Early radiographic osseointegration of a novel highly porous 3D-printed titanium collar for megaprostheses compared to a previous generation smooth HA-coated collar

PURPOSE: Extracortical osseointegration at the collar-bone interface of megaprostheses is associated with improved implant stability, lower rates of stem fracture and loosening. The use of hydroxy-apatite (HA-) coated collars showed mixed results in previously published reports. A novel collar system has recently become available utilizing additive manufacturing technology to create a highly porous titanium collar with a calcium-phosphate coated surface. The aim of this study was to evaluate our early experience with this novel collar and compare it to the previously used HA-coated model. METHODS: Twenty patients who underwent megaprostheses implantation utilizing the novel collar system were case matched to 20 patients who had previously undergone a HA-coated collar. A minimum radiological follow-up of three months was available in all included patients. Osseointegration was evaluated using postoperative plain radiographs in two planes based on a previously published semi-quantitative score. RESULTS: Compared to the HA-coated collar the use of the novel highly porous collar was associated with a higher proportion of cases demonstrating osseointegration at the bone-collar interface (80% vs. 65%). Application of the highly porous collar led to a significantly shortened time to reach the final ongrowth score (173 ± 89 days vs. 299 ± 165 days, p < 0.05). At one year follow-up, 90% of the novel collars had reached their final osseoingration grade compared to 50% in the HA-coated collar group (p < 0.001). Radiological osseointegration was seen in 71% for highly porous collars where the indication was revision arthroplasty, compared to 27% in reported in the literature. CONCLUSION: These results indicate more reliable and accelerated osseointegration at the bone-collar interface of a novel highly porous collar system compared to a previously used HA-coated collar. Further studies are warranted to confirm these findings.