How Biodiversity, Climate and Landscape Drive Functional Redundancy of British Butterflies

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Functional redundancy, the coexistence of species with similar functional roles, is of critical importance for ecosystem function stability. However, drivers of functional redundancy remain relatively poorly understood. Here, we analyzed four traits of British butterflies and aimed to identify the biotic and abiotic factors that affect the spatial patterns of functional redundancy. The most important factor was taxonomic diversity, with species-rich communities having the highest level of functional redundancy. Temperature was associated with redundancy and with different facets of taxonomic and functional diversity. However, although warmer areas hosted species-rich communities, redundancy was greatest in areas of intermediate mean annual temperature and declined at higher temperatures. This might imply that despite the positive effect of increased temperature on butterfly diversity, warmer and species-rich areas are vulnerable, perhaps due to the land uses dominating in these regions. Landscape heterogeneity promoted species richness, functional redundancy and variation in species and functional composition of the butterfly assemblages, underscoring the importance of maintaining diverse landscapes. ABSTRACT: Biodiversity promotes the functioning of ecosystems, and functional redundancy safeguards this functioning against environmental changes. However, what drives functional redundancy remains unclear. We analyzed taxonomic diversity, functional diversity (richness and β-diversity) and functional redundancy patterns of British butterflies. We explored the effect of temperature and landscape-related variables on richness and redundancy using generalized additive models, and on β-diversity using generalized dissimilarity models. The species richness-functional richness relationship was saturating, indicating functional redundancy in species-rich communities. Assemblages did not deviate from random expectations regarding functional richness. Temperature exerted a significant effect on all diversity aspects and on redundancy, with the latter relationship being unimodal. Landscape-related variables played a role in driving observed patterns. Although taxonomic and functional β-diversity were highly congruent, the model of taxonomic β-diversity explained more deviance than the model of functional β-diversity did. Species-rich butterfly assemblages exhibited functional redundancy. Climate- and landscape-related variables emerged as significant drivers of diversity and redundancy. Τaxonomic β-diversity was more strongly associated with the environmental gradient, while functional β-diversity was driven more strongly by stochasticity. Temperature promoted species richness and β-diversity, but warmer areas exhibited lower levels of functional redundancy. This might be related to the land uses prevailing in warmer areas (e.g., agricultural intensification).