Cargando…
Is Simulation a Practical and Effective Training Modality in Psychiatry? an Evaluation of What Works and Doesn't From Our Experience in North East
AIMS: Several studies on simulation as a method of teaching have identified advantages- on attitudes, skills, knowledge and behaviours, and non-technical skills such as situational awareness, team working, interpersonal interactions with improved confidence. Use of simulation in Psychiatry is growin...
Autores principales: | , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Cambridge University Press
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10345549/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1192/bjo.2023.153 |
_version_ | 1785073113673760768 |
---|---|
author | Rao, Prathibha Owen, Bruce Tippins, Val Mcloughlin, Claire Lamph, Richard |
author_facet | Rao, Prathibha Owen, Bruce Tippins, Val Mcloughlin, Claire Lamph, Richard |
author_sort | Rao, Prathibha |
collection | PubMed |
description | AIMS: Several studies on simulation as a method of teaching have identified advantages- on attitudes, skills, knowledge and behaviours, and non-technical skills such as situational awareness, team working, interpersonal interactions with improved confidence. Use of simulation in Psychiatry is growing, but studies are limited. We decided to evaluate our own delivery of simulation in trust and align this to the national strategy to identify gaps and further work METHODS: Core trainees- Emergencies in Psychiatry- seclusion, suicide risk assessment and fracture neck of femur. Communication skills course, mock CASC, ILS. Higher trainees- Tribunal preparation and providing evidence, Induction- Out of hours supervising 1st on call, Managing serious incident. In development-Immersive technology- Higher trainee supervising a junior doctor OOH. RESULTS: : Participant anxiety-Performing in front of peers can be demanding and reduces take up. ‘What to expect’ pre-session workbook, small group numbers (3), reiterating the focus of session on learning and confidentiality has improved participation. Resource (scenario development) - Takes time and effort to achieve high quality, piloting and continual adjustments to tailor to the learners' needs. We appointed 3 SIM leads and hold regular meetings. Resource (trainers)- Hard to resource trained trainers. Developed an in-house training programmes for trainers, but persistent difficulties in maintaining consistency and time commitments with same group of ‘trained trainers’. Included brief training pre-session in morning for facilitators. Resources (finance)-Expensive to support Simulated patients. We used COVID-19 recovery funds and constructed purpose-built SIM rooms in education centre, which adds to fidelity. CONCLUSION: Feedback: Excellent feedback received with positive comments about supportive learning, SIM facilities and debriefing. Despite being highly resource intensive, simulation is a powerful, unique, and valuable method of training in Psychiatry. Availability of resource will continue to pose challenges, but use of digital Immersive technology and focussing on relevant areas in line with National vision strategy and with identified groups- Induction, SuppoRTT, new to NHS, Remediation, CASC preparation and enhancing capacity of learning environment where there are gaps may be a good starting point. Use of MDT integrated scenarios can offer more fidelity. : CT1s-Physical health skills (refresher), history taking, MSE, handover. Emergency scenarios- NMS, lithium toxicity, cardiac complications due to clozapine. Higher trainees- Mental health act assessments, supervising doctors in training/members of MDT. Chairing team meeting, handover, breaking bad news, presenting in a coroner's court; |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-10345549 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | Cambridge University Press |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-103455492023-07-15 Is Simulation a Practical and Effective Training Modality in Psychiatry? an Evaluation of What Works and Doesn't From Our Experience in North East Rao, Prathibha Owen, Bruce Tippins, Val Mcloughlin, Claire Lamph, Richard BJPsych Open Education and Training AIMS: Several studies on simulation as a method of teaching have identified advantages- on attitudes, skills, knowledge and behaviours, and non-technical skills such as situational awareness, team working, interpersonal interactions with improved confidence. Use of simulation in Psychiatry is growing, but studies are limited. We decided to evaluate our own delivery of simulation in trust and align this to the national strategy to identify gaps and further work METHODS: Core trainees- Emergencies in Psychiatry- seclusion, suicide risk assessment and fracture neck of femur. Communication skills course, mock CASC, ILS. Higher trainees- Tribunal preparation and providing evidence, Induction- Out of hours supervising 1st on call, Managing serious incident. In development-Immersive technology- Higher trainee supervising a junior doctor OOH. RESULTS: : Participant anxiety-Performing in front of peers can be demanding and reduces take up. ‘What to expect’ pre-session workbook, small group numbers (3), reiterating the focus of session on learning and confidentiality has improved participation. Resource (scenario development) - Takes time and effort to achieve high quality, piloting and continual adjustments to tailor to the learners' needs. We appointed 3 SIM leads and hold regular meetings. Resource (trainers)- Hard to resource trained trainers. Developed an in-house training programmes for trainers, but persistent difficulties in maintaining consistency and time commitments with same group of ‘trained trainers’. Included brief training pre-session in morning for facilitators. Resources (finance)-Expensive to support Simulated patients. We used COVID-19 recovery funds and constructed purpose-built SIM rooms in education centre, which adds to fidelity. CONCLUSION: Feedback: Excellent feedback received with positive comments about supportive learning, SIM facilities and debriefing. Despite being highly resource intensive, simulation is a powerful, unique, and valuable method of training in Psychiatry. Availability of resource will continue to pose challenges, but use of digital Immersive technology and focussing on relevant areas in line with National vision strategy and with identified groups- Induction, SuppoRTT, new to NHS, Remediation, CASC preparation and enhancing capacity of learning environment where there are gaps may be a good starting point. Use of MDT integrated scenarios can offer more fidelity. : CT1s-Physical health skills (refresher), history taking, MSE, handover. Emergency scenarios- NMS, lithium toxicity, cardiac complications due to clozapine. Higher trainees- Mental health act assessments, supervising doctors in training/members of MDT. Chairing team meeting, handover, breaking bad news, presenting in a coroner's court; Cambridge University Press 2023-07-07 /pmc/articles/PMC10345549/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1192/bjo.2023.153 Text en © The Author(s) 2023 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/This is an Open Access article, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0), which permits unrestricted re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. This does not need to be placed under each abstract, just each page is fine. |
spellingShingle | Education and Training Rao, Prathibha Owen, Bruce Tippins, Val Mcloughlin, Claire Lamph, Richard Is Simulation a Practical and Effective Training Modality in Psychiatry? an Evaluation of What Works and Doesn't From Our Experience in North East |
title | Is Simulation a Practical and Effective Training Modality in Psychiatry? an Evaluation of What Works and Doesn't From Our Experience in North East |
title_full | Is Simulation a Practical and Effective Training Modality in Psychiatry? an Evaluation of What Works and Doesn't From Our Experience in North East |
title_fullStr | Is Simulation a Practical and Effective Training Modality in Psychiatry? an Evaluation of What Works and Doesn't From Our Experience in North East |
title_full_unstemmed | Is Simulation a Practical and Effective Training Modality in Psychiatry? an Evaluation of What Works and Doesn't From Our Experience in North East |
title_short | Is Simulation a Practical and Effective Training Modality in Psychiatry? an Evaluation of What Works and Doesn't From Our Experience in North East |
title_sort | is simulation a practical and effective training modality in psychiatry? an evaluation of what works and doesn't from our experience in north east |
topic | Education and Training |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10345549/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1192/bjo.2023.153 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT raoprathibha issimulationapracticalandeffectivetrainingmodalityinpsychiatryanevaluationofwhatworksanddoesntfromourexperienceinnortheast AT owenbruce issimulationapracticalandeffectivetrainingmodalityinpsychiatryanevaluationofwhatworksanddoesntfromourexperienceinnortheast AT tippinsval issimulationapracticalandeffectivetrainingmodalityinpsychiatryanevaluationofwhatworksanddoesntfromourexperienceinnortheast AT mcloughlinclaire issimulationapracticalandeffectivetrainingmodalityinpsychiatryanevaluationofwhatworksanddoesntfromourexperienceinnortheast AT lamphrichard issimulationapracticalandeffectivetrainingmodalityinpsychiatryanevaluationofwhatworksanddoesntfromourexperienceinnortheast |