Cargando…

Primary Tumour Treatment in Stage 4 Colorectal Cancer with Unresectable Liver and Lung Metastases and No Peritoneal Carcinomatosis—Current Trends and Attitudes in the Absence of Clear Guidelines

Background: The treatment of the primary tumour in colorectal cancer with unresectable liver and/or lung metastases but no peritoneal carcinomatosis is still a matter of debate. In the absence of clear evidence and guidelines, our survey was aimed at obtaining a snapshot of the current attitudes and...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Tebala, Giovanni Domenico, Di Cintio, Antonio, Ricci, Francesco, Avenia, Stefano, Cirocchi, Roberto, Desiderio, Jacopo, Di Nardo, Domenico, Di Saverio, Salomone, Gemini, Alessandro, Ranucci, Maria Chiara, Trastulli, Stefano, Cianchi, Fabio, Scatizzi, Marco, Catena, Fausto
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10219093/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37240604
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/jcm12103499
_version_ 1785048927673778176
author Tebala, Giovanni Domenico
Di Cintio, Antonio
Ricci, Francesco
Avenia, Stefano
Cirocchi, Roberto
Desiderio, Jacopo
Di Nardo, Domenico
Di Saverio, Salomone
Gemini, Alessandro
Ranucci, Maria Chiara
Trastulli, Stefano
Cianchi, Fabio
Scatizzi, Marco
Catena, Fausto
author_facet Tebala, Giovanni Domenico
Di Cintio, Antonio
Ricci, Francesco
Avenia, Stefano
Cirocchi, Roberto
Desiderio, Jacopo
Di Nardo, Domenico
Di Saverio, Salomone
Gemini, Alessandro
Ranucci, Maria Chiara
Trastulli, Stefano
Cianchi, Fabio
Scatizzi, Marco
Catena, Fausto
author_sort Tebala, Giovanni Domenico
collection PubMed
description Background: The treatment of the primary tumour in colorectal cancer with unresectable liver and/or lung metastases but no peritoneal carcinomatosis is still a matter of debate. In the absence of clear evidence and guidelines, our survey was aimed at obtaining a snapshot of the current attitudes and the rationales for the choice of offering resection of the primary tumour (RPT) despite the presence of untreatable metastases. Methods: An online survey was administered to medical professionals worldwide. The survey had three sections: (1) demographics of the respondent, (2) case scenarios and (3) general questions. For each respondent, an “elective resection score” and an “emergency resection score” were calculated as a percentage of the times he or she would offer RPT in the elective and in the emergency case scenarios. They were correlated to independent variables such as age, type of affiliation and specific workload. Results: Most respondents would offer palliative chemotherapy as the first choice in elective scenarios, while a more aggressive approach with RPT would be reserved for younger patients with good performance status and in emergency situations. Respondents younger than 50 years old and those with a specific workload of fewer than 40 cases of colorectal cancer per year tend to be more conservative. Conclusions: In the absence of clear guidelines and evidence, there is a lack of consensus on the treatment of the primary tumour in case of colon cancer with unresectable liver and/or lung metastases and no peritoneal carcinomatosis. Palliative chemotherapy seems to be the first option, but more consistent evidence is needed to guide this choice.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10219093
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-102190932023-05-27 Primary Tumour Treatment in Stage 4 Colorectal Cancer with Unresectable Liver and Lung Metastases and No Peritoneal Carcinomatosis—Current Trends and Attitudes in the Absence of Clear Guidelines Tebala, Giovanni Domenico Di Cintio, Antonio Ricci, Francesco Avenia, Stefano Cirocchi, Roberto Desiderio, Jacopo Di Nardo, Domenico Di Saverio, Salomone Gemini, Alessandro Ranucci, Maria Chiara Trastulli, Stefano Cianchi, Fabio Scatizzi, Marco Catena, Fausto J Clin Med Article Background: The treatment of the primary tumour in colorectal cancer with unresectable liver and/or lung metastases but no peritoneal carcinomatosis is still a matter of debate. In the absence of clear evidence and guidelines, our survey was aimed at obtaining a snapshot of the current attitudes and the rationales for the choice of offering resection of the primary tumour (RPT) despite the presence of untreatable metastases. Methods: An online survey was administered to medical professionals worldwide. The survey had three sections: (1) demographics of the respondent, (2) case scenarios and (3) general questions. For each respondent, an “elective resection score” and an “emergency resection score” were calculated as a percentage of the times he or she would offer RPT in the elective and in the emergency case scenarios. They were correlated to independent variables such as age, type of affiliation and specific workload. Results: Most respondents would offer palliative chemotherapy as the first choice in elective scenarios, while a more aggressive approach with RPT would be reserved for younger patients with good performance status and in emergency situations. Respondents younger than 50 years old and those with a specific workload of fewer than 40 cases of colorectal cancer per year tend to be more conservative. Conclusions: In the absence of clear guidelines and evidence, there is a lack of consensus on the treatment of the primary tumour in case of colon cancer with unresectable liver and/or lung metastases and no peritoneal carcinomatosis. Palliative chemotherapy seems to be the first option, but more consistent evidence is needed to guide this choice. MDPI 2023-05-16 /pmc/articles/PMC10219093/ /pubmed/37240604 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/jcm12103499 Text en © 2023 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Tebala, Giovanni Domenico
Di Cintio, Antonio
Ricci, Francesco
Avenia, Stefano
Cirocchi, Roberto
Desiderio, Jacopo
Di Nardo, Domenico
Di Saverio, Salomone
Gemini, Alessandro
Ranucci, Maria Chiara
Trastulli, Stefano
Cianchi, Fabio
Scatizzi, Marco
Catena, Fausto
Primary Tumour Treatment in Stage 4 Colorectal Cancer with Unresectable Liver and Lung Metastases and No Peritoneal Carcinomatosis—Current Trends and Attitudes in the Absence of Clear Guidelines
title Primary Tumour Treatment in Stage 4 Colorectal Cancer with Unresectable Liver and Lung Metastases and No Peritoneal Carcinomatosis—Current Trends and Attitudes in the Absence of Clear Guidelines
title_full Primary Tumour Treatment in Stage 4 Colorectal Cancer with Unresectable Liver and Lung Metastases and No Peritoneal Carcinomatosis—Current Trends and Attitudes in the Absence of Clear Guidelines
title_fullStr Primary Tumour Treatment in Stage 4 Colorectal Cancer with Unresectable Liver and Lung Metastases and No Peritoneal Carcinomatosis—Current Trends and Attitudes in the Absence of Clear Guidelines
title_full_unstemmed Primary Tumour Treatment in Stage 4 Colorectal Cancer with Unresectable Liver and Lung Metastases and No Peritoneal Carcinomatosis—Current Trends and Attitudes in the Absence of Clear Guidelines
title_short Primary Tumour Treatment in Stage 4 Colorectal Cancer with Unresectable Liver and Lung Metastases and No Peritoneal Carcinomatosis—Current Trends and Attitudes in the Absence of Clear Guidelines
title_sort primary tumour treatment in stage 4 colorectal cancer with unresectable liver and lung metastases and no peritoneal carcinomatosis—current trends and attitudes in the absence of clear guidelines
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10219093/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37240604
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/jcm12103499
work_keys_str_mv AT tebalagiovannidomenico primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT dicintioantonio primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT riccifrancesco primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT aveniastefano primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT cirocchiroberto primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT desideriojacopo primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT dinardodomenico primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT disaveriosalomone primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT geminialessandro primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT ranuccimariachiara primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT trastullistefano primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT cianchifabio primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT scatizzimarco primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT catenafausto primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines
AT primarytumourtreatmentinstage4colorectalcancerwithunresectableliverandlungmetastasesandnoperitonealcarcinomatosiscurrenttrendsandattitudesintheabsenceofclearguidelines