Cargando…

The robot eyes don't have it. The presence of eyes on collaborative robots yields marginally higher user trust but lower performance

Eye gaze is a prominent feature of human social lives, but little is known on whether fitting eyes on machines makes humans trust them more. In this study we compared subjective and objective markers of human trust when collaborating with eyed and non-eyed robots of the same type. We used virtual re...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Pilacinski, Artur, Pinto, Ana, Oliveira, Soraia, Araújo, Eduardo, Carvalho, Carla, Silva, Paula Alexandra, Matias, Ricardo, Menezes, Paulo, Sousa, Sonia
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Elsevier 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10382291/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37520993
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e18164
_version_ 1785080647410253824
author Pilacinski, Artur
Pinto, Ana
Oliveira, Soraia
Araújo, Eduardo
Carvalho, Carla
Silva, Paula Alexandra
Matias, Ricardo
Menezes, Paulo
Sousa, Sonia
author_facet Pilacinski, Artur
Pinto, Ana
Oliveira, Soraia
Araújo, Eduardo
Carvalho, Carla
Silva, Paula Alexandra
Matias, Ricardo
Menezes, Paulo
Sousa, Sonia
author_sort Pilacinski, Artur
collection PubMed
description Eye gaze is a prominent feature of human social lives, but little is known on whether fitting eyes on machines makes humans trust them more. In this study we compared subjective and objective markers of human trust when collaborating with eyed and non-eyed robots of the same type. We used virtual reality scenes in which we manipulated distance and the presence of eyes on a robot's display during simple collaboration scenes. We found that while collaboration with eyed cobots resulted in slightly higher subjective trust ratings, the objective markers such as pupil size and task completion time indicated it was in fact less comfortable to collaborate with eyed robots. These findings are in line with recent suggestions that anthropomorphism may be actually a detrimental feature of collaborative robots. These findings also show the complex relationship between human objective and subjective markers of trust when collaborating with artificial agents.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10382291
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Elsevier
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-103822912023-07-30 The robot eyes don't have it. The presence of eyes on collaborative robots yields marginally higher user trust but lower performance Pilacinski, Artur Pinto, Ana Oliveira, Soraia Araújo, Eduardo Carvalho, Carla Silva, Paula Alexandra Matias, Ricardo Menezes, Paulo Sousa, Sonia Heliyon Research Article Eye gaze is a prominent feature of human social lives, but little is known on whether fitting eyes on machines makes humans trust them more. In this study we compared subjective and objective markers of human trust when collaborating with eyed and non-eyed robots of the same type. We used virtual reality scenes in which we manipulated distance and the presence of eyes on a robot's display during simple collaboration scenes. We found that while collaboration with eyed cobots resulted in slightly higher subjective trust ratings, the objective markers such as pupil size and task completion time indicated it was in fact less comfortable to collaborate with eyed robots. These findings are in line with recent suggestions that anthropomorphism may be actually a detrimental feature of collaborative robots. These findings also show the complex relationship between human objective and subjective markers of trust when collaborating with artificial agents. Elsevier 2023-07-11 /pmc/articles/PMC10382291/ /pubmed/37520993 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e18164 Text en © 2023 Published by Elsevier Ltd. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
spellingShingle Research Article
Pilacinski, Artur
Pinto, Ana
Oliveira, Soraia
Araújo, Eduardo
Carvalho, Carla
Silva, Paula Alexandra
Matias, Ricardo
Menezes, Paulo
Sousa, Sonia
The robot eyes don't have it. The presence of eyes on collaborative robots yields marginally higher user trust but lower performance
title The robot eyes don't have it. The presence of eyes on collaborative robots yields marginally higher user trust but lower performance
title_full The robot eyes don't have it. The presence of eyes on collaborative robots yields marginally higher user trust but lower performance
title_fullStr The robot eyes don't have it. The presence of eyes on collaborative robots yields marginally higher user trust but lower performance
title_full_unstemmed The robot eyes don't have it. The presence of eyes on collaborative robots yields marginally higher user trust but lower performance
title_short The robot eyes don't have it. The presence of eyes on collaborative robots yields marginally higher user trust but lower performance
title_sort robot eyes don't have it. the presence of eyes on collaborative robots yields marginally higher user trust but lower performance
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10382291/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37520993
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e18164
work_keys_str_mv AT pilacinskiartur theroboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT pintoana theroboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT oliveirasoraia theroboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT araujoeduardo theroboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT carvalhocarla theroboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT silvapaulaalexandra theroboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT matiasricardo theroboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT menezespaulo theroboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT sousasonia theroboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT pilacinskiartur roboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT pintoana roboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT oliveirasoraia roboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT araujoeduardo roboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT carvalhocarla roboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT silvapaulaalexandra roboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT matiasricardo roboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT menezespaulo roboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance
AT sousasonia roboteyesdonthaveitthepresenceofeyesoncollaborativerobotsyieldsmarginallyhigherusertrustbutlowerperformance