Cargando…
The multicenter effectiveness study of inpatient and day hospital treatment in departments of psychosomatic medicine and psychotherapy in Germany
BACKGROUND: Reliable outcome data of psychosomatic inpatient and day hospital treatment with a focus on psychotherapy are important to strengthen ecological validity by assessing the reality of mental health care in the field. This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of inpatient and day hospit...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Frontiers Media S.A.
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10440687/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37608994 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2023.1155582 |
_version_ | 1785093206464004096 |
---|---|
author | Doering, Stephan Herpertz, Stephan Pape, Magdalena Hofmann, Tobias Rose, Matthias Imbierowicz, Katrin Geiser, Franziska Bierling, Antonie Louise Weidner, Kerstin Rademacher, Jörg Michalek, Silke Morawa, Eva Erim, Yesim Teigelack, Per Teufel, Martin Hartmann, Armin Lahmann, Claas Peters, Eva Milena Johanne Kruse, Johannes von Boetticher, Dirk Herrmann-Lingen, Christoph Nöhre, Mariel de Zwaan, Martina Dinger, Ulrike Friederich, Hans-Christoph Niecke, Alexander Albus, Christian Zwerenz, Rüdiger Beutel, Manfred Sattel, Heribert Christian Henningsen, Peter Stein, Barbara Waller, Christiane Hake, Karsten Spitzer, Carsten Stengel, Andreas Zipfel, Stephan Weimer, Katja Gündel, Harald Kessler, Henrik |
author_facet | Doering, Stephan Herpertz, Stephan Pape, Magdalena Hofmann, Tobias Rose, Matthias Imbierowicz, Katrin Geiser, Franziska Bierling, Antonie Louise Weidner, Kerstin Rademacher, Jörg Michalek, Silke Morawa, Eva Erim, Yesim Teigelack, Per Teufel, Martin Hartmann, Armin Lahmann, Claas Peters, Eva Milena Johanne Kruse, Johannes von Boetticher, Dirk Herrmann-Lingen, Christoph Nöhre, Mariel de Zwaan, Martina Dinger, Ulrike Friederich, Hans-Christoph Niecke, Alexander Albus, Christian Zwerenz, Rüdiger Beutel, Manfred Sattel, Heribert Christian Henningsen, Peter Stein, Barbara Waller, Christiane Hake, Karsten Spitzer, Carsten Stengel, Andreas Zipfel, Stephan Weimer, Katja Gündel, Harald Kessler, Henrik |
author_sort | Doering, Stephan |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: Reliable outcome data of psychosomatic inpatient and day hospital treatment with a focus on psychotherapy are important to strengthen ecological validity by assessing the reality of mental health care in the field. This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of inpatient and day hospital treatment in German university departments of Psychosomatic Medicine and Psychotherapy in a prospective, naturalistic, multicenter design including structured assessments. METHODS: Structured interviews were used to diagnose mental disorders according to ICD-10 and DSM-IV at baseline. Depression, anxiety, somatization, eating disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms, as well as personality functioning were assessed by means of questionnaires on admission and at discharge. RESULTS: 2,094 patients recruited by 19 participating university hospitals consented to participation in the study. Effect sizes for each of the outcome criteria were calculated for 4–5 sub-groups per outcome domain with differing severity at baseline. Pre-post effect sizes for patients with moderate and high symptom severity at baseline ranged from d = 0.78 to d = 3.61 with symptoms of PTSD, depression, and anxiety showing the largest and somatization as well as personality functioning showing somewhat smaller effects. CONCLUSIONS: Inpatient and day hospital treatment in German university departments of Psychosomatic Medicine and Psychotherapy is effective under field conditions. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: https://drks.de/search/de/trial/DRKS00016412, identifier: DRKS00016412. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-10440687 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | Frontiers Media S.A. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-104406872023-08-22 The multicenter effectiveness study of inpatient and day hospital treatment in departments of psychosomatic medicine and psychotherapy in Germany Doering, Stephan Herpertz, Stephan Pape, Magdalena Hofmann, Tobias Rose, Matthias Imbierowicz, Katrin Geiser, Franziska Bierling, Antonie Louise Weidner, Kerstin Rademacher, Jörg Michalek, Silke Morawa, Eva Erim, Yesim Teigelack, Per Teufel, Martin Hartmann, Armin Lahmann, Claas Peters, Eva Milena Johanne Kruse, Johannes von Boetticher, Dirk Herrmann-Lingen, Christoph Nöhre, Mariel de Zwaan, Martina Dinger, Ulrike Friederich, Hans-Christoph Niecke, Alexander Albus, Christian Zwerenz, Rüdiger Beutel, Manfred Sattel, Heribert Christian Henningsen, Peter Stein, Barbara Waller, Christiane Hake, Karsten Spitzer, Carsten Stengel, Andreas Zipfel, Stephan Weimer, Katja Gündel, Harald Kessler, Henrik Front Psychiatry Psychiatry BACKGROUND: Reliable outcome data of psychosomatic inpatient and day hospital treatment with a focus on psychotherapy are important to strengthen ecological validity by assessing the reality of mental health care in the field. This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of inpatient and day hospital treatment in German university departments of Psychosomatic Medicine and Psychotherapy in a prospective, naturalistic, multicenter design including structured assessments. METHODS: Structured interviews were used to diagnose mental disorders according to ICD-10 and DSM-IV at baseline. Depression, anxiety, somatization, eating disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms, as well as personality functioning were assessed by means of questionnaires on admission and at discharge. RESULTS: 2,094 patients recruited by 19 participating university hospitals consented to participation in the study. Effect sizes for each of the outcome criteria were calculated for 4–5 sub-groups per outcome domain with differing severity at baseline. Pre-post effect sizes for patients with moderate and high symptom severity at baseline ranged from d = 0.78 to d = 3.61 with symptoms of PTSD, depression, and anxiety showing the largest and somatization as well as personality functioning showing somewhat smaller effects. CONCLUSIONS: Inpatient and day hospital treatment in German university departments of Psychosomatic Medicine and Psychotherapy is effective under field conditions. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: https://drks.de/search/de/trial/DRKS00016412, identifier: DRKS00016412. Frontiers Media S.A. 2023-08-07 /pmc/articles/PMC10440687/ /pubmed/37608994 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2023.1155582 Text en Copyright © 2023 Doering, Herpertz, Pape, Hofmann, Rose, Imbierowicz, Geiser, Bierling, Weidner, Rademacher, Michalek, Morawa, Erim, Teigelack, Teufel, Hartmann, Lahmann, Peters, Kruse, von Boetticher, Herrmann-Lingen, Nöhre, de Zwaan, Dinger, Friederich, Niecke, Albus, Zwerenz, Beutel, Sattel, Henningsen, Stein, Waller, Hake, Spitzer, Stengel, Zipfel, Weimer, Gündel and Kessler. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms. |
spellingShingle | Psychiatry Doering, Stephan Herpertz, Stephan Pape, Magdalena Hofmann, Tobias Rose, Matthias Imbierowicz, Katrin Geiser, Franziska Bierling, Antonie Louise Weidner, Kerstin Rademacher, Jörg Michalek, Silke Morawa, Eva Erim, Yesim Teigelack, Per Teufel, Martin Hartmann, Armin Lahmann, Claas Peters, Eva Milena Johanne Kruse, Johannes von Boetticher, Dirk Herrmann-Lingen, Christoph Nöhre, Mariel de Zwaan, Martina Dinger, Ulrike Friederich, Hans-Christoph Niecke, Alexander Albus, Christian Zwerenz, Rüdiger Beutel, Manfred Sattel, Heribert Christian Henningsen, Peter Stein, Barbara Waller, Christiane Hake, Karsten Spitzer, Carsten Stengel, Andreas Zipfel, Stephan Weimer, Katja Gündel, Harald Kessler, Henrik The multicenter effectiveness study of inpatient and day hospital treatment in departments of psychosomatic medicine and psychotherapy in Germany |
title | The multicenter effectiveness study of inpatient and day hospital treatment in departments of psychosomatic medicine and psychotherapy in Germany |
title_full | The multicenter effectiveness study of inpatient and day hospital treatment in departments of psychosomatic medicine and psychotherapy in Germany |
title_fullStr | The multicenter effectiveness study of inpatient and day hospital treatment in departments of psychosomatic medicine and psychotherapy in Germany |
title_full_unstemmed | The multicenter effectiveness study of inpatient and day hospital treatment in departments of psychosomatic medicine and psychotherapy in Germany |
title_short | The multicenter effectiveness study of inpatient and day hospital treatment in departments of psychosomatic medicine and psychotherapy in Germany |
title_sort | multicenter effectiveness study of inpatient and day hospital treatment in departments of psychosomatic medicine and psychotherapy in germany |
topic | Psychiatry |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10440687/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37608994 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2023.1155582 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT doeringstephan themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT herpertzstephan themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT papemagdalena themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT hofmanntobias themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT rosematthias themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT imbierowiczkatrin themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT geiserfranziska themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT bierlingantonielouise themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT weidnerkerstin themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT rademacherjorg themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT michaleksilke themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT morawaeva themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT erimyesim themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT teigelackper themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT teufelmartin themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT hartmannarmin themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT lahmannclaas themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT petersevamilenajohanne themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT krusejohannes themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT vonboetticherdirk themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT herrmannlingenchristoph themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT nohremariel themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT dezwaanmartina themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT dingerulrike themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT friederichhanschristoph themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT nieckealexander themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT albuschristian themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT zwerenzrudiger themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT beutelmanfred themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT sattelheribertchristian themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT henningsenpeter themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT steinbarbara themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT wallerchristiane themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT hakekarsten themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT spitzercarsten themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT stengelandreas themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT zipfelstephan themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT weimerkatja themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT gundelharald themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT kesslerhenrik themulticentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT doeringstephan multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT herpertzstephan multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT papemagdalena multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT hofmanntobias multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT rosematthias multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT imbierowiczkatrin multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT geiserfranziska multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT bierlingantonielouise multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT weidnerkerstin multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT rademacherjorg multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT michaleksilke multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT morawaeva multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT erimyesim multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT teigelackper multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT teufelmartin multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT hartmannarmin multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT lahmannclaas multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT petersevamilenajohanne multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT krusejohannes multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT vonboetticherdirk multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT herrmannlingenchristoph multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT nohremariel multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT dezwaanmartina multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT dingerulrike multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT friederichhanschristoph multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT nieckealexander multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT albuschristian multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT zwerenzrudiger multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT beutelmanfred multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT sattelheribertchristian multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT henningsenpeter multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT steinbarbara multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT wallerchristiane multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT hakekarsten multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT spitzercarsten multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT stengelandreas multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT zipfelstephan multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT weimerkatja multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT gundelharald multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany AT kesslerhenrik multicentereffectivenessstudyofinpatientanddayhospitaltreatmentindepartmentsofpsychosomaticmedicineandpsychotherapyingermany |