Cargando…
Real-World Validation of Molecular International Prognostic Scoring System for Myelodysplastic Syndromes
Myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS) are heterogeneous myeloid neoplasms in which a risk-adapted treatment strategy is needed. Recently, a new clinical-molecular prognostic model, the Molecular International Prognostic Scoring System (IPSS-M) was proposed to improve the prediction of clinical outcome of...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Wolters Kluwer Health
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10414702/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36930857 http://dx.doi.org/10.1200/JCO.22.01784 |
_version_ | 1785087398824116224 |
---|---|
author | Sauta, Elisabetta Robin, Marie Bersanelli, Matteo Travaglino, Erica Meggendorfer, Manja Zhao, Lin-Pierre Caballero Berrocal, Juan Carlos Sala, Claudia Maggioni, Giulia Bernardi, Massimo Di Grazia, Carmen Vago, Luca Rivoli, Giulia Borin, Lorenza D'Amico, Saverio Tentori, Cristina Astrid Ubezio, Marta Campagna, Alessia Russo, Antonio Mannina, Daniele Lanino, Luca Chiusolo, Patrizia Giaccone, Luisa Voso, Maria Teresa Riva, Marta Oliva, Esther Natalie Zampini, Matteo Riva, Elena Nibourel, Olivier Bicchieri, Marilena Bolli, Niccolo’ Rambaldi, Alessandro Passamonti, Francesco Savevski, Victor Santoro, Armando Germing, Ulrich Kordasti, Shahram Santini, Valeria Diez-Campelo, Maria Sanz, Guillermo Sole, Francesc Kern, Wolfgang Platzbecker, Uwe Ades, Lionel Fenaux, Pierre Haferlach, Torsten Castellani, Gastone Della Porta, Matteo Giovanni |
author_facet | Sauta, Elisabetta Robin, Marie Bersanelli, Matteo Travaglino, Erica Meggendorfer, Manja Zhao, Lin-Pierre Caballero Berrocal, Juan Carlos Sala, Claudia Maggioni, Giulia Bernardi, Massimo Di Grazia, Carmen Vago, Luca Rivoli, Giulia Borin, Lorenza D'Amico, Saverio Tentori, Cristina Astrid Ubezio, Marta Campagna, Alessia Russo, Antonio Mannina, Daniele Lanino, Luca Chiusolo, Patrizia Giaccone, Luisa Voso, Maria Teresa Riva, Marta Oliva, Esther Natalie Zampini, Matteo Riva, Elena Nibourel, Olivier Bicchieri, Marilena Bolli, Niccolo’ Rambaldi, Alessandro Passamonti, Francesco Savevski, Victor Santoro, Armando Germing, Ulrich Kordasti, Shahram Santini, Valeria Diez-Campelo, Maria Sanz, Guillermo Sole, Francesc Kern, Wolfgang Platzbecker, Uwe Ades, Lionel Fenaux, Pierre Haferlach, Torsten Castellani, Gastone Della Porta, Matteo Giovanni |
author_sort | Sauta, Elisabetta |
collection | PubMed |
description | Myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS) are heterogeneous myeloid neoplasms in which a risk-adapted treatment strategy is needed. Recently, a new clinical-molecular prognostic model, the Molecular International Prognostic Scoring System (IPSS-M) was proposed to improve the prediction of clinical outcome of the currently available tool (Revised International Prognostic Scoring System [IPSS-R]). We aimed to provide an extensive validation of IPSS-M. METHODS: A total of 2,876 patients with primary MDS from the GenoMed4All consortium were retrospectively analyzed. RESULTS: IPSS-M improved prognostic discrimination across all clinical end points with respect to IPSS-R (concordance was 0.81 v 0.74 for overall survival and 0.89 v 0.76 for leukemia-free survival, respectively). This was true even in those patients without detectable gene mutations. Compared with the IPSS-R based stratification, the IPSS-M risk group changed in 46% of patients (23.6% and 22.4% of subjects were upstaged and downstaged, respectively). In patients treated with hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT), IPSS-M significantly improved the prediction of the risk of disease relapse and the probability of post-transplantation survival versus IPSS-R (concordance was 0.76 v 0.60 for overall survival and 0.89 v 0.70 for probability of relapse, respectively). In high-risk patients treated with hypomethylating agents (HMA), IPSS-M failed to stratify individual probability of response; response duration and probability of survival were inversely related to IPSS-M risk. Finally, we tested the accuracy in predicting IPSS-M when molecular information was missed and we defined a minimum set of 15 relevant genes associated with high performance of the score. CONCLUSION: IPSS-M improves MDS prognostication and might result in a more effective selection of candidates to HSCT. Additional factors other than gene mutations can be involved in determining HMA sensitivity. The definition of a minimum set of relevant genes may facilitate the clinical implementation of the score. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-10414702 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | Wolters Kluwer Health |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-104147022023-08-11 Real-World Validation of Molecular International Prognostic Scoring System for Myelodysplastic Syndromes Sauta, Elisabetta Robin, Marie Bersanelli, Matteo Travaglino, Erica Meggendorfer, Manja Zhao, Lin-Pierre Caballero Berrocal, Juan Carlos Sala, Claudia Maggioni, Giulia Bernardi, Massimo Di Grazia, Carmen Vago, Luca Rivoli, Giulia Borin, Lorenza D'Amico, Saverio Tentori, Cristina Astrid Ubezio, Marta Campagna, Alessia Russo, Antonio Mannina, Daniele Lanino, Luca Chiusolo, Patrizia Giaccone, Luisa Voso, Maria Teresa Riva, Marta Oliva, Esther Natalie Zampini, Matteo Riva, Elena Nibourel, Olivier Bicchieri, Marilena Bolli, Niccolo’ Rambaldi, Alessandro Passamonti, Francesco Savevski, Victor Santoro, Armando Germing, Ulrich Kordasti, Shahram Santini, Valeria Diez-Campelo, Maria Sanz, Guillermo Sole, Francesc Kern, Wolfgang Platzbecker, Uwe Ades, Lionel Fenaux, Pierre Haferlach, Torsten Castellani, Gastone Della Porta, Matteo Giovanni J Clin Oncol ORIGINAL REPORTS Myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS) are heterogeneous myeloid neoplasms in which a risk-adapted treatment strategy is needed. Recently, a new clinical-molecular prognostic model, the Molecular International Prognostic Scoring System (IPSS-M) was proposed to improve the prediction of clinical outcome of the currently available tool (Revised International Prognostic Scoring System [IPSS-R]). We aimed to provide an extensive validation of IPSS-M. METHODS: A total of 2,876 patients with primary MDS from the GenoMed4All consortium were retrospectively analyzed. RESULTS: IPSS-M improved prognostic discrimination across all clinical end points with respect to IPSS-R (concordance was 0.81 v 0.74 for overall survival and 0.89 v 0.76 for leukemia-free survival, respectively). This was true even in those patients without detectable gene mutations. Compared with the IPSS-R based stratification, the IPSS-M risk group changed in 46% of patients (23.6% and 22.4% of subjects were upstaged and downstaged, respectively). In patients treated with hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT), IPSS-M significantly improved the prediction of the risk of disease relapse and the probability of post-transplantation survival versus IPSS-R (concordance was 0.76 v 0.60 for overall survival and 0.89 v 0.70 for probability of relapse, respectively). In high-risk patients treated with hypomethylating agents (HMA), IPSS-M failed to stratify individual probability of response; response duration and probability of survival were inversely related to IPSS-M risk. Finally, we tested the accuracy in predicting IPSS-M when molecular information was missed and we defined a minimum set of 15 relevant genes associated with high performance of the score. CONCLUSION: IPSS-M improves MDS prognostication and might result in a more effective selection of candidates to HSCT. Additional factors other than gene mutations can be involved in determining HMA sensitivity. The definition of a minimum set of relevant genes may facilitate the clinical implementation of the score. Wolters Kluwer Health 2023-05-20 2023-03-17 /pmc/articles/PMC10414702/ /pubmed/36930857 http://dx.doi.org/10.1200/JCO.22.01784 Text en © 2023 by American Society of Clinical Oncology https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial No Derivatives 4.0 License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ |
spellingShingle | ORIGINAL REPORTS Sauta, Elisabetta Robin, Marie Bersanelli, Matteo Travaglino, Erica Meggendorfer, Manja Zhao, Lin-Pierre Caballero Berrocal, Juan Carlos Sala, Claudia Maggioni, Giulia Bernardi, Massimo Di Grazia, Carmen Vago, Luca Rivoli, Giulia Borin, Lorenza D'Amico, Saverio Tentori, Cristina Astrid Ubezio, Marta Campagna, Alessia Russo, Antonio Mannina, Daniele Lanino, Luca Chiusolo, Patrizia Giaccone, Luisa Voso, Maria Teresa Riva, Marta Oliva, Esther Natalie Zampini, Matteo Riva, Elena Nibourel, Olivier Bicchieri, Marilena Bolli, Niccolo’ Rambaldi, Alessandro Passamonti, Francesco Savevski, Victor Santoro, Armando Germing, Ulrich Kordasti, Shahram Santini, Valeria Diez-Campelo, Maria Sanz, Guillermo Sole, Francesc Kern, Wolfgang Platzbecker, Uwe Ades, Lionel Fenaux, Pierre Haferlach, Torsten Castellani, Gastone Della Porta, Matteo Giovanni Real-World Validation of Molecular International Prognostic Scoring System for Myelodysplastic Syndromes |
title | Real-World Validation of Molecular International Prognostic Scoring System for Myelodysplastic Syndromes |
title_full | Real-World Validation of Molecular International Prognostic Scoring System for Myelodysplastic Syndromes |
title_fullStr | Real-World Validation of Molecular International Prognostic Scoring System for Myelodysplastic Syndromes |
title_full_unstemmed | Real-World Validation of Molecular International Prognostic Scoring System for Myelodysplastic Syndromes |
title_short | Real-World Validation of Molecular International Prognostic Scoring System for Myelodysplastic Syndromes |
title_sort | real-world validation of molecular international prognostic scoring system for myelodysplastic syndromes |
topic | ORIGINAL REPORTS |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10414702/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36930857 http://dx.doi.org/10.1200/JCO.22.01784 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT sautaelisabetta realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT robinmarie realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT bersanellimatteo realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT travaglinoerica realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT meggendorfermanja realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT zhaolinpierre realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT caballeroberrocaljuancarlos realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT salaclaudia realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT maggionigiulia realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT bernardimassimo realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT digraziacarmen realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT vagoluca realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT rivoligiulia realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT borinlorenza realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT damicosaverio realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT tentoricristinaastrid realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT ubeziomarta realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT campagnaalessia realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT russoantonio realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT manninadaniele realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT laninoluca realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT chiusolopatrizia realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT giacconeluisa realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT vosomariateresa realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT rivamarta realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT olivaesthernatalie realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT zampinimatteo realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT rivaelena realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT nibourelolivier realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT bicchierimarilena realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT bolliniccolo realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT rambaldialessandro realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT passamontifrancesco realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT savevskivictor realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT santoroarmando realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT germingulrich realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT kordastishahram realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT santinivaleria realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT diezcampelomaria realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT sanzguillermo realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT solefrancesc realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT kernwolfgang realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT platzbeckeruwe realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT adeslionel realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT fenauxpierre realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT haferlachtorsten realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT castellanigastone realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes AT dellaportamatteogiovanni realworldvalidationofmolecularinternationalprognosticscoringsystemformyelodysplasticsyndromes |