Ensemble machine learning methods in screening electronic health records: A scoping review

BACKGROUND: Electronic health records provide the opportunity to identify undiagnosed individuals likely to have a given disease using machine learning techniques, and who could then benefit from more medical screening and case finding, reducing the number needed to screen with convenience and healthcare cost savings. Ensemble machine learning models combining multiple prediction estimates into one are often said to provide better predictive performances than non-ensemble models. Yet, to our knowledge, no literature review summarises the use and performances of different types of ensemble machine learning models in the context of medical pre-screening. METHOD: We aimed to conduct a scoping review of the literature reporting the derivation of ensemble machine learning models for screening of electronic health records. We searched EMBASE and MEDLINE databases across all years applying a formal search strategy using terms related to medical screening, electronic health records and machine learning. Data were collected, analysed, and reported in accordance with the PRISMA scoping review guideline. RESULTS: A total of 3355 articles were retrieved, of which 145 articles met our inclusion criteria and were included in this study. Ensemble machine learning models were increasingly employed across several medical specialties and often outperformed non-ensemble approaches. Ensemble machine learning models with complex combination strategies and heterogeneous classifiers often outperformed other types of ensemble machine learning models but were also less used. Ensemble machine learning models methodologies, processing steps and data sources were often not clearly described. CONCLUSIONS: Our work highlights the importance of deriving and comparing the performances of different types of ensemble machine learning models when screening electronic health records and underscores the need for more comprehensive reporting of machine learning methodologies employed in clinical research.