Comparative Assessment of the Efficacy of Newly Designed Multiple Variability Loop and Opus Loop for Anterior en Masse Retraction in Orthodontics: A Finite Element Study

Introduction Two different mechanisms are used to close the space after extractions, i.e., friction/sliding mechanics and frictionless/loop mechanics. The focus of this study is on space closure using frictionless or loop mechanics, which utilize loops to achieve the desired tooth movement. Loops are designed to increase the resiliency of the archwire so that the ideal moment-to-force ratio (M/F) of 8:1 to 10:1 for bodily tooth movement can be obtained. By incorporating various loop designs, the resiliency of archwires may be increased, and an ideal M/F ratio can be obtained. Method Different pre-activation bends were incorporated in the titanium molybdenum alloy (TMA) wire at alpha (canine side) and beta (premolar side), respectively. A total of 36 finite element method (FEM) models were prepared with and without pre-activation bends to evaluate the moment-to-force ratio. Result The results obtained from the finite element method (FEM) analysis provided valuable insights into the force and moment generated during activation while retracting the tooth. Specifically, the alpha bend at 15 degrees and the beta bend at 20 degrees produced the most desirable results for generating moments on the anterior and posterior teeth, respectively. Conclusion To ensure the proper utilization of the multiple variability (MV) loop, we recommend its preparation using a 0.019 x 0.025-inch TMA wire. This selection will maximize the loop's capabilities and enhance its performance in achieving the desired tooth movement.