Cargando…
A Critical Issue in Lung Cancer Cytology and Small Biopsies: DNA and RNA Extraction from Archival Stained Slides for Biomarker Detection through Real Time PCR and NGS—The Experience in Pathological Anatomy Unit
The handling of biomaterials is crucial for precision medicine in advanced-stage lung patients with only cytology or small biopsies available. The main purpose of the study was to evaluate the quantity and quality of nucleic acids extracted from mixed stained slides (MSSs), including H&E, IHC an...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
MDPI
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10178763/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37175028 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/diagnostics13091637 |
_version_ | 1785040938396024832 |
---|---|
author | Zannini, Giuseppa Tedesco, Ilaria Cozzolino, Immacolata Montella, Marco Clery, Eduardo Della Corte, Carminia Maria Morgillo, Floriana Accardo, Marina Franco, Renato Zito Marino, Federica |
author_facet | Zannini, Giuseppa Tedesco, Ilaria Cozzolino, Immacolata Montella, Marco Clery, Eduardo Della Corte, Carminia Maria Morgillo, Floriana Accardo, Marina Franco, Renato Zito Marino, Federica |
author_sort | Zannini, Giuseppa |
collection | PubMed |
description | The handling of biomaterials is crucial for precision medicine in advanced-stage lung patients with only cytology or small biopsies available. The main purpose of the study was to evaluate the quantity and quality of nucleic acids extracted from mixed stained slides (MSSs), including H&E, IHC and FISH, compared to the extraction from unstained slides (USs). A series of 35 lung adenocarcinoma surgical samples was selected to set up the method and the technical approach was validated in a series of 15 small biopsies and 38 cytological samples. DNA extracted from MSSs was adequate in all samples and the Real Time PCR was successful in 30/35 surgical samples (86%), 14/15 small biopsies (93%), and 33/38 cytological samples (87%). NGS using DNA extracted from MSSs was successful in 18/35 surgical samples (51%), 11/15 small biopsies (73%), and 26/38 cytological samples (68%). RNA extracted from MSSs was unsatisfactory in all cases showing an inadequate degree of fragmentation. Our technical approach based on the recovery of stained slides could represent a strategic way forward for DNA-based biomarker testing in lung cancer cases without biomaterials. The RNA extracted from MSSs did not represent a successful approach. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-10178763 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | MDPI |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-101787632023-05-13 A Critical Issue in Lung Cancer Cytology and Small Biopsies: DNA and RNA Extraction from Archival Stained Slides for Biomarker Detection through Real Time PCR and NGS—The Experience in Pathological Anatomy Unit Zannini, Giuseppa Tedesco, Ilaria Cozzolino, Immacolata Montella, Marco Clery, Eduardo Della Corte, Carminia Maria Morgillo, Floriana Accardo, Marina Franco, Renato Zito Marino, Federica Diagnostics (Basel) Article The handling of biomaterials is crucial for precision medicine in advanced-stage lung patients with only cytology or small biopsies available. The main purpose of the study was to evaluate the quantity and quality of nucleic acids extracted from mixed stained slides (MSSs), including H&E, IHC and FISH, compared to the extraction from unstained slides (USs). A series of 35 lung adenocarcinoma surgical samples was selected to set up the method and the technical approach was validated in a series of 15 small biopsies and 38 cytological samples. DNA extracted from MSSs was adequate in all samples and the Real Time PCR was successful in 30/35 surgical samples (86%), 14/15 small biopsies (93%), and 33/38 cytological samples (87%). NGS using DNA extracted from MSSs was successful in 18/35 surgical samples (51%), 11/15 small biopsies (73%), and 26/38 cytological samples (68%). RNA extracted from MSSs was unsatisfactory in all cases showing an inadequate degree of fragmentation. Our technical approach based on the recovery of stained slides could represent a strategic way forward for DNA-based biomarker testing in lung cancer cases without biomaterials. The RNA extracted from MSSs did not represent a successful approach. MDPI 2023-05-05 /pmc/articles/PMC10178763/ /pubmed/37175028 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/diagnostics13091637 Text en © 2023 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). |
spellingShingle | Article Zannini, Giuseppa Tedesco, Ilaria Cozzolino, Immacolata Montella, Marco Clery, Eduardo Della Corte, Carminia Maria Morgillo, Floriana Accardo, Marina Franco, Renato Zito Marino, Federica A Critical Issue in Lung Cancer Cytology and Small Biopsies: DNA and RNA Extraction from Archival Stained Slides for Biomarker Detection through Real Time PCR and NGS—The Experience in Pathological Anatomy Unit |
title | A Critical Issue in Lung Cancer Cytology and Small Biopsies: DNA and RNA Extraction from Archival Stained Slides for Biomarker Detection through Real Time PCR and NGS—The Experience in Pathological Anatomy Unit |
title_full | A Critical Issue in Lung Cancer Cytology and Small Biopsies: DNA and RNA Extraction from Archival Stained Slides for Biomarker Detection through Real Time PCR and NGS—The Experience in Pathological Anatomy Unit |
title_fullStr | A Critical Issue in Lung Cancer Cytology and Small Biopsies: DNA and RNA Extraction from Archival Stained Slides for Biomarker Detection through Real Time PCR and NGS—The Experience in Pathological Anatomy Unit |
title_full_unstemmed | A Critical Issue in Lung Cancer Cytology and Small Biopsies: DNA and RNA Extraction from Archival Stained Slides for Biomarker Detection through Real Time PCR and NGS—The Experience in Pathological Anatomy Unit |
title_short | A Critical Issue in Lung Cancer Cytology and Small Biopsies: DNA and RNA Extraction from Archival Stained Slides for Biomarker Detection through Real Time PCR and NGS—The Experience in Pathological Anatomy Unit |
title_sort | critical issue in lung cancer cytology and small biopsies: dna and rna extraction from archival stained slides for biomarker detection through real time pcr and ngs—the experience in pathological anatomy unit |
topic | Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10178763/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37175028 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/diagnostics13091637 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT zanninigiuseppa acriticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT tedescoilaria acriticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT cozzolinoimmacolata acriticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT montellamarco acriticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT cleryeduardo acriticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT dellacortecarminiamaria acriticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT morgillofloriana acriticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT accardomarina acriticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT francorenato acriticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT zitomarinofederica acriticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT zanninigiuseppa criticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT tedescoilaria criticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT cozzolinoimmacolata criticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT montellamarco criticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT cleryeduardo criticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT dellacortecarminiamaria criticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT morgillofloriana criticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT accardomarina criticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT francorenato criticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit AT zitomarinofederica criticalissueinlungcancercytologyandsmallbiopsiesdnaandrnaextractionfromarchivalstainedslidesforbiomarkerdetectionthroughrealtimepcrandngstheexperienceinpathologicalanatomyunit |