Cargando…

A Randomized Trial to Assess the Impact of a Package of Diagnostic Tools and Diagnostic Algorithm on Antibiotic Prescriptions for the Management of Febrile Illnesses Among Children and Adolescents in Primary Health Facilities in Burkina Faso

BACKGROUND: Low- and middle-income countries face significant challenges in differentiating bacterial from viral causes of febrile illnesses, leading to inappropriate use of antibiotics. This trial aimed to evaluate the impact of an intervention package comprising diagnostic tests, a diagnostic algo...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Kiemde, Francois, Valia, Daniel, Kabore, Berenger, Rouamba, Toussaint, Kone, Alima Nadine, Sawadogo, Seydou, Compaore, Adelaide, Salami, Olawale, Horgan, Philip, Moore, Catrin E, Dittrich, Sabine, Nkeramahame, Juvenal, Olliaro, Piero, Tinto, Halidou
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Oxford University Press 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10368409/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37490742
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/cid/ciad331
_version_ 1785077499910160384
author Kiemde, Francois
Valia, Daniel
Kabore, Berenger
Rouamba, Toussaint
Kone, Alima Nadine
Sawadogo, Seydou
Compaore, Adelaide
Salami, Olawale
Horgan, Philip
Moore, Catrin E
Dittrich, Sabine
Nkeramahame, Juvenal
Olliaro, Piero
Tinto, Halidou
author_facet Kiemde, Francois
Valia, Daniel
Kabore, Berenger
Rouamba, Toussaint
Kone, Alima Nadine
Sawadogo, Seydou
Compaore, Adelaide
Salami, Olawale
Horgan, Philip
Moore, Catrin E
Dittrich, Sabine
Nkeramahame, Juvenal
Olliaro, Piero
Tinto, Halidou
author_sort Kiemde, Francois
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Low- and middle-income countries face significant challenges in differentiating bacterial from viral causes of febrile illnesses, leading to inappropriate use of antibiotics. This trial aimed to evaluate the impact of an intervention package comprising diagnostic tests, a diagnostic algorithm, and a training-and-communication package on antibiotic prescriptions and clinical outcomes. METHODS: Patients aged 6 months to 18 years with fever or history of fever within the past 7 days with no focus, or a suspected respiratory tract infection, arriving at 2 health facilities were randomized to either the intervention package or standard practice. The primary outcomes were the proportions of patients who recovered at day 7 (D7) and patients prescribed antibiotics at day 0. RESULTS: Of 1718 patients randomized, 1681 (97.8%; intervention: 844; control: 837) completed follow-up: 99.5% recovered at D7 in the intervention arm versus 100% in standard practice (P = .135). Antibiotics were prescribed to 40.6% of patients in the intervention group versus 57.5% in the control arm (risk ratio: 29.3%; 95% CI: 21.8–36.0%; risk difference [RD]: −16.8%; 95% CI: −21.7% to −12.0%; P < .001), which translates to 1 additional antibiotic prescription saved every 6 (95% CI: 5–8) consultations. This reduction was significant regardless of test results for malaria, but was greater in patients without malaria (RD: −46.0%; −54.7% to −37.4%; P < .001), those with a respiratory diagnosis (RD: −38.2%; −43.8% to −32.6%; P < .001), and in children 6–59 months old (RD: −20.4%; −26.0% to −14.9%; P < .001). Except for the period July–September, the reduction was consistent across the other quarters (P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: The implementation of the package can reduce inappropriate antibiotic prescription without compromising clinical outcomes. CLINICAL TRIALS REGISTRATION: clinicaltrials.gov; NCT04081051.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10368409
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Oxford University Press
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-103684092023-07-26 A Randomized Trial to Assess the Impact of a Package of Diagnostic Tools and Diagnostic Algorithm on Antibiotic Prescriptions for the Management of Febrile Illnesses Among Children and Adolescents in Primary Health Facilities in Burkina Faso Kiemde, Francois Valia, Daniel Kabore, Berenger Rouamba, Toussaint Kone, Alima Nadine Sawadogo, Seydou Compaore, Adelaide Salami, Olawale Horgan, Philip Moore, Catrin E Dittrich, Sabine Nkeramahame, Juvenal Olliaro, Piero Tinto, Halidou Clin Infect Dis Supplement Article BACKGROUND: Low- and middle-income countries face significant challenges in differentiating bacterial from viral causes of febrile illnesses, leading to inappropriate use of antibiotics. This trial aimed to evaluate the impact of an intervention package comprising diagnostic tests, a diagnostic algorithm, and a training-and-communication package on antibiotic prescriptions and clinical outcomes. METHODS: Patients aged 6 months to 18 years with fever or history of fever within the past 7 days with no focus, or a suspected respiratory tract infection, arriving at 2 health facilities were randomized to either the intervention package or standard practice. The primary outcomes were the proportions of patients who recovered at day 7 (D7) and patients prescribed antibiotics at day 0. RESULTS: Of 1718 patients randomized, 1681 (97.8%; intervention: 844; control: 837) completed follow-up: 99.5% recovered at D7 in the intervention arm versus 100% in standard practice (P = .135). Antibiotics were prescribed to 40.6% of patients in the intervention group versus 57.5% in the control arm (risk ratio: 29.3%; 95% CI: 21.8–36.0%; risk difference [RD]: −16.8%; 95% CI: −21.7% to −12.0%; P < .001), which translates to 1 additional antibiotic prescription saved every 6 (95% CI: 5–8) consultations. This reduction was significant regardless of test results for malaria, but was greater in patients without malaria (RD: −46.0%; −54.7% to −37.4%; P < .001), those with a respiratory diagnosis (RD: −38.2%; −43.8% to −32.6%; P < .001), and in children 6–59 months old (RD: −20.4%; −26.0% to −14.9%; P < .001). Except for the period July–September, the reduction was consistent across the other quarters (P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: The implementation of the package can reduce inappropriate antibiotic prescription without compromising clinical outcomes. CLINICAL TRIALS REGISTRATION: clinicaltrials.gov; NCT04081051. Oxford University Press 2023-07-25 /pmc/articles/PMC10368409/ /pubmed/37490742 http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/cid/ciad331 Text en © The Author(s) 2023. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Infectious Diseases Society of America. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted reuse, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Supplement Article
Kiemde, Francois
Valia, Daniel
Kabore, Berenger
Rouamba, Toussaint
Kone, Alima Nadine
Sawadogo, Seydou
Compaore, Adelaide
Salami, Olawale
Horgan, Philip
Moore, Catrin E
Dittrich, Sabine
Nkeramahame, Juvenal
Olliaro, Piero
Tinto, Halidou
A Randomized Trial to Assess the Impact of a Package of Diagnostic Tools and Diagnostic Algorithm on Antibiotic Prescriptions for the Management of Febrile Illnesses Among Children and Adolescents in Primary Health Facilities in Burkina Faso
title A Randomized Trial to Assess the Impact of a Package of Diagnostic Tools and Diagnostic Algorithm on Antibiotic Prescriptions for the Management of Febrile Illnesses Among Children and Adolescents in Primary Health Facilities in Burkina Faso
title_full A Randomized Trial to Assess the Impact of a Package of Diagnostic Tools and Diagnostic Algorithm on Antibiotic Prescriptions for the Management of Febrile Illnesses Among Children and Adolescents in Primary Health Facilities in Burkina Faso
title_fullStr A Randomized Trial to Assess the Impact of a Package of Diagnostic Tools and Diagnostic Algorithm on Antibiotic Prescriptions for the Management of Febrile Illnesses Among Children and Adolescents in Primary Health Facilities in Burkina Faso
title_full_unstemmed A Randomized Trial to Assess the Impact of a Package of Diagnostic Tools and Diagnostic Algorithm on Antibiotic Prescriptions for the Management of Febrile Illnesses Among Children and Adolescents in Primary Health Facilities in Burkina Faso
title_short A Randomized Trial to Assess the Impact of a Package of Diagnostic Tools and Diagnostic Algorithm on Antibiotic Prescriptions for the Management of Febrile Illnesses Among Children and Adolescents in Primary Health Facilities in Burkina Faso
title_sort randomized trial to assess the impact of a package of diagnostic tools and diagnostic algorithm on antibiotic prescriptions for the management of febrile illnesses among children and adolescents in primary health facilities in burkina faso
topic Supplement Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10368409/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37490742
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/cid/ciad331
work_keys_str_mv AT kiemdefrancois arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT valiadaniel arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT kaboreberenger arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT rouambatoussaint arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT konealimanadine arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT sawadogoseydou arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT compaoreadelaide arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT salamiolawale arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT horganphilip arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT moorecatrine arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT dittrichsabine arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT nkeramahamejuvenal arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT olliaropiero arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT tintohalidou arandomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT kiemdefrancois randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT valiadaniel randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT kaboreberenger randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT rouambatoussaint randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT konealimanadine randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT sawadogoseydou randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT compaoreadelaide randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT salamiolawale randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT horganphilip randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT moorecatrine randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT dittrichsabine randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT nkeramahamejuvenal randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT olliaropiero randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso
AT tintohalidou randomizedtrialtoassesstheimpactofapackageofdiagnostictoolsanddiagnosticalgorithmonantibioticprescriptionsforthemanagementoffebrileillnessesamongchildrenandadolescentsinprimaryhealthfacilitiesinburkinafaso