Cargando…

The Prognostic Effect of Immune Cell Infiltration Depends on Molecular Subtype in Endometrioid Ovarian Carcinomas

PURPOSE: Endometrioid ovarian carcinoma (ENOC) is the second most-common type of ovarian carcinoma, comprising 10%–20% of cases. Recently, the study of ENOC has benefitted from comparisons to endometrial carcinomas including defining ENOC with four prognostic molecular subtypes. Each subtype suggest...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Heinze, Karolin, Cairns, Evan S., Thornton, Shelby, Harris, Bronwyn, Milne, Katy, Grube, Marcel, Meyer, Charlotte, Karnezis, Anthony N., Fereday, Sian, Garsed, Dale W., Leung, Samuel C.Y., Chiu, Derek S., Moubarak, Malak, Harter, Philipp, Heitz, Florian, McAlpine, Jessica N., DeFazio, Anna, Bowtell, David D.L., Goode, Ellen L., Pike, Malcolm, Ramus, Susan J., Pearce, C. Leigh, Staebler, Annette, Köbel, Martin, Kommoss, Stefan, Talhouk, Aline, Nelson, Brad H., Anglesio, Michael S.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: American Association for Cancer Research 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10472107/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37339172
http://dx.doi.org/10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-22-3815
_version_ 1785100003723706368
author Heinze, Karolin
Cairns, Evan S.
Thornton, Shelby
Harris, Bronwyn
Milne, Katy
Grube, Marcel
Meyer, Charlotte
Karnezis, Anthony N.
Fereday, Sian
Garsed, Dale W.
Leung, Samuel C.Y.
Chiu, Derek S.
Moubarak, Malak
Harter, Philipp
Heitz, Florian
McAlpine, Jessica N.
DeFazio, Anna
Bowtell, David D.L.
Goode, Ellen L.
Pike, Malcolm
Ramus, Susan J.
Pearce, C. Leigh
Staebler, Annette
Köbel, Martin
Kommoss, Stefan
Talhouk, Aline
Nelson, Brad H.
Anglesio, Michael S.
author_facet Heinze, Karolin
Cairns, Evan S.
Thornton, Shelby
Harris, Bronwyn
Milne, Katy
Grube, Marcel
Meyer, Charlotte
Karnezis, Anthony N.
Fereday, Sian
Garsed, Dale W.
Leung, Samuel C.Y.
Chiu, Derek S.
Moubarak, Malak
Harter, Philipp
Heitz, Florian
McAlpine, Jessica N.
DeFazio, Anna
Bowtell, David D.L.
Goode, Ellen L.
Pike, Malcolm
Ramus, Susan J.
Pearce, C. Leigh
Staebler, Annette
Köbel, Martin
Kommoss, Stefan
Talhouk, Aline
Nelson, Brad H.
Anglesio, Michael S.
author_sort Heinze, Karolin
collection PubMed
description PURPOSE: Endometrioid ovarian carcinoma (ENOC) is the second most-common type of ovarian carcinoma, comprising 10%–20% of cases. Recently, the study of ENOC has benefitted from comparisons to endometrial carcinomas including defining ENOC with four prognostic molecular subtypes. Each subtype suggests differential mechanisms of progression, although tumor-initiating events remain elusive. There is evidence that the ovarian microenvironment may be critical to early lesion establishment and progression. However, while immune infiltrates have been well studied in high-grade serous ovarian carcinoma, studies in ENOC are limited. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: We report on 210 ENOC, with clinical follow-up and molecular subtype annotation. Using multiplex IHC and immunofluorescence, we examine the prevalence of T-cell lineage, B-cell lineage, macrophages, and populations with programmed cell death protein 1 or programmed death-ligand 1 across subtypes of ENOC. RESULTS: Immune cell infiltrates in tumor epithelium and stroma showed higher densities in ENOC subtypes with known high mutation burden (POLEmut and MMRd). While molecular subtypes were prognostically significant, immune infiltrates were not (overall survival P > 0.2). Analysis by molecular subtype revealed that immune cell density was prognostically significant in only the no specific molecular profile (NSMP) subtype, where immune infiltrates lacking B cells (TIL(B minus)) had inferior outcome (disease-specific survival: HR, 4.0; 95% confidence interval, 1.1–14.7; P < 0.05). Similar to endometrial carcinomas, molecular subtype stratification was generally superior to immune response in predicting outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: Subtype stratification is critical for better understanding of ENOC, in particular the distribution and prognostic significance of immune cell infiltrates. The role of B cells in the immune response within NSMP tumors warrants further study.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10472107
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher American Association for Cancer Research
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-104721072023-09-02 The Prognostic Effect of Immune Cell Infiltration Depends on Molecular Subtype in Endometrioid Ovarian Carcinomas Heinze, Karolin Cairns, Evan S. Thornton, Shelby Harris, Bronwyn Milne, Katy Grube, Marcel Meyer, Charlotte Karnezis, Anthony N. Fereday, Sian Garsed, Dale W. Leung, Samuel C.Y. Chiu, Derek S. Moubarak, Malak Harter, Philipp Heitz, Florian McAlpine, Jessica N. DeFazio, Anna Bowtell, David D.L. Goode, Ellen L. Pike, Malcolm Ramus, Susan J. Pearce, C. Leigh Staebler, Annette Köbel, Martin Kommoss, Stefan Talhouk, Aline Nelson, Brad H. Anglesio, Michael S. Clin Cancer Res Translational Cancer Mechanisms and Therapy PURPOSE: Endometrioid ovarian carcinoma (ENOC) is the second most-common type of ovarian carcinoma, comprising 10%–20% of cases. Recently, the study of ENOC has benefitted from comparisons to endometrial carcinomas including defining ENOC with four prognostic molecular subtypes. Each subtype suggests differential mechanisms of progression, although tumor-initiating events remain elusive. There is evidence that the ovarian microenvironment may be critical to early lesion establishment and progression. However, while immune infiltrates have been well studied in high-grade serous ovarian carcinoma, studies in ENOC are limited. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN: We report on 210 ENOC, with clinical follow-up and molecular subtype annotation. Using multiplex IHC and immunofluorescence, we examine the prevalence of T-cell lineage, B-cell lineage, macrophages, and populations with programmed cell death protein 1 or programmed death-ligand 1 across subtypes of ENOC. RESULTS: Immune cell infiltrates in tumor epithelium and stroma showed higher densities in ENOC subtypes with known high mutation burden (POLEmut and MMRd). While molecular subtypes were prognostically significant, immune infiltrates were not (overall survival P > 0.2). Analysis by molecular subtype revealed that immune cell density was prognostically significant in only the no specific molecular profile (NSMP) subtype, where immune infiltrates lacking B cells (TIL(B minus)) had inferior outcome (disease-specific survival: HR, 4.0; 95% confidence interval, 1.1–14.7; P < 0.05). Similar to endometrial carcinomas, molecular subtype stratification was generally superior to immune response in predicting outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: Subtype stratification is critical for better understanding of ENOC, in particular the distribution and prognostic significance of immune cell infiltrates. The role of B cells in the immune response within NSMP tumors warrants further study. American Association for Cancer Research 2023-09-01 2023-06-20 /pmc/articles/PMC10472107/ /pubmed/37339172 http://dx.doi.org/10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-22-3815 Text en ©2023 The Authors; Published by the American Association for Cancer Research https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/This open access article is distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) license.
spellingShingle Translational Cancer Mechanisms and Therapy
Heinze, Karolin
Cairns, Evan S.
Thornton, Shelby
Harris, Bronwyn
Milne, Katy
Grube, Marcel
Meyer, Charlotte
Karnezis, Anthony N.
Fereday, Sian
Garsed, Dale W.
Leung, Samuel C.Y.
Chiu, Derek S.
Moubarak, Malak
Harter, Philipp
Heitz, Florian
McAlpine, Jessica N.
DeFazio, Anna
Bowtell, David D.L.
Goode, Ellen L.
Pike, Malcolm
Ramus, Susan J.
Pearce, C. Leigh
Staebler, Annette
Köbel, Martin
Kommoss, Stefan
Talhouk, Aline
Nelson, Brad H.
Anglesio, Michael S.
The Prognostic Effect of Immune Cell Infiltration Depends on Molecular Subtype in Endometrioid Ovarian Carcinomas
title The Prognostic Effect of Immune Cell Infiltration Depends on Molecular Subtype in Endometrioid Ovarian Carcinomas
title_full The Prognostic Effect of Immune Cell Infiltration Depends on Molecular Subtype in Endometrioid Ovarian Carcinomas
title_fullStr The Prognostic Effect of Immune Cell Infiltration Depends on Molecular Subtype in Endometrioid Ovarian Carcinomas
title_full_unstemmed The Prognostic Effect of Immune Cell Infiltration Depends on Molecular Subtype in Endometrioid Ovarian Carcinomas
title_short The Prognostic Effect of Immune Cell Infiltration Depends on Molecular Subtype in Endometrioid Ovarian Carcinomas
title_sort prognostic effect of immune cell infiltration depends on molecular subtype in endometrioid ovarian carcinomas
topic Translational Cancer Mechanisms and Therapy
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10472107/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37339172
http://dx.doi.org/10.1158/1078-0432.CCR-22-3815
work_keys_str_mv AT heinzekarolin theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT cairnsevans theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT thorntonshelby theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT harrisbronwyn theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT milnekaty theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT grubemarcel theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT meyercharlotte theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT karnezisanthonyn theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT feredaysian theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT garseddalew theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT leungsamuelcy theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT chiudereks theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT moubarakmalak theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT harterphilipp theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT heitzflorian theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT mcalpinejessican theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT defazioanna theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT bowtelldaviddl theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT goodeellenl theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT pikemalcolm theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT ramussusanj theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT pearcecleigh theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT staeblerannette theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT kobelmartin theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT kommossstefan theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT talhoukaline theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT nelsonbradh theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT anglesiomichaels theprognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT heinzekarolin prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT cairnsevans prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT thorntonshelby prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT harrisbronwyn prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT milnekaty prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT grubemarcel prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT meyercharlotte prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT karnezisanthonyn prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT feredaysian prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT garseddalew prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT leungsamuelcy prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT chiudereks prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT moubarakmalak prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT harterphilipp prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT heitzflorian prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT mcalpinejessican prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT defazioanna prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT bowtelldaviddl prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT goodeellenl prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT pikemalcolm prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT ramussusanj prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT pearcecleigh prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT staeblerannette prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT kobelmartin prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT kommossstefan prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT talhoukaline prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT nelsonbradh prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas
AT anglesiomichaels prognosticeffectofimmunecellinfiltrationdependsonmolecularsubtypeinendometrioidovariancarcinomas