Exploring the Impact of Book Club Participation on Clinicians’ Empathy and Reflection on Empathetic Practice: A Wake-Up Call

Introduction: Empathy is associated with desirable outcomes in healthcare, including improved patient-clinician rapport, fewer patient complications, and reduced clinician burnout. Despite these benefits, research suggests empathy declines during professional training. This study aimed to explore the impact of book club participation on clinicians’ and trainees’ empathy and perspectives on empathetic patient care. Methods: In this mixed-methods study, anesthesiology clinicians and trainees were invited to respond to a baseline online empathy survey followed by an invitation to read a book and to participate in one of four facilitated book club sessions. Post-intervention empathy was measured. The primary outcome of the quantitative analysis was a change in empathy scores as measured by the Toronto Empathy Questionnaire. A thematic analysis of book club sessions and open-ended comments in the post-intervention survey was conducted. Results: Participants included 74 responders to the baseline survey and 73 responders to the post-intervention survey. Empathy score change in the book club participants was not statistically significant from those who did not participate in any book club sessions (F((2, 39)) = 0.42, p=0.66). Thematic analysis of the book club sessions revealed four themes that highlight how the book club enhanced empathy awareness among trainees and clinicians: 1) a wake-up call, 2) deciding whether to take action, 3) learning and nurturing empathy, and 4) changing the culture. Conclusion: There were no significant changes in empathy scores associated with book club participation. Thematic analysis highlighted barriers toward empathetic patient care, areas for improvement, and voiced intentions to practice with heightened empathy. Book clubs may be a viable venue to nurture a culture of increased self-awareness and motivation to counteract loss of empathy, but just one experience may not be sufficient.