Cargando…

Antigen concentration, viral load, and test performance for SARS-CoV-2 in multiple specimen types

The relationship between N-antigen concentration and viral load within and across different specimens guides the clinical performance of rapid diagnostic tests (RDT) in different uses. A prospective study was conducted in Porto Velho, Brazil, to investigate RDT performance in different specimen type...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Golden, Allison, Oliveira-Silva, Michelle, Slater, Hannah, Vieira, Alexia Martines, Bansil, Pooja, Gerth-Guyette, Emily, Leader, Brandon T., Zobrist, Stephanie, Braga Ferreira, Alan Kennedy, Santos de Araujo, Erika Crhistina, de Lucena Cruz, Catherine Duran, Garbin, Eduardo, Bizilj, Greg T., Carlson, Sean J., Sagalovsky, Mariana, Pal, Sampa, Gupta, Vin, Wolansky, Leo, Boyle, David S., Vieira Dall’Acqua, Deusilene Souza, Naveca, Felipe Gomes, do Nascimento, Valdinete Alves, Villalobos Salcedo, Juan Miguel, Drain, Paul K., Costa, Alexandre Dias Tavares, Pereira, Dhélio, Domingo, Gonzalo J.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10355390/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37467188
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0287814
_version_ 1785075128419221504
author Golden, Allison
Oliveira-Silva, Michelle
Slater, Hannah
Vieira, Alexia Martines
Bansil, Pooja
Gerth-Guyette, Emily
Leader, Brandon T.
Zobrist, Stephanie
Braga Ferreira, Alan Kennedy
Santos de Araujo, Erika Crhistina
de Lucena Cruz, Catherine Duran
Garbin, Eduardo
Bizilj, Greg T.
Carlson, Sean J.
Sagalovsky, Mariana
Pal, Sampa
Gupta, Vin
Wolansky, Leo
Boyle, David S.
Vieira Dall’Acqua, Deusilene Souza
Naveca, Felipe Gomes
do Nascimento, Valdinete Alves
Villalobos Salcedo, Juan Miguel
Drain, Paul K.
Costa, Alexandre Dias Tavares
Pereira, Dhélio
Domingo, Gonzalo J.
author_facet Golden, Allison
Oliveira-Silva, Michelle
Slater, Hannah
Vieira, Alexia Martines
Bansil, Pooja
Gerth-Guyette, Emily
Leader, Brandon T.
Zobrist, Stephanie
Braga Ferreira, Alan Kennedy
Santos de Araujo, Erika Crhistina
de Lucena Cruz, Catherine Duran
Garbin, Eduardo
Bizilj, Greg T.
Carlson, Sean J.
Sagalovsky, Mariana
Pal, Sampa
Gupta, Vin
Wolansky, Leo
Boyle, David S.
Vieira Dall’Acqua, Deusilene Souza
Naveca, Felipe Gomes
do Nascimento, Valdinete Alves
Villalobos Salcedo, Juan Miguel
Drain, Paul K.
Costa, Alexandre Dias Tavares
Pereira, Dhélio
Domingo, Gonzalo J.
author_sort Golden, Allison
collection PubMed
description The relationship between N-antigen concentration and viral load within and across different specimens guides the clinical performance of rapid diagnostic tests (RDT) in different uses. A prospective study was conducted in Porto Velho, Brazil, to investigate RDT performance in different specimen types as a function of the correlation between antigen concentration and viral load. The study included 214 close contacts with recent exposures to confirmed cases, aged 12 years and older and with various levels of vaccination. Antigen concentration was measured in nasopharyngeal swab (NPS), anterior nares swab (ANS), and saliva specimens. Reverse transcriptase (RT)–PCR was conducted on the NPS and saliva specimens, and two RDTs were conducted on ANS and one RDT on saliva. Antigen concentration correlated well with viral load when measured in the same specimen type but not across specimen types. Antigen levels were higher in symptomatic cases compared to asymptomatic/oligosymptomatic cases and lower in saliva compared to NPS and ANS samples. Discordant results between the RDTs conducted on ANS and the RT-PCR on NPS were resolved by antigen concentration values. The analytical limit-of-detection of RDTs can be used to predict the performance of the tests in populations for which the antigen concentration is known. The antigen dynamics across different sample types observed in SARS-CoV-2 disease progression support use of RDTs with nasal samples. Given lower antigen concentrations in saliva, rapid testing using saliva is expected to require improved RDT analytical sensitivity to achieve clinical sensitivity similar to rapid testing of nasal samples.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10355390
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-103553902023-07-20 Antigen concentration, viral load, and test performance for SARS-CoV-2 in multiple specimen types Golden, Allison Oliveira-Silva, Michelle Slater, Hannah Vieira, Alexia Martines Bansil, Pooja Gerth-Guyette, Emily Leader, Brandon T. Zobrist, Stephanie Braga Ferreira, Alan Kennedy Santos de Araujo, Erika Crhistina de Lucena Cruz, Catherine Duran Garbin, Eduardo Bizilj, Greg T. Carlson, Sean J. Sagalovsky, Mariana Pal, Sampa Gupta, Vin Wolansky, Leo Boyle, David S. Vieira Dall’Acqua, Deusilene Souza Naveca, Felipe Gomes do Nascimento, Valdinete Alves Villalobos Salcedo, Juan Miguel Drain, Paul K. Costa, Alexandre Dias Tavares Pereira, Dhélio Domingo, Gonzalo J. PLoS One Research Article The relationship between N-antigen concentration and viral load within and across different specimens guides the clinical performance of rapid diagnostic tests (RDT) in different uses. A prospective study was conducted in Porto Velho, Brazil, to investigate RDT performance in different specimen types as a function of the correlation between antigen concentration and viral load. The study included 214 close contacts with recent exposures to confirmed cases, aged 12 years and older and with various levels of vaccination. Antigen concentration was measured in nasopharyngeal swab (NPS), anterior nares swab (ANS), and saliva specimens. Reverse transcriptase (RT)–PCR was conducted on the NPS and saliva specimens, and two RDTs were conducted on ANS and one RDT on saliva. Antigen concentration correlated well with viral load when measured in the same specimen type but not across specimen types. Antigen levels were higher in symptomatic cases compared to asymptomatic/oligosymptomatic cases and lower in saliva compared to NPS and ANS samples. Discordant results between the RDTs conducted on ANS and the RT-PCR on NPS were resolved by antigen concentration values. The analytical limit-of-detection of RDTs can be used to predict the performance of the tests in populations for which the antigen concentration is known. The antigen dynamics across different sample types observed in SARS-CoV-2 disease progression support use of RDTs with nasal samples. Given lower antigen concentrations in saliva, rapid testing using saliva is expected to require improved RDT analytical sensitivity to achieve clinical sensitivity similar to rapid testing of nasal samples. Public Library of Science 2023-07-19 /pmc/articles/PMC10355390/ /pubmed/37467188 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0287814 Text en © 2023 Golden et al https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Research Article
Golden, Allison
Oliveira-Silva, Michelle
Slater, Hannah
Vieira, Alexia Martines
Bansil, Pooja
Gerth-Guyette, Emily
Leader, Brandon T.
Zobrist, Stephanie
Braga Ferreira, Alan Kennedy
Santos de Araujo, Erika Crhistina
de Lucena Cruz, Catherine Duran
Garbin, Eduardo
Bizilj, Greg T.
Carlson, Sean J.
Sagalovsky, Mariana
Pal, Sampa
Gupta, Vin
Wolansky, Leo
Boyle, David S.
Vieira Dall’Acqua, Deusilene Souza
Naveca, Felipe Gomes
do Nascimento, Valdinete Alves
Villalobos Salcedo, Juan Miguel
Drain, Paul K.
Costa, Alexandre Dias Tavares
Pereira, Dhélio
Domingo, Gonzalo J.
Antigen concentration, viral load, and test performance for SARS-CoV-2 in multiple specimen types
title Antigen concentration, viral load, and test performance for SARS-CoV-2 in multiple specimen types
title_full Antigen concentration, viral load, and test performance for SARS-CoV-2 in multiple specimen types
title_fullStr Antigen concentration, viral load, and test performance for SARS-CoV-2 in multiple specimen types
title_full_unstemmed Antigen concentration, viral load, and test performance for SARS-CoV-2 in multiple specimen types
title_short Antigen concentration, viral load, and test performance for SARS-CoV-2 in multiple specimen types
title_sort antigen concentration, viral load, and test performance for sars-cov-2 in multiple specimen types
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10355390/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37467188
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0287814
work_keys_str_mv AT goldenallison antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT oliveirasilvamichelle antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT slaterhannah antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT vieiraalexiamartines antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT bansilpooja antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT gerthguyetteemily antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT leaderbrandont antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT zobriststephanie antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT bragaferreiraalankennedy antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT santosdearaujoerikacrhistina antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT delucenacruzcatherineduran antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT garbineduardo antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT biziljgregt antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT carlsonseanj antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT sagalovskymariana antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT palsampa antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT guptavin antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT wolanskyleo antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT boyledavids antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT vieiradallacquadeusilenesouza antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT navecafelipegomes antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT donascimentovaldinetealves antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT villalobossalcedojuanmiguel antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT drainpaulk antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT costaalexandrediastavares antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT pereiradhelio antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes
AT domingogonzaloj antigenconcentrationviralloadandtestperformanceforsarscov2inmultiplespecimentypes