Cargando…

International e-Delphi Consensus Recommendations for the Assessment and Diagnosis of Circadian rest–Activity Rhythm Disorders (CARDs) in Patients with Cancer

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Circadian rhythms are internal changes that happen roughly over a 24-h period. In patients with cancer, healthy circadian rhythms may become abnormal, and these changes have been linked to more symptoms, poorer quality of life, and shorter survival. Circadian rhythms can be observed...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Gouldthorpe, Craig, Ancoli-Israel, Sonia, Cash, Elizabeth, Innominato, Pasquale, Jakobsen, Gunnhild, Lévi, Francis, Miaskowski, Christine, Parganiha, Arti, Pati, Atanu Kumar, Pereira, Deidre, Revell, Victoria, Zeitzer, Jamie M., Davies, Andrew
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10416864/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37568600
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers15153784
_version_ 1785087879179927552
author Gouldthorpe, Craig
Ancoli-Israel, Sonia
Cash, Elizabeth
Innominato, Pasquale
Jakobsen, Gunnhild
Lévi, Francis
Miaskowski, Christine
Parganiha, Arti
Pati, Atanu Kumar
Pereira, Deidre
Revell, Victoria
Zeitzer, Jamie M.
Davies, Andrew
author_facet Gouldthorpe, Craig
Ancoli-Israel, Sonia
Cash, Elizabeth
Innominato, Pasquale
Jakobsen, Gunnhild
Lévi, Francis
Miaskowski, Christine
Parganiha, Arti
Pati, Atanu Kumar
Pereira, Deidre
Revell, Victoria
Zeitzer, Jamie M.
Davies, Andrew
author_sort Gouldthorpe, Craig
collection PubMed
description SIMPLE SUMMARY: Circadian rhythms are internal changes that happen roughly over a 24-h period. In patients with cancer, healthy circadian rhythms may become abnormal, and these changes have been linked to more symptoms, poorer quality of life, and shorter survival. Circadian rhythms can be observed in rest and during physical activity, and disorders of this rest–activity rhythm are common. There are many ways to research and report rest–activity rhythms, and currently, there are no formal criteria to diagnose the condition. This study aimed to provide recommendations on how to assess and diagnose the condition. ABSTRACT: Purpose: Circadian rest–Activity Rhythm Disorders (CARDs) are common in patients with cancer, particularly in advanced disease. CARDs are associated with increased symptom burden, poorer quality of life, and shorter survival. Research and reporting practices lack standardization, and formal diagnostic criteria do not exist. This electronic Delphi (e-Delphi) study aimed to formulate international recommendations for the assessment and diagnosis of CARDs in patients with cancer. Methods: An international e-Delphi was performed using an online platform (Welphi). Round 1 developed statements regarding circadian rest–activity rhythms, diagnostic criteria, and assessment techniques. Rounds 2 and 3 involved participants rating their level of agreement with the statements and providing comments until consensus (defined internally as 67%) and stability between rounds were achieved. Recommendations were then created and distributed to participants for comments before being finalized. Results: Sixteen participants from nine different clinical specialties and seven different countries, with 5–35 years of relevant research experience, were recruited, and thirteen participants completed all three rounds. Of the 164 generated statements, 66% achieved consensus, and responses were stable between the final two rounds. Conclusions: The e-Delphi resulted in international recommendations for assessing and diagnosing CARDs in patients with cancer. These recommendations should ensure standardized research and reporting practices in future studies.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10416864
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-104168642023-08-12 International e-Delphi Consensus Recommendations for the Assessment and Diagnosis of Circadian rest–Activity Rhythm Disorders (CARDs) in Patients with Cancer Gouldthorpe, Craig Ancoli-Israel, Sonia Cash, Elizabeth Innominato, Pasquale Jakobsen, Gunnhild Lévi, Francis Miaskowski, Christine Parganiha, Arti Pati, Atanu Kumar Pereira, Deidre Revell, Victoria Zeitzer, Jamie M. Davies, Andrew Cancers (Basel) Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: Circadian rhythms are internal changes that happen roughly over a 24-h period. In patients with cancer, healthy circadian rhythms may become abnormal, and these changes have been linked to more symptoms, poorer quality of life, and shorter survival. Circadian rhythms can be observed in rest and during physical activity, and disorders of this rest–activity rhythm are common. There are many ways to research and report rest–activity rhythms, and currently, there are no formal criteria to diagnose the condition. This study aimed to provide recommendations on how to assess and diagnose the condition. ABSTRACT: Purpose: Circadian rest–Activity Rhythm Disorders (CARDs) are common in patients with cancer, particularly in advanced disease. CARDs are associated with increased symptom burden, poorer quality of life, and shorter survival. Research and reporting practices lack standardization, and formal diagnostic criteria do not exist. This electronic Delphi (e-Delphi) study aimed to formulate international recommendations for the assessment and diagnosis of CARDs in patients with cancer. Methods: An international e-Delphi was performed using an online platform (Welphi). Round 1 developed statements regarding circadian rest–activity rhythms, diagnostic criteria, and assessment techniques. Rounds 2 and 3 involved participants rating their level of agreement with the statements and providing comments until consensus (defined internally as 67%) and stability between rounds were achieved. Recommendations were then created and distributed to participants for comments before being finalized. Results: Sixteen participants from nine different clinical specialties and seven different countries, with 5–35 years of relevant research experience, were recruited, and thirteen participants completed all three rounds. Of the 164 generated statements, 66% achieved consensus, and responses were stable between the final two rounds. Conclusions: The e-Delphi resulted in international recommendations for assessing and diagnosing CARDs in patients with cancer. These recommendations should ensure standardized research and reporting practices in future studies. MDPI 2023-07-26 /pmc/articles/PMC10416864/ /pubmed/37568600 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers15153784 Text en © 2023 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Gouldthorpe, Craig
Ancoli-Israel, Sonia
Cash, Elizabeth
Innominato, Pasquale
Jakobsen, Gunnhild
Lévi, Francis
Miaskowski, Christine
Parganiha, Arti
Pati, Atanu Kumar
Pereira, Deidre
Revell, Victoria
Zeitzer, Jamie M.
Davies, Andrew
International e-Delphi Consensus Recommendations for the Assessment and Diagnosis of Circadian rest–Activity Rhythm Disorders (CARDs) in Patients with Cancer
title International e-Delphi Consensus Recommendations for the Assessment and Diagnosis of Circadian rest–Activity Rhythm Disorders (CARDs) in Patients with Cancer
title_full International e-Delphi Consensus Recommendations for the Assessment and Diagnosis of Circadian rest–Activity Rhythm Disorders (CARDs) in Patients with Cancer
title_fullStr International e-Delphi Consensus Recommendations for the Assessment and Diagnosis of Circadian rest–Activity Rhythm Disorders (CARDs) in Patients with Cancer
title_full_unstemmed International e-Delphi Consensus Recommendations for the Assessment and Diagnosis of Circadian rest–Activity Rhythm Disorders (CARDs) in Patients with Cancer
title_short International e-Delphi Consensus Recommendations for the Assessment and Diagnosis of Circadian rest–Activity Rhythm Disorders (CARDs) in Patients with Cancer
title_sort international e-delphi consensus recommendations for the assessment and diagnosis of circadian rest–activity rhythm disorders (cards) in patients with cancer
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10416864/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37568600
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers15153784
work_keys_str_mv AT gouldthorpecraig internationaledelphiconsensusrecommendationsfortheassessmentanddiagnosisofcircadianrestactivityrhythmdisorderscardsinpatientswithcancer
AT ancoliisraelsonia internationaledelphiconsensusrecommendationsfortheassessmentanddiagnosisofcircadianrestactivityrhythmdisorderscardsinpatientswithcancer
AT cashelizabeth internationaledelphiconsensusrecommendationsfortheassessmentanddiagnosisofcircadianrestactivityrhythmdisorderscardsinpatientswithcancer
AT innominatopasquale internationaledelphiconsensusrecommendationsfortheassessmentanddiagnosisofcircadianrestactivityrhythmdisorderscardsinpatientswithcancer
AT jakobsengunnhild internationaledelphiconsensusrecommendationsfortheassessmentanddiagnosisofcircadianrestactivityrhythmdisorderscardsinpatientswithcancer
AT levifrancis internationaledelphiconsensusrecommendationsfortheassessmentanddiagnosisofcircadianrestactivityrhythmdisorderscardsinpatientswithcancer
AT miaskowskichristine internationaledelphiconsensusrecommendationsfortheassessmentanddiagnosisofcircadianrestactivityrhythmdisorderscardsinpatientswithcancer
AT parganihaarti internationaledelphiconsensusrecommendationsfortheassessmentanddiagnosisofcircadianrestactivityrhythmdisorderscardsinpatientswithcancer
AT patiatanukumar internationaledelphiconsensusrecommendationsfortheassessmentanddiagnosisofcircadianrestactivityrhythmdisorderscardsinpatientswithcancer
AT pereiradeidre internationaledelphiconsensusrecommendationsfortheassessmentanddiagnosisofcircadianrestactivityrhythmdisorderscardsinpatientswithcancer
AT revellvictoria internationaledelphiconsensusrecommendationsfortheassessmentanddiagnosisofcircadianrestactivityrhythmdisorderscardsinpatientswithcancer
AT zeitzerjamiem internationaledelphiconsensusrecommendationsfortheassessmentanddiagnosisofcircadianrestactivityrhythmdisorderscardsinpatientswithcancer
AT daviesandrew internationaledelphiconsensusrecommendationsfortheassessmentanddiagnosisofcircadianrestactivityrhythmdisorderscardsinpatientswithcancer