Cargando…

A novel blood based triage test for colorectal cancer in primary care: a pilot study

BACKGROUND: The majority of colorectal cancers (CRCs) are detected after symptomatic presentation to primary care. Given the shared symptoms of CRC and benign disorders, it is challenging to manage the risk of missed diagnosis. Colonoscopy resources cannot keep pace with increasing demand. There is...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Jenkins, Cerys, Woods, Freya, Chandler, Susan, Carter, Kym, Jenkins, Rhys, Cunningham, Andrew, Nelson, Kayleigh, Still, Rachel, Walters, Jenna A, Gwynn, Non, Chea, Wilson, Harford, Rachel, O'Neill, Claire, Hepburn, Julie, Hill, Ian, Wilkes, Heather, Fegan, Greg, Dunstan, Peter, Harris, Dean A
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Royal College of General Practitioners 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10354317/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36332909
http://dx.doi.org/10.3399/BJGPO.2022.0077
_version_ 1785074900341358592
author Jenkins, Cerys
Woods, Freya
Chandler, Susan
Carter, Kym
Jenkins, Rhys
Cunningham, Andrew
Nelson, Kayleigh
Still, Rachel
Walters, Jenna A
Gwynn, Non
Chea, Wilson
Harford, Rachel
O'Neill, Claire
Hepburn, Julie
Hill, Ian
Wilkes, Heather
Fegan, Greg
Dunstan, Peter
Harris, Dean A
author_facet Jenkins, Cerys
Woods, Freya
Chandler, Susan
Carter, Kym
Jenkins, Rhys
Cunningham, Andrew
Nelson, Kayleigh
Still, Rachel
Walters, Jenna A
Gwynn, Non
Chea, Wilson
Harford, Rachel
O'Neill, Claire
Hepburn, Julie
Hill, Ian
Wilkes, Heather
Fegan, Greg
Dunstan, Peter
Harris, Dean A
author_sort Jenkins, Cerys
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: The majority of colorectal cancers (CRCs) are detected after symptomatic presentation to primary care. Given the shared symptoms of CRC and benign disorders, it is challenging to manage the risk of missed diagnosis. Colonoscopy resources cannot keep pace with increasing demand. There is a pressing need for access to simple triage tools in primary care to help prioritise patients for referral. AIM: To evaluate the performance of a novel spectroscopy-based CRC blood test in primary care. DESIGN & SETTING: Mixed-methods pilot study of test performance and GP focus group discussions in South Wales. METHOD: Patients on the urgent suspected cancer (USC) pathway were recruited for the Raman spectroscopy (RS) test coupled to machine learning classification (‘Raman-CRC’) to identify CRC within the referred population. Qualitative focus group work evaluated the acceptability of the test in primary care by thematic analysis of focus group theorising. RESULTS: A total of 532 patients aged ≥50 years referred on the USC pathway were recruited from 27 GP practices. Twenty-nine patients (5.0%) were diagnosed with CRC. Raman-CRC identified CRC with sensitivity 95.7%, specificity 69.3% with area under curve (AUC) of 0.80 compared with colonoscopy as the reference test (248 patients). Stage I and II cancers were detected with 78.6% sensitivity. Focus group themes underlined the convenience of a blood test for the patient and the test’s value as a risk assessment tool in primary care. CONCLUSION: The findings support this novel, non-invasive, blood-based method to prioritise those patients most likely to have CRC. Raman-CRC may accelerate access to diagnosis with potential to improve cancer outcomes.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10354317
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Royal College of General Practitioners
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-103543172023-07-20 A novel blood based triage test for colorectal cancer in primary care: a pilot study Jenkins, Cerys Woods, Freya Chandler, Susan Carter, Kym Jenkins, Rhys Cunningham, Andrew Nelson, Kayleigh Still, Rachel Walters, Jenna A Gwynn, Non Chea, Wilson Harford, Rachel O'Neill, Claire Hepburn, Julie Hill, Ian Wilkes, Heather Fegan, Greg Dunstan, Peter Harris, Dean A BJGP Open Research BACKGROUND: The majority of colorectal cancers (CRCs) are detected after symptomatic presentation to primary care. Given the shared symptoms of CRC and benign disorders, it is challenging to manage the risk of missed diagnosis. Colonoscopy resources cannot keep pace with increasing demand. There is a pressing need for access to simple triage tools in primary care to help prioritise patients for referral. AIM: To evaluate the performance of a novel spectroscopy-based CRC blood test in primary care. DESIGN & SETTING: Mixed-methods pilot study of test performance and GP focus group discussions in South Wales. METHOD: Patients on the urgent suspected cancer (USC) pathway were recruited for the Raman spectroscopy (RS) test coupled to machine learning classification (‘Raman-CRC’) to identify CRC within the referred population. Qualitative focus group work evaluated the acceptability of the test in primary care by thematic analysis of focus group theorising. RESULTS: A total of 532 patients aged ≥50 years referred on the USC pathway were recruited from 27 GP practices. Twenty-nine patients (5.0%) were diagnosed with CRC. Raman-CRC identified CRC with sensitivity 95.7%, specificity 69.3% with area under curve (AUC) of 0.80 compared with colonoscopy as the reference test (248 patients). Stage I and II cancers were detected with 78.6% sensitivity. Focus group themes underlined the convenience of a blood test for the patient and the test’s value as a risk assessment tool in primary care. CONCLUSION: The findings support this novel, non-invasive, blood-based method to prioritise those patients most likely to have CRC. Raman-CRC may accelerate access to diagnosis with potential to improve cancer outcomes. Royal College of General Practitioners 2022-12-14 /pmc/articles/PMC10354317/ /pubmed/36332909 http://dx.doi.org/10.3399/BJGPO.2022.0077 Text en Copyright © 2022, The Authors https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This article is Open Access: CC BY license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
spellingShingle Research
Jenkins, Cerys
Woods, Freya
Chandler, Susan
Carter, Kym
Jenkins, Rhys
Cunningham, Andrew
Nelson, Kayleigh
Still, Rachel
Walters, Jenna A
Gwynn, Non
Chea, Wilson
Harford, Rachel
O'Neill, Claire
Hepburn, Julie
Hill, Ian
Wilkes, Heather
Fegan, Greg
Dunstan, Peter
Harris, Dean A
A novel blood based triage test for colorectal cancer in primary care: a pilot study
title A novel blood based triage test for colorectal cancer in primary care: a pilot study
title_full A novel blood based triage test for colorectal cancer in primary care: a pilot study
title_fullStr A novel blood based triage test for colorectal cancer in primary care: a pilot study
title_full_unstemmed A novel blood based triage test for colorectal cancer in primary care: a pilot study
title_short A novel blood based triage test for colorectal cancer in primary care: a pilot study
title_sort novel blood based triage test for colorectal cancer in primary care: a pilot study
topic Research
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10354317/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36332909
http://dx.doi.org/10.3399/BJGPO.2022.0077
work_keys_str_mv AT jenkinscerys anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT woodsfreya anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT chandlersusan anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT carterkym anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT jenkinsrhys anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT cunninghamandrew anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT nelsonkayleigh anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT stillrachel anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT waltersjennaa anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT gwynnnon anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT cheawilson anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT harfordrachel anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT oneillclaire anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT hepburnjulie anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT hillian anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT wilkesheather anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT fegangreg anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT dunstanpeter anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT harrisdeana anovelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT jenkinscerys novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT woodsfreya novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT chandlersusan novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT carterkym novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT jenkinsrhys novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT cunninghamandrew novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT nelsonkayleigh novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT stillrachel novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT waltersjennaa novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT gwynnnon novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT cheawilson novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT harfordrachel novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT oneillclaire novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT hepburnjulie novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT hillian novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT wilkesheather novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT fegangreg novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT dunstanpeter novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy
AT harrisdeana novelbloodbasedtriagetestforcolorectalcancerinprimarycareapilotstudy