Thyroidectomy With or Without Nerve Identification: A Personal Experience and Technique

Introduction: Careful and precise dissection of the gland, away from the typical trajectory of the recurrent and external laryngeal nerves, poses a minimal or similar risk of nerve injuries compared to directly visualizing and identifying the nerves. Materials and methods: In a randomized controlled study involving 150 patients with various thyroid disorders who underwent different surgical procedures (total, near total, and hemi thyroidectomy), the patients were randomly assigned into two groups using a coin toss. The first group (G1) consisted of 75 patients who underwent thyroidectomy with nerve visual identification, while the second group (G2) comprised 75 patients without the requirement of nerve visualization. The aim was to determine the method with a lower risk of complications. Results: The incidence of external laryngeal nerve palsy (ELNP) was found to be higher in G1 patients compared to G2 patients (5.3% vs 2%), while no cases of permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) palsy were observed in either group. The frequency of total nerve injury was higher in G1, with 14 patients (10.2%), compared to G2, with eight patients (5.3%). However, there was no significant association between nerve identification and the rate of nerve injury (P value = 0.452). Among the different surgical procedures, total thyroidectomy for toxic goiter was the most common operation associated with transient external laryngeal nerve (TELN) injury and permanent external laryngeal nerve (PELN) injury. Conclusion: By employing meticulous dissection techniques in proximity to the thyroid capsule, experienced surgeons can effectively reduce the risk of nerve injury, even in the absence of direct nerve visualization.