Cargando…

What interventions should we implement in England's mental health services? The mental health implementation network (MHIN) mixed-methods approach to rapid prioritisation

INTRODUCTION: Setting mental health priorities helps researchers, policy makers, and service funders improve mental health services. In the context of a national mental health implementation programme in England, this study aims to identify implementable evidence-based interventions in key priority...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Ahuja, Shalini, Phillips, Lawrence, Smartt, Caroline, Khalid, Sundus, Coldham, Tina, Fischer, Laura, Rae, Sarah, Sevdalis, Nick, Boaz, Annette, Robinson, Sarah, Gaughran, Fiona, Lelliott, Zoe, Jones, Peter, Thornicroft, Graham, Munshi, Jayati-Das, Drummond, Colin, Perez, Jesus, Littlejohns, Peter
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Frontiers Media S.A. 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10456870/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37638343
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/frhs.2023.1204207
_version_ 1785096803212853248
author Ahuja, Shalini
Phillips, Lawrence
Smartt, Caroline
Khalid, Sundus
Coldham, Tina
Fischer, Laura
Rae, Sarah
Sevdalis, Nick
Boaz, Annette
Robinson, Sarah
Gaughran, Fiona
Lelliott, Zoe
Jones, Peter
Thornicroft, Graham
Munshi, Jayati-Das
Drummond, Colin
Perez, Jesus
Littlejohns, Peter
author_facet Ahuja, Shalini
Phillips, Lawrence
Smartt, Caroline
Khalid, Sundus
Coldham, Tina
Fischer, Laura
Rae, Sarah
Sevdalis, Nick
Boaz, Annette
Robinson, Sarah
Gaughran, Fiona
Lelliott, Zoe
Jones, Peter
Thornicroft, Graham
Munshi, Jayati-Das
Drummond, Colin
Perez, Jesus
Littlejohns, Peter
author_sort Ahuja, Shalini
collection PubMed
description INTRODUCTION: Setting mental health priorities helps researchers, policy makers, and service funders improve mental health services. In the context of a national mental health implementation programme in England, this study aims to identify implementable evidence-based interventions in key priority areas to improve mental health service delivery. METHODS: A mixed-methods research design was used for a three step prioritisation approach involving systematic scoping reviews (additional manuscript under development), expert consultations and data triangulation. Groups with diverse expertise, including experts by experience, worked together to improve decision-making quality by promoting more inclusive and comprehensive discussions. A multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) model was used to combine participants' varied opinions, data and judgments about the data's relevance to the issues at hand during a decision conferencing workshop where the priorities were finalised. RESULTS: The study identified mental health interventions in three mental health priority areas: mental health inequalities, child and adolescent mental health, comorbidities with a focus on integration of mental and physical health services and mental health and substance misuse problems. Key interventions in all the priority areas are outlined. The programme is putting some of these evidence-based interventions into action nationwide in each of these three priority mental health priority areas. CONCLUSION: We report an inclusive attempt to ensure that the list of mental health service priorities agrees with perceived needs on the ground and focuses on evidence-based interventions. Other fields of healthcare may also benefit from this methodological approach if they need to make rapid health-prioritisation decisions.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10456870
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-104568702023-08-26 What interventions should we implement in England's mental health services? The mental health implementation network (MHIN) mixed-methods approach to rapid prioritisation Ahuja, Shalini Phillips, Lawrence Smartt, Caroline Khalid, Sundus Coldham, Tina Fischer, Laura Rae, Sarah Sevdalis, Nick Boaz, Annette Robinson, Sarah Gaughran, Fiona Lelliott, Zoe Jones, Peter Thornicroft, Graham Munshi, Jayati-Das Drummond, Colin Perez, Jesus Littlejohns, Peter Front Health Serv Health Services INTRODUCTION: Setting mental health priorities helps researchers, policy makers, and service funders improve mental health services. In the context of a national mental health implementation programme in England, this study aims to identify implementable evidence-based interventions in key priority areas to improve mental health service delivery. METHODS: A mixed-methods research design was used for a three step prioritisation approach involving systematic scoping reviews (additional manuscript under development), expert consultations and data triangulation. Groups with diverse expertise, including experts by experience, worked together to improve decision-making quality by promoting more inclusive and comprehensive discussions. A multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) model was used to combine participants' varied opinions, data and judgments about the data's relevance to the issues at hand during a decision conferencing workshop where the priorities were finalised. RESULTS: The study identified mental health interventions in three mental health priority areas: mental health inequalities, child and adolescent mental health, comorbidities with a focus on integration of mental and physical health services and mental health and substance misuse problems. Key interventions in all the priority areas are outlined. The programme is putting some of these evidence-based interventions into action nationwide in each of these three priority mental health priority areas. CONCLUSION: We report an inclusive attempt to ensure that the list of mental health service priorities agrees with perceived needs on the ground and focuses on evidence-based interventions. Other fields of healthcare may also benefit from this methodological approach if they need to make rapid health-prioritisation decisions. Frontiers Media S.A. 2023-08-11 /pmc/articles/PMC10456870/ /pubmed/37638343 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/frhs.2023.1204207 Text en © 2023 Ahuja, Phillips, Smartt, Khalid, Coldham, Fischer, Rae, Sevdalis, Boaz, Robinson, Gaughran, Lelliott, Jones, Thornicroft, Munshi, Drummond, Perez and Littlejohns. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY) (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) . The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
spellingShingle Health Services
Ahuja, Shalini
Phillips, Lawrence
Smartt, Caroline
Khalid, Sundus
Coldham, Tina
Fischer, Laura
Rae, Sarah
Sevdalis, Nick
Boaz, Annette
Robinson, Sarah
Gaughran, Fiona
Lelliott, Zoe
Jones, Peter
Thornicroft, Graham
Munshi, Jayati-Das
Drummond, Colin
Perez, Jesus
Littlejohns, Peter
What interventions should we implement in England's mental health services? The mental health implementation network (MHIN) mixed-methods approach to rapid prioritisation
title What interventions should we implement in England's mental health services? The mental health implementation network (MHIN) mixed-methods approach to rapid prioritisation
title_full What interventions should we implement in England's mental health services? The mental health implementation network (MHIN) mixed-methods approach to rapid prioritisation
title_fullStr What interventions should we implement in England's mental health services? The mental health implementation network (MHIN) mixed-methods approach to rapid prioritisation
title_full_unstemmed What interventions should we implement in England's mental health services? The mental health implementation network (MHIN) mixed-methods approach to rapid prioritisation
title_short What interventions should we implement in England's mental health services? The mental health implementation network (MHIN) mixed-methods approach to rapid prioritisation
title_sort what interventions should we implement in england's mental health services? the mental health implementation network (mhin) mixed-methods approach to rapid prioritisation
topic Health Services
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10456870/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37638343
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/frhs.2023.1204207
work_keys_str_mv AT ahujashalini whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT phillipslawrence whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT smarttcaroline whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT khalidsundus whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT coldhamtina whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT fischerlaura whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT raesarah whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT sevdalisnick whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT boazannette whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT robinsonsarah whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT gaughranfiona whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT lelliottzoe whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT jonespeter whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT thornicroftgraham whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT munshijayatidas whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT drummondcolin whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT perezjesus whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation
AT littlejohnspeter whatinterventionsshouldweimplementinenglandsmentalhealthservicesthementalhealthimplementationnetworkmhinmixedmethodsapproachtorapidprioritisation