Cargando…
The Burden of Disease due to COVID-19 (BoCO-19): A study protocol for a secondary analysis of surveillance data in Southern and Eastern Europe, and Central Asia
INTRODUCTION: The COVID-19 pandemic has had an extensive impact on public health worldwide. However, in many countries burden of disease indicators for COVID-19 have not yet been calculated or used for monitoring. The present study protocol describes an approach developed in the project “The Burden...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Public Library of Science
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10575506/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37831679 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0292041 |
_version_ | 1785120936771452928 |
---|---|
author | Cawley, Caoimhe Gabrani, Jonila Stevanović, Aleksandar Aidaraliev, Rakhat Çakmak Barsbay, Mehtap Cilovic Lagarija, Seila Davletov, Kairat Djamangulova, Tolkun Glushkova, Natalya an der Heiden, Matthias Kaçaniku-Gunga, Pranvera Kereselidze, Maia Kryeziu, Besfort Lkhagvasuren, Khorolsuren Mehdiyev, Samir Oharova, Dariia Sadikkhodjayeva, Diloram Santric Milicevic, Milena Stanisic, Milica Stojisavljevic, Stela Tecirli, Gulcan Terzic, Natasa Wengler, Annelene Rommel, Alexander |
author_facet | Cawley, Caoimhe Gabrani, Jonila Stevanović, Aleksandar Aidaraliev, Rakhat Çakmak Barsbay, Mehtap Cilovic Lagarija, Seila Davletov, Kairat Djamangulova, Tolkun Glushkova, Natalya an der Heiden, Matthias Kaçaniku-Gunga, Pranvera Kereselidze, Maia Kryeziu, Besfort Lkhagvasuren, Khorolsuren Mehdiyev, Samir Oharova, Dariia Sadikkhodjayeva, Diloram Santric Milicevic, Milena Stanisic, Milica Stojisavljevic, Stela Tecirli, Gulcan Terzic, Natasa Wengler, Annelene Rommel, Alexander |
author_sort | Cawley, Caoimhe |
collection | PubMed |
description | INTRODUCTION: The COVID-19 pandemic has had an extensive impact on public health worldwide. However, in many countries burden of disease indicators for COVID-19 have not yet been calculated or used for monitoring. The present study protocol describes an approach developed in the project “The Burden of Disease due to COVID-19. Towards a harmonization of population health metrics for the surveillance of dynamic outbreaks” (BoCO-19). The process of data collection and aggregation across 14 different countries and sub-national regions in Southern and Eastern Europe and Central Asia is described, as well as the methodological approaches used. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The study implemented in BoCO-19 is a secondary data analysis, using information from national surveillance systems as part of mandatory reporting on notifiable diseases. A customized data collection template is used to gather aggregated data on population size as well as COVID-19 cases and deaths. Years of life lost (YLL), as one component of the number of Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALY), are calculated as described in a recently proposed COVID-19 disease model (the ‘Burden-EU’ model) for the calculation of DALY. All-cause mortality data are collected for excess mortality sensitivity analyses. For the calculation of Years lived with disability (YLD), the Burden-EU model is adapted based on recent evidence. Because Covid-19 cases vary in terms of disease severity, the possibility and suitability of applying a uniform severity distribution of cases across all countries and sub-national regions will be explored. An approach recently developed for the Global Burden of Disease Study, that considers post-acute consequences of COVID-19, is likely to be adopted. Findings will be compared to explore the quality and usability of the existing data, to identify trends across age-groups and sexes and to formulate recommendations concerning potential improvements in data availability and quality. DISCUSSION: BoCO-19 serves as a collaborative platform in order to build international capacity for the calculation of burden of disease indicators, and to support national experts in the analysis and interpretation of country-specific data, including their strengths and weaknesses. Challenges include inherent differences in data collection and reporting systems between countries, as well as assumptions that have to be made during the calculation process. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-10575506 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | Public Library of Science |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-105755062023-10-14 The Burden of Disease due to COVID-19 (BoCO-19): A study protocol for a secondary analysis of surveillance data in Southern and Eastern Europe, and Central Asia Cawley, Caoimhe Gabrani, Jonila Stevanović, Aleksandar Aidaraliev, Rakhat Çakmak Barsbay, Mehtap Cilovic Lagarija, Seila Davletov, Kairat Djamangulova, Tolkun Glushkova, Natalya an der Heiden, Matthias Kaçaniku-Gunga, Pranvera Kereselidze, Maia Kryeziu, Besfort Lkhagvasuren, Khorolsuren Mehdiyev, Samir Oharova, Dariia Sadikkhodjayeva, Diloram Santric Milicevic, Milena Stanisic, Milica Stojisavljevic, Stela Tecirli, Gulcan Terzic, Natasa Wengler, Annelene Rommel, Alexander PLoS One Study Protocol INTRODUCTION: The COVID-19 pandemic has had an extensive impact on public health worldwide. However, in many countries burden of disease indicators for COVID-19 have not yet been calculated or used for monitoring. The present study protocol describes an approach developed in the project “The Burden of Disease due to COVID-19. Towards a harmonization of population health metrics for the surveillance of dynamic outbreaks” (BoCO-19). The process of data collection and aggregation across 14 different countries and sub-national regions in Southern and Eastern Europe and Central Asia is described, as well as the methodological approaches used. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The study implemented in BoCO-19 is a secondary data analysis, using information from national surveillance systems as part of mandatory reporting on notifiable diseases. A customized data collection template is used to gather aggregated data on population size as well as COVID-19 cases and deaths. Years of life lost (YLL), as one component of the number of Disability Adjusted Life Years (DALY), are calculated as described in a recently proposed COVID-19 disease model (the ‘Burden-EU’ model) for the calculation of DALY. All-cause mortality data are collected for excess mortality sensitivity analyses. For the calculation of Years lived with disability (YLD), the Burden-EU model is adapted based on recent evidence. Because Covid-19 cases vary in terms of disease severity, the possibility and suitability of applying a uniform severity distribution of cases across all countries and sub-national regions will be explored. An approach recently developed for the Global Burden of Disease Study, that considers post-acute consequences of COVID-19, is likely to be adopted. Findings will be compared to explore the quality and usability of the existing data, to identify trends across age-groups and sexes and to formulate recommendations concerning potential improvements in data availability and quality. DISCUSSION: BoCO-19 serves as a collaborative platform in order to build international capacity for the calculation of burden of disease indicators, and to support national experts in the analysis and interpretation of country-specific data, including their strengths and weaknesses. Challenges include inherent differences in data collection and reporting systems between countries, as well as assumptions that have to be made during the calculation process. Public Library of Science 2023-10-13 /pmc/articles/PMC10575506/ /pubmed/37831679 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0292041 Text en © 2023 Cawley et al https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. |
spellingShingle | Study Protocol Cawley, Caoimhe Gabrani, Jonila Stevanović, Aleksandar Aidaraliev, Rakhat Çakmak Barsbay, Mehtap Cilovic Lagarija, Seila Davletov, Kairat Djamangulova, Tolkun Glushkova, Natalya an der Heiden, Matthias Kaçaniku-Gunga, Pranvera Kereselidze, Maia Kryeziu, Besfort Lkhagvasuren, Khorolsuren Mehdiyev, Samir Oharova, Dariia Sadikkhodjayeva, Diloram Santric Milicevic, Milena Stanisic, Milica Stojisavljevic, Stela Tecirli, Gulcan Terzic, Natasa Wengler, Annelene Rommel, Alexander The Burden of Disease due to COVID-19 (BoCO-19): A study protocol for a secondary analysis of surveillance data in Southern and Eastern Europe, and Central Asia |
title | The Burden of Disease due to COVID-19 (BoCO-19): A study protocol for a secondary analysis of surveillance data in Southern and Eastern Europe, and Central Asia |
title_full | The Burden of Disease due to COVID-19 (BoCO-19): A study protocol for a secondary analysis of surveillance data in Southern and Eastern Europe, and Central Asia |
title_fullStr | The Burden of Disease due to COVID-19 (BoCO-19): A study protocol for a secondary analysis of surveillance data in Southern and Eastern Europe, and Central Asia |
title_full_unstemmed | The Burden of Disease due to COVID-19 (BoCO-19): A study protocol for a secondary analysis of surveillance data in Southern and Eastern Europe, and Central Asia |
title_short | The Burden of Disease due to COVID-19 (BoCO-19): A study protocol for a secondary analysis of surveillance data in Southern and Eastern Europe, and Central Asia |
title_sort | burden of disease due to covid-19 (boco-19): a study protocol for a secondary analysis of surveillance data in southern and eastern europe, and central asia |
topic | Study Protocol |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10575506/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37831679 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0292041 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT cawleycaoimhe theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT gabranijonila theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT stevanovicaleksandar theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT aidaralievrakhat theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT cakmakbarsbaymehtap theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT ciloviclagarijaseila theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT davletovkairat theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT djamangulovatolkun theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT glushkovanatalya theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT anderheidenmatthias theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT kacanikugungapranvera theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT kereselidzemaia theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT kryeziubesfort theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT lkhagvasurenkhorolsuren theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT mehdiyevsamir theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT oharovadariia theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT sadikkhodjayevadiloram theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT santricmilicevicmilena theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT stanisicmilica theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT stojisavljevicstela theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT tecirligulcan theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT terzicnatasa theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT wenglerannelene theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT rommelalexander theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT theburdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT cawleycaoimhe burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT gabranijonila burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT stevanovicaleksandar burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT aidaralievrakhat burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT cakmakbarsbaymehtap burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT ciloviclagarijaseila burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT davletovkairat burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT djamangulovatolkun burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT glushkovanatalya burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT anderheidenmatthias burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT kacanikugungapranvera burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT kereselidzemaia burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT kryeziubesfort burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT lkhagvasurenkhorolsuren burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT mehdiyevsamir burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT oharovadariia burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT sadikkhodjayevadiloram burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT santricmilicevicmilena burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT stanisicmilica burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT stojisavljevicstela burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT tecirligulcan burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT terzicnatasa burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT wenglerannelene burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT rommelalexander burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia AT burdenofdiseaseduetocovid19boco19astudyprotocolforasecondaryanalysisofsurveillancedatainsouthernandeasterneuropeandcentralasia |