, and few, minor complications were reported (fatigue (n = 2) and headache (n = 1)). CONCLUSIONS: Our study suggests that a left‐lateralized DMN is likely the primary functional network disturbed in anxiety‐related disorders, which can be improved by identifying and targeting abnormal regions with a rapid, data‐driven, agile aTBS treatment on an individualized basis. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2023-03-22 /pmc/articles/PMC10175990/ /pubmed/36949668 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/brb3.2914 Text en © 2023 The Authors. Brain and Behavior published by Wiley Periodicals LLC. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Original Articles
Young, Isabella M.
Taylor, Hugh M.
Nicholas, Peter J.
Mackenzie, Alana
Tanglay, Onur
Dadario, Nicholas B.
Osipowicz, Karol
Davis, Ethan
Doyen, Stephane
Teo, Charles
Sughrue, Michael E.
An agile, data‐driven approach for target selection in rTMS therapy for anxiety symptoms: Proof of concept and preliminary data for two novel targets
title An agile, data‐driven approach for target selection in rTMS therapy for anxiety symptoms: Proof of concept and preliminary data for two novel targets
title_full An agile, data‐driven approach for target selection in rTMS therapy for anxiety symptoms: Proof of concept and preliminary data for two novel targets
title_fullStr An agile, data‐driven approach for target selection in rTMS therapy for anxiety symptoms: Proof of concept and preliminary data for two novel targets
title_full_unstemmed An agile, data‐driven approach for target selection in rTMS therapy for anxiety symptoms: Proof of concept and preliminary data for two novel targets
title_short An agile, data‐driven approach for target selection in rTMS therapy for anxiety symptoms: Proof of concept and preliminary data for two novel targets
title_sort agile, data‐driven approach for target selection in rtms therapy for anxiety symptoms: proof of concept and preliminary data for two novel targets
topic Original Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10175990/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36949668
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/brb3.2914
work_keys_str_mv AT youngisabellam anagiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT taylorhughm anagiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT nicholaspeterj anagiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT mackenziealana anagiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT tanglayonur anagiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT dadarionicholasb anagiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT osipowiczkarol anagiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT davisethan anagiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT doyenstephane anagiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT teocharles anagiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT sughruemichaele anagiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT youngisabellam agiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT taylorhughm agiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT nicholaspeterj agiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT mackenziealana agiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT tanglayonur agiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT dadarionicholasb agiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT osipowiczkarol agiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT davisethan agiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT doyenstephane agiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT teocharles agiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets
AT sughruemichaele agiledatadrivenapproachfortargetselectioninrtmstherapyforanxietysymptomsproofofconceptandpreliminarydatafortwonoveltargets