Respirometry reveals major lineage-based differences in the energetics of osmoregulation in aquatic invertebrates

All freshwater organisms are challenged to control their internal balance of water and ions in strongly hypotonic environments. We compared the influence of external salinity on the oxygen consumption rates (Ṁ(O(2))) of three species of freshwater insects, one snail and two crustaceans. Consistent with available literature, we found a clear decrease in Ṁ(O(2)) with increasing salinity in the snail Elimia sp. and crustaceans Hyalella azteca and Gammarus pulex (r(5)=−0.90, P=0.03). However, we show here for the first time that metabolic rate was unchanged by salinity in the aquatic insects, whereas ion transport rates were positively correlated with higher salinities. In contrast, when we examined the ionic influx rates in the freshwater snail and crustaceans, we found that Ca uptake rates were highest under the most dilute conditions, while Na uptake rates increased with salinity. In G. pulex exposed to a serially diluted ion matrix, Ca uptake rates were positively associated with Ṁ(O(2)) (r(5)=−0.93, P=0.02). This positive association between Ca uptake rate and Ṁ(O(2)) was also observed when conductivity was held constant but Ca concentration was manipulated (1.7–17.3 mg Ca l(−1)) (r(5)=0.94, P=0.05). This finding potentially implicates the cost of calcium uptake as a driver of increased metabolic rate under dilute conditions in organisms with calcified exoskeletons and suggests major phyletic differences in osmoregulatory physiology. Freshwater insects may be energetically challenged by higher salinities, while lower salinities may be more challenging for other freshwater taxa.