Cargando…

Evaluation of factors leading to poor outcomes for pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia in Mexico: a multi-institutional report of 2,116 patients

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) survival rates in low- and middle-income countries are lower due to deficiencies in multilevel factors, including access to timely diagnosis, risk-stratified therapy, and comprehensive supportive care. This retrospective study aimed t...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Moreira, Daniel C., González-Ramella, Oscar, Echavarría Valenzuela, Maite, Carrillo, Angela K., Faughnan, Lane, Job, Godwin, Chen, Yichen, Villegas, Cesar, Ellis Irigoyen, Andrea, Barra Urbays, Rosario, Ramírez Martinez, Maribel, Altamirano Alvarez, Eduardo, León Espitia, José Antonio, López Facundo, Norma Araceli, Colunga Pedraza, Julia Esther, Reyes Gutierrez, Flor de María, Aguilar Román, Ana Berenice, Tamez Gómez, Edna Liliana, Portillo Zavala, Claudia Selene, Negroe Ocampo, Natalia del Carmen, Pulido Sanchez, Sandra Guadalupe, Cortés Alva, Deyanira, Casillas Toral, Paola, Salas Villa, Karime, Mendoza Sánchez, Patricia Judith, Pérez Alvarado, Carlos, Tamayo Pedraza, Gabriela, González Zamorano, Margarita, Ávila Alba, José Manuel Ricardo, Becerril Becerril, Jocelyn, Ramírez Durán, Hernán, Sandoval Cabrera, Antonio, Pineda Gordillo, Adolfo, de la Rosa Alonso, Dora Iveth, Mejía Marín, Leonardo Javier, Benítez Can, Leslie de los Ángeles, Gutiérrez Martinez, Itzel, Jiménez Osorio, Mariana Isabel, Echeandia, Naomi, Casillas, Erika, Guerrero-Gomez, Karla, Devidas, Meenakshi, Friedrich, Paola
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Frontiers Media S.A. 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10544893/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37790759
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fonc.2023.1255555
_version_ 1785114566894551040
author Moreira, Daniel C.
González-Ramella, Oscar
Echavarría Valenzuela, Maite
Carrillo, Angela K.
Faughnan, Lane
Job, Godwin
Chen, Yichen
Villegas, Cesar
Ellis Irigoyen, Andrea
Barra Urbays, Rosario
Ramírez Martinez, Maribel
Altamirano Alvarez, Eduardo
León Espitia, José Antonio
López Facundo, Norma Araceli
Colunga Pedraza, Julia Esther
Reyes Gutierrez, Flor de María
Aguilar Román, Ana Berenice
Tamez Gómez, Edna Liliana
Portillo Zavala, Claudia Selene
Negroe Ocampo, Natalia del Carmen
Pulido Sanchez, Sandra Guadalupe
Cortés Alva, Deyanira
Casillas Toral, Paola
Salas Villa, Karime
Mendoza Sánchez, Patricia Judith
Pérez Alvarado, Carlos
Tamayo Pedraza, Gabriela
González Zamorano, Margarita
Ávila Alba, José Manuel Ricardo
Becerril Becerril, Jocelyn
Ramírez Durán, Hernán
Sandoval Cabrera, Antonio
Pineda Gordillo, Adolfo
de la Rosa Alonso, Dora Iveth
Mejía Marín, Leonardo Javier
Benítez Can, Leslie de los Ángeles
Gutiérrez Martinez, Itzel
Jiménez Osorio, Mariana Isabel
Echeandia, Naomi
Casillas, Erika
Guerrero-Gomez, Karla
Devidas, Meenakshi
Friedrich, Paola
author_facet Moreira, Daniel C.
González-Ramella, Oscar
Echavarría Valenzuela, Maite
Carrillo, Angela K.
Faughnan, Lane
Job, Godwin
Chen, Yichen
Villegas, Cesar
Ellis Irigoyen, Andrea
Barra Urbays, Rosario
Ramírez Martinez, Maribel
Altamirano Alvarez, Eduardo
León Espitia, José Antonio
López Facundo, Norma Araceli
Colunga Pedraza, Julia Esther
Reyes Gutierrez, Flor de María
Aguilar Román, Ana Berenice
Tamez Gómez, Edna Liliana
Portillo Zavala, Claudia Selene
Negroe Ocampo, Natalia del Carmen
Pulido Sanchez, Sandra Guadalupe
Cortés Alva, Deyanira
Casillas Toral, Paola
Salas Villa, Karime
Mendoza Sánchez, Patricia Judith
Pérez Alvarado, Carlos
Tamayo Pedraza, Gabriela
González Zamorano, Margarita
Ávila Alba, José Manuel Ricardo
Becerril Becerril, Jocelyn
Ramírez Durán, Hernán
Sandoval Cabrera, Antonio
Pineda Gordillo, Adolfo
de la Rosa Alonso, Dora Iveth
Mejía Marín, Leonardo Javier
Benítez Can, Leslie de los Ángeles
Gutiérrez Martinez, Itzel
Jiménez Osorio, Mariana Isabel
Echeandia, Naomi
Casillas, Erika
Guerrero-Gomez, Karla
Devidas, Meenakshi
Friedrich, Paola
author_sort Moreira, Daniel C.
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) survival rates in low- and middle-income countries are lower due to deficiencies in multilevel factors, including access to timely diagnosis, risk-stratified therapy, and comprehensive supportive care. This retrospective study aimed to analyze outcomes for pediatric ALL at 16 centers in Mexico. METHODS: Patients <18 years of age with newly diagnosed B- and T-cell ALL treated between January 2011 and December 2019 were included. Clinical and biological characteristics and their association with outcomes were examined. RESULTS: Overall, 2,116 patients with a median age of 6.3 years were included. B-cell immunophenotype was identified in 1,889 (89.3%) patients. The median white blood cells at diagnosis were 11.2.5 × 10(3)/mm(3). CNS-1 status was reported in 1,810 (85.5%), CNS-2 in 67 (3.2%), and CNS-3 in 61 (2.9%). A total of 1,488 patients (70.4%) were classified as high-risk at diagnosis. However, in 52.5% (991/1,889) of patients with B-cell ALL, the reported risk group did not match the calculated risk group allocation based on National Cancer Institute (NCI) criteria. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) and PCR tests were performed for 407 (19.2%) and 736 (34.8%) patients, respectively. Minimal residual disease (MRD) during induction was performed in 1,158 patients (54.7%). The median follow-up was 3.7 years. During induction, 191 patients died (9.1%), and 45 patients (2.1%) experienced induction failure. A total of 365 deaths (17.3%) occurred, including 174 deaths after remission. Six percent (176) of patients abandoned treatment. The 5-year event-free survival (EFS) was 58.9% ± 1.7% for B-cell ALL and 47.4% ± 5.9% for T-cell ALL, while the 5-year overall survival (OS) was 67.5% ± 1.6% for B-cell ALL and 54.3% ± 0.6% for T-cell ALL. The 5-year cumulative incidence of central nervous system (CNS) relapse was 5.5% ± 0.6%. For the whole cohort, significantly higher outcomes were seen for patients aged 1–10 years, with DNA index >0.9, with hyperdiploid ALL, and without substantial treatment modifications. In multivariable analyses, age and Day 15 MRD continued to have a significant effect on EFS. CONCLUSION: Outcomes in this multi-institutional cohort describe poor outcomes, influenced by incomplete and inconsistent risk stratification, early toxic death, high on-treatment mortality, and high CNS relapse rate. Adopting comprehensive risk-stratification strategies, evidence-informed de-intensification for favorable-risk patients and optimized supportive care could improve outcomes.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10544893
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Frontiers Media S.A.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-105448932023-10-03 Evaluation of factors leading to poor outcomes for pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia in Mexico: a multi-institutional report of 2,116 patients Moreira, Daniel C. González-Ramella, Oscar Echavarría Valenzuela, Maite Carrillo, Angela K. Faughnan, Lane Job, Godwin Chen, Yichen Villegas, Cesar Ellis Irigoyen, Andrea Barra Urbays, Rosario Ramírez Martinez, Maribel Altamirano Alvarez, Eduardo León Espitia, José Antonio López Facundo, Norma Araceli Colunga Pedraza, Julia Esther Reyes Gutierrez, Flor de María Aguilar Román, Ana Berenice Tamez Gómez, Edna Liliana Portillo Zavala, Claudia Selene Negroe Ocampo, Natalia del Carmen Pulido Sanchez, Sandra Guadalupe Cortés Alva, Deyanira Casillas Toral, Paola Salas Villa, Karime Mendoza Sánchez, Patricia Judith Pérez Alvarado, Carlos Tamayo Pedraza, Gabriela González Zamorano, Margarita Ávila Alba, José Manuel Ricardo Becerril Becerril, Jocelyn Ramírez Durán, Hernán Sandoval Cabrera, Antonio Pineda Gordillo, Adolfo de la Rosa Alonso, Dora Iveth Mejía Marín, Leonardo Javier Benítez Can, Leslie de los Ángeles Gutiérrez Martinez, Itzel Jiménez Osorio, Mariana Isabel Echeandia, Naomi Casillas, Erika Guerrero-Gomez, Karla Devidas, Meenakshi Friedrich, Paola Front Oncol Oncology BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) survival rates in low- and middle-income countries are lower due to deficiencies in multilevel factors, including access to timely diagnosis, risk-stratified therapy, and comprehensive supportive care. This retrospective study aimed to analyze outcomes for pediatric ALL at 16 centers in Mexico. METHODS: Patients <18 years of age with newly diagnosed B- and T-cell ALL treated between January 2011 and December 2019 were included. Clinical and biological characteristics and their association with outcomes were examined. RESULTS: Overall, 2,116 patients with a median age of 6.3 years were included. B-cell immunophenotype was identified in 1,889 (89.3%) patients. The median white blood cells at diagnosis were 11.2.5 × 10(3)/mm(3). CNS-1 status was reported in 1,810 (85.5%), CNS-2 in 67 (3.2%), and CNS-3 in 61 (2.9%). A total of 1,488 patients (70.4%) were classified as high-risk at diagnosis. However, in 52.5% (991/1,889) of patients with B-cell ALL, the reported risk group did not match the calculated risk group allocation based on National Cancer Institute (NCI) criteria. Fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) and PCR tests were performed for 407 (19.2%) and 736 (34.8%) patients, respectively. Minimal residual disease (MRD) during induction was performed in 1,158 patients (54.7%). The median follow-up was 3.7 years. During induction, 191 patients died (9.1%), and 45 patients (2.1%) experienced induction failure. A total of 365 deaths (17.3%) occurred, including 174 deaths after remission. Six percent (176) of patients abandoned treatment. The 5-year event-free survival (EFS) was 58.9% ± 1.7% for B-cell ALL and 47.4% ± 5.9% for T-cell ALL, while the 5-year overall survival (OS) was 67.5% ± 1.6% for B-cell ALL and 54.3% ± 0.6% for T-cell ALL. The 5-year cumulative incidence of central nervous system (CNS) relapse was 5.5% ± 0.6%. For the whole cohort, significantly higher outcomes were seen for patients aged 1–10 years, with DNA index >0.9, with hyperdiploid ALL, and without substantial treatment modifications. In multivariable analyses, age and Day 15 MRD continued to have a significant effect on EFS. CONCLUSION: Outcomes in this multi-institutional cohort describe poor outcomes, influenced by incomplete and inconsistent risk stratification, early toxic death, high on-treatment mortality, and high CNS relapse rate. Adopting comprehensive risk-stratification strategies, evidence-informed de-intensification for favorable-risk patients and optimized supportive care could improve outcomes. Frontiers Media S.A. 2023-09-18 /pmc/articles/PMC10544893/ /pubmed/37790759 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fonc.2023.1255555 Text en Copyright © 2023 Moreira, González-Ramella, Echavarría Valenzuela, Carrillo, Faughnan, Job, Chen, Villegas, Ellis Irigoyen, Barra Urbays, Ramírez Martinez, Altamirano Alvarez, León Espitia, López Facundo, Colunga Pedraza, Reyes Gutierrez, Aguilar Román, Tamez Gómez, Portillo Zavala, Negroe Ocampo, Pulido Sanchez, Cortés Alva, Casillas Toral, Salas Villa, Mendoza Sánchez, Pérez Alvarado, Tamayo Pedraza, González Zamorano, Ávila Alba, Becerril Becerril, Ramírez Durán, Sandoval Cabrera, Pineda Gordillo, de la Rosa Alonso, Mejía Marín, Benítez Can, Gutiérrez Martinez, Jiménez Osorio, Echeandia, Casillas, Guerrero-Gomez, Devidas and Friedrich https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.
spellingShingle Oncology
Moreira, Daniel C.
González-Ramella, Oscar
Echavarría Valenzuela, Maite
Carrillo, Angela K.
Faughnan, Lane
Job, Godwin
Chen, Yichen
Villegas, Cesar
Ellis Irigoyen, Andrea
Barra Urbays, Rosario
Ramírez Martinez, Maribel
Altamirano Alvarez, Eduardo
León Espitia, José Antonio
López Facundo, Norma Araceli
Colunga Pedraza, Julia Esther
Reyes Gutierrez, Flor de María
Aguilar Román, Ana Berenice
Tamez Gómez, Edna Liliana
Portillo Zavala, Claudia Selene
Negroe Ocampo, Natalia del Carmen
Pulido Sanchez, Sandra Guadalupe
Cortés Alva, Deyanira
Casillas Toral, Paola
Salas Villa, Karime
Mendoza Sánchez, Patricia Judith
Pérez Alvarado, Carlos
Tamayo Pedraza, Gabriela
González Zamorano, Margarita
Ávila Alba, José Manuel Ricardo
Becerril Becerril, Jocelyn
Ramírez Durán, Hernán
Sandoval Cabrera, Antonio
Pineda Gordillo, Adolfo
de la Rosa Alonso, Dora Iveth
Mejía Marín, Leonardo Javier
Benítez Can, Leslie de los Ángeles
Gutiérrez Martinez, Itzel
Jiménez Osorio, Mariana Isabel
Echeandia, Naomi
Casillas, Erika
Guerrero-Gomez, Karla
Devidas, Meenakshi
Friedrich, Paola
Evaluation of factors leading to poor outcomes for pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia in Mexico: a multi-institutional report of 2,116 patients
title Evaluation of factors leading to poor outcomes for pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia in Mexico: a multi-institutional report of 2,116 patients
title_full Evaluation of factors leading to poor outcomes for pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia in Mexico: a multi-institutional report of 2,116 patients
title_fullStr Evaluation of factors leading to poor outcomes for pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia in Mexico: a multi-institutional report of 2,116 patients
title_full_unstemmed Evaluation of factors leading to poor outcomes for pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia in Mexico: a multi-institutional report of 2,116 patients
title_short Evaluation of factors leading to poor outcomes for pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia in Mexico: a multi-institutional report of 2,116 patients
title_sort evaluation of factors leading to poor outcomes for pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia in mexico: a multi-institutional report of 2,116 patients
topic Oncology
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10544893/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37790759
http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fonc.2023.1255555
work_keys_str_mv AT moreiradanielc evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT gonzalezramellaoscar evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT echavarriavalenzuelamaite evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT carrilloangelak evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT faughnanlane evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT jobgodwin evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT chenyichen evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT villegascesar evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT ellisirigoyenandrea evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT barraurbaysrosario evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT ramirezmartinezmaribel evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT altamiranoalvarezeduardo evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT leonespitiajoseantonio evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT lopezfacundonormaaraceli evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT colungapedrazajuliaesther evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT reyesgutierrezflordemaria evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT aguilarromananaberenice evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT tamezgomezednaliliana evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT portillozavalaclaudiaselene evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT negroeocamponataliadelcarmen evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT pulidosanchezsandraguadalupe evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT cortesalvadeyanira evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT casillastoralpaola evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT salasvillakarime evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT mendozasanchezpatriciajudith evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT perezalvaradocarlos evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT tamayopedrazagabriela evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT gonzalezzamoranomargarita evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT avilaalbajosemanuelricardo evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT becerrilbecerriljocelyn evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT ramirezduranhernan evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT sandovalcabreraantonio evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT pinedagordilloadolfo evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT delarosaalonsodoraiveth evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT mejiamarinleonardojavier evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT benitezcanlesliedelosangeles evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT gutierrezmartinezitzel evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT jimenezosoriomarianaisabel evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT echeandianaomi evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT casillaserika evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT guerrerogomezkarla evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT devidasmeenakshi evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients
AT friedrichpaola evaluationoffactorsleadingtopooroutcomesforpediatricacutelymphoblasticleukemiainmexicoamultiinstitutionalreportof2116patients