Cargando…
EPEN-02. OPTIMISING BIOMARKERS FOR ACCURATE EPENDYMOMA DIAGNOSIS, PROGNOSTICATION AND STRATIFICATION WITHIN INTERNATIONAL CLINICAL TRIALS: A BIOMECA STUDY
Accurate identification of brain tumour molecular subgroups is increasingly important. We aimed to establish the most accurate and reproducible ependymoma subgroup biomarker detection techniques, across 147 cases from International Society of Pediatric Oncology (SIOP) Ependymoma II trial participant...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Oxford University Press
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10259930/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/neuonc/noad073.106 |
_version_ | 1785057748135706624 |
---|---|
author | Chapman, Rebecca J Ghasemi, David R Andreiuolo, Felipe Zschernack, Valentina Espariat, Arnault Tauziede Buttarelli, Francesca Giangaspero, Felice Grill, Jacques Haberler, Christine Paine, Simon M L Scott, Ian Jacques, Thomas S Sill, Martin Stephan, Pfister Kilday, John Paul LeBlond, Pierre Massimino, Maura Modena, Piergiorgio Varlet, Pascale Pietsch, Torsten Grundy, Richard G Pajtler, Kristian W Ritzmann, Timothy A |
author_facet | Chapman, Rebecca J Ghasemi, David R Andreiuolo, Felipe Zschernack, Valentina Espariat, Arnault Tauziede Buttarelli, Francesca Giangaspero, Felice Grill, Jacques Haberler, Christine Paine, Simon M L Scott, Ian Jacques, Thomas S Sill, Martin Stephan, Pfister Kilday, John Paul LeBlond, Pierre Massimino, Maura Modena, Piergiorgio Varlet, Pascale Pietsch, Torsten Grundy, Richard G Pajtler, Kristian W Ritzmann, Timothy A |
author_sort | Chapman, Rebecca J |
collection | PubMed |
description | Accurate identification of brain tumour molecular subgroups is increasingly important. We aimed to establish the most accurate and reproducible ependymoma subgroup biomarker detection techniques, across 147 cases from International Society of Pediatric Oncology (SIOP) Ependymoma II trial participants, enrolled in the pan-European “Biomarkers of Ependymoma in Children and Adolescents (BIOMECA)” study. Across six European BIOMECA laboratories we evaluated epigenetic profiling (DNA methylation array); immunohistochemistry (IHC) for nuclear p65-RELA, H3K27me3, and Tenascin-C; copy number analysis via FISH and MLPA (1q, CDKN2A), and MIP and DNA methylation array (genome-wide copy number evaluation); analysis of ZFTA- and YAP1-fusions by RT-PCR and sequencing, Nanostring and break-apart FISH. DNA Methylation profiling classified 65.3% (n=96/147) of cases as EPN-PFA and 15% (n=22/147) as ST-ZFTA fusion-positive. Immunohistochemical loss of H3K27me3 was a reproducible and accurate surrogate marker for EPN-PFA (sensitivity 99-100% across three centres). IHC for p65-RELA, FISH, and RNA-based analyses effectively identified ZFTA- and YAP1- fused supratentorial ependymomas. Detection of 1q gain using FISH exhibited only 57% inter-centre concordance and low sensitivity and specificity whilst MIP, MLPA and DNA methylation-based approaches demonstrated greater accuracy. We confirm, in a prospective trial cohort, that H3K27me3 IHC is a robust EPN-PFA biomarker. Tenascin-C should be abandoned as a PFA marker. DNA methylation and MIP arrays are effective tools for copy number analysis of 1q gain, 6q and CDKN2A loss whilst FISH is inadequate. Fusion detection was successful, but rare novel fusions need more extensive technologies. We propose CORE and CORE Plus test sets to guide future diagnostic approaches. CORE tests represent those that can currently be used to stratify and inform clinical trials and diagnosis and include IHC and DNA methylation profiling. CORE Plus tests have additional advantages for challenging cases and for use in the research setting and comprise of MIP and RNA-NGS sequencing. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-10259930 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | Oxford University Press |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-102599302023-06-13 EPEN-02. OPTIMISING BIOMARKERS FOR ACCURATE EPENDYMOMA DIAGNOSIS, PROGNOSTICATION AND STRATIFICATION WITHIN INTERNATIONAL CLINICAL TRIALS: A BIOMECA STUDY Chapman, Rebecca J Ghasemi, David R Andreiuolo, Felipe Zschernack, Valentina Espariat, Arnault Tauziede Buttarelli, Francesca Giangaspero, Felice Grill, Jacques Haberler, Christine Paine, Simon M L Scott, Ian Jacques, Thomas S Sill, Martin Stephan, Pfister Kilday, John Paul LeBlond, Pierre Massimino, Maura Modena, Piergiorgio Varlet, Pascale Pietsch, Torsten Grundy, Richard G Pajtler, Kristian W Ritzmann, Timothy A Neuro Oncol Final Category: Ependymoma - EPEN Accurate identification of brain tumour molecular subgroups is increasingly important. We aimed to establish the most accurate and reproducible ependymoma subgroup biomarker detection techniques, across 147 cases from International Society of Pediatric Oncology (SIOP) Ependymoma II trial participants, enrolled in the pan-European “Biomarkers of Ependymoma in Children and Adolescents (BIOMECA)” study. Across six European BIOMECA laboratories we evaluated epigenetic profiling (DNA methylation array); immunohistochemistry (IHC) for nuclear p65-RELA, H3K27me3, and Tenascin-C; copy number analysis via FISH and MLPA (1q, CDKN2A), and MIP and DNA methylation array (genome-wide copy number evaluation); analysis of ZFTA- and YAP1-fusions by RT-PCR and sequencing, Nanostring and break-apart FISH. DNA Methylation profiling classified 65.3% (n=96/147) of cases as EPN-PFA and 15% (n=22/147) as ST-ZFTA fusion-positive. Immunohistochemical loss of H3K27me3 was a reproducible and accurate surrogate marker for EPN-PFA (sensitivity 99-100% across three centres). IHC for p65-RELA, FISH, and RNA-based analyses effectively identified ZFTA- and YAP1- fused supratentorial ependymomas. Detection of 1q gain using FISH exhibited only 57% inter-centre concordance and low sensitivity and specificity whilst MIP, MLPA and DNA methylation-based approaches demonstrated greater accuracy. We confirm, in a prospective trial cohort, that H3K27me3 IHC is a robust EPN-PFA biomarker. Tenascin-C should be abandoned as a PFA marker. DNA methylation and MIP arrays are effective tools for copy number analysis of 1q gain, 6q and CDKN2A loss whilst FISH is inadequate. Fusion detection was successful, but rare novel fusions need more extensive technologies. We propose CORE and CORE Plus test sets to guide future diagnostic approaches. CORE tests represent those that can currently be used to stratify and inform clinical trials and diagnosis and include IHC and DNA methylation profiling. CORE Plus tests have additional advantages for challenging cases and for use in the research setting and comprise of MIP and RNA-NGS sequencing. Oxford University Press 2023-06-12 /pmc/articles/PMC10259930/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/neuonc/noad073.106 Text en © The Author(s) 2023. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Society for Neuro-Oncology. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact journals.permissions@oup.com |
spellingShingle | Final Category: Ependymoma - EPEN Chapman, Rebecca J Ghasemi, David R Andreiuolo, Felipe Zschernack, Valentina Espariat, Arnault Tauziede Buttarelli, Francesca Giangaspero, Felice Grill, Jacques Haberler, Christine Paine, Simon M L Scott, Ian Jacques, Thomas S Sill, Martin Stephan, Pfister Kilday, John Paul LeBlond, Pierre Massimino, Maura Modena, Piergiorgio Varlet, Pascale Pietsch, Torsten Grundy, Richard G Pajtler, Kristian W Ritzmann, Timothy A EPEN-02. OPTIMISING BIOMARKERS FOR ACCURATE EPENDYMOMA DIAGNOSIS, PROGNOSTICATION AND STRATIFICATION WITHIN INTERNATIONAL CLINICAL TRIALS: A BIOMECA STUDY |
title | EPEN-02. OPTIMISING BIOMARKERS FOR ACCURATE EPENDYMOMA DIAGNOSIS, PROGNOSTICATION AND STRATIFICATION WITHIN INTERNATIONAL CLINICAL TRIALS: A BIOMECA STUDY |
title_full | EPEN-02. OPTIMISING BIOMARKERS FOR ACCURATE EPENDYMOMA DIAGNOSIS, PROGNOSTICATION AND STRATIFICATION WITHIN INTERNATIONAL CLINICAL TRIALS: A BIOMECA STUDY |
title_fullStr | EPEN-02. OPTIMISING BIOMARKERS FOR ACCURATE EPENDYMOMA DIAGNOSIS, PROGNOSTICATION AND STRATIFICATION WITHIN INTERNATIONAL CLINICAL TRIALS: A BIOMECA STUDY |
title_full_unstemmed | EPEN-02. OPTIMISING BIOMARKERS FOR ACCURATE EPENDYMOMA DIAGNOSIS, PROGNOSTICATION AND STRATIFICATION WITHIN INTERNATIONAL CLINICAL TRIALS: A BIOMECA STUDY |
title_short | EPEN-02. OPTIMISING BIOMARKERS FOR ACCURATE EPENDYMOMA DIAGNOSIS, PROGNOSTICATION AND STRATIFICATION WITHIN INTERNATIONAL CLINICAL TRIALS: A BIOMECA STUDY |
title_sort | epen-02. optimising biomarkers for accurate ependymoma diagnosis, prognostication and stratification within international clinical trials: a biomeca study |
topic | Final Category: Ependymoma - EPEN |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10259930/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/neuonc/noad073.106 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT chapmanrebeccaj epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT ghasemidavidr epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT andreiuolofelipe epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT zschernackvalentina epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT espariatarnaulttauziede epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT buttarellifrancesca epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT giangasperofelice epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT grilljacques epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT haberlerchristine epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT painesimonml epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT scottian epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT jacquesthomass epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT sillmartin epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT stephanpfister epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT kildayjohnpaul epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT leblondpierre epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT massiminomaura epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT modenapiergiorgio epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT varletpascale epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT pietschtorsten epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT grundyrichardg epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT pajtlerkristianw epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy AT ritzmanntimothya epen02optimisingbiomarkersforaccurateependymomadiagnosisprognosticationandstratificationwithininternationalclinicaltrialsabiomecastudy |