Case mix-based changes in health status: A prospective study of elective surgery patients in Vancouver, Canada

INTRODUCTION: Hospital activity is often measured using diagnosis-related groups, or case mix groups, but this information does not represent important aspects of patients’ health outcomes. This study reports on case mix-based changes in health status of elective (planned) surgery patients in Vancouver, Canada. DATA AND METHODS: We used a prospectively recruited cohort of consecutive patients scheduled for planned inpatient or outpatient surgery in six acute care hospitals in Vancouver. All participants completed the EQ-5D(5L) preoperatively and 6 months postoperatively, collected from October 2015 to September 2020 and linked with hospital discharge data. The main outcome was whether patients’ self-reported health status improved among different inpatient and outpatient case mix groups. RESULTS: The study included 1665 participants with completed EQ-5D(5L) preoperatively and postoperatively, representing a 44.8% participation rate across eight inpatient and outpatient surgical case mix categories. All case mix categories were associated with a statistically significant gain in health status (p < .01 or lower) as measured by the utility value and visual analogue scale score. Foot and ankle surgery patients had the lowest preoperative health status (mean utility value: 0.6103), while bariatric surgery patients reported the largest improvements in health status (mean gain in utility value: 0.1515). CONCLUSIONS: This study provides evidence that it was feasible to compare patient-reported outcomes across case mix categories of surgical patients in a consistent manner across a system of hospitals in one province in Canada. Reporting changes in health status of operative case mix categories identifies characteristics of patients more likely to experience significant gains in health.