Cargando…

A novel directional-oriented method for predicting shear wave velocity through empirical rock physics relationship using geostatistics analysis

This study attempts to design a novel direction–oriented approach for estimating shear wave velocity (V(S)) through geostatistical methods (GM) using density employing geophysical log data. The research area involves three hydrocarbon wells drilled in carbonate reservoirs that are comprised of oil a...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Makarian, Esmael, Mirhashemi, Maryam, Elyasi, Ayub, Mansourian, Danial, Falahat, Reza, Radwan, Ahmed E., El-Aal, Ahmed, Fan, Cunhui, Li, Hu
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Nature Publishing Group UK 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10645940/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37963938
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-47016-9
_version_ 1785147421404168192
author Makarian, Esmael
Mirhashemi, Maryam
Elyasi, Ayub
Mansourian, Danial
Falahat, Reza
Radwan, Ahmed E.
El-Aal, Ahmed
Fan, Cunhui
Li, Hu
author_facet Makarian, Esmael
Mirhashemi, Maryam
Elyasi, Ayub
Mansourian, Danial
Falahat, Reza
Radwan, Ahmed E.
El-Aal, Ahmed
Fan, Cunhui
Li, Hu
author_sort Makarian, Esmael
collection PubMed
description This study attempts to design a novel direction–oriented approach for estimating shear wave velocity (V(S)) through geostatistical methods (GM) using density employing geophysical log data. The research area involves three hydrocarbon wells drilled in carbonate reservoirs that are comprised of oil and water. Firstly, V(S) was estimated using the four selected empirical rock physics relationships (ERR) in well A (target well), and then all results were evaluated by ten statistical benchmarks. All results show that the best ERR is Greenberg and Castagna, with R(2) = 0.8104 and Correlation = 0.90, while Gardner's equation obtained the poorest results with R(2) = 0.6766 and correlation = 0.82. Next, Gardner's method was improved through GM by employing Ordinary Kriging (OKr) in two directions in well A, and then Cross-Validation and Jack-knife methods (JKm and CVm, respectively) were used to assess OKr's performance and efficiency. Initially, CVm and JKm were employed to estimate Vs using the available density and its relationship with shear wave velocity, where the performance of CVm was better with R(2) = 0.8865 and correlation = 0.94. In this step, some points from the original V(S) were used to train the data. Finally, Vs was estimated through JKm and using the relationship between the shear wave velocity of two wells near the target well, including wells B and C; however, in this step, the original shear wave velocity of the target well was completely ignored. Reading the results, JKm could show excellent performance with R(2) = 0.8503 and Corr = 0.922. In contrast to previous studies that used only Correlation and R-squared (R(2)), this study further provides accurate results by employing a wide range of statistical benchmarks to investigate all results. In contrast to traditional empirical rock physics relationships, the developed direction-oriented technique demonstrated improved predicted accuracy and robustness in the investigated carbonate field. This work demonstrates that GM can effectively estimate Vs and has a significant potential to enhance V(S) estimation using density.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10645940
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Nature Publishing Group UK
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-106459402023-11-14 A novel directional-oriented method for predicting shear wave velocity through empirical rock physics relationship using geostatistics analysis Makarian, Esmael Mirhashemi, Maryam Elyasi, Ayub Mansourian, Danial Falahat, Reza Radwan, Ahmed E. El-Aal, Ahmed Fan, Cunhui Li, Hu Sci Rep Article This study attempts to design a novel direction–oriented approach for estimating shear wave velocity (V(S)) through geostatistical methods (GM) using density employing geophysical log data. The research area involves three hydrocarbon wells drilled in carbonate reservoirs that are comprised of oil and water. Firstly, V(S) was estimated using the four selected empirical rock physics relationships (ERR) in well A (target well), and then all results were evaluated by ten statistical benchmarks. All results show that the best ERR is Greenberg and Castagna, with R(2) = 0.8104 and Correlation = 0.90, while Gardner's equation obtained the poorest results with R(2) = 0.6766 and correlation = 0.82. Next, Gardner's method was improved through GM by employing Ordinary Kriging (OKr) in two directions in well A, and then Cross-Validation and Jack-knife methods (JKm and CVm, respectively) were used to assess OKr's performance and efficiency. Initially, CVm and JKm were employed to estimate Vs using the available density and its relationship with shear wave velocity, where the performance of CVm was better with R(2) = 0.8865 and correlation = 0.94. In this step, some points from the original V(S) were used to train the data. Finally, Vs was estimated through JKm and using the relationship between the shear wave velocity of two wells near the target well, including wells B and C; however, in this step, the original shear wave velocity of the target well was completely ignored. Reading the results, JKm could show excellent performance with R(2) = 0.8503 and Corr = 0.922. In contrast to previous studies that used only Correlation and R-squared (R(2)), this study further provides accurate results by employing a wide range of statistical benchmarks to investigate all results. In contrast to traditional empirical rock physics relationships, the developed direction-oriented technique demonstrated improved predicted accuracy and robustness in the investigated carbonate field. This work demonstrates that GM can effectively estimate Vs and has a significant potential to enhance V(S) estimation using density. Nature Publishing Group UK 2023-11-14 /pmc/articles/PMC10645940/ /pubmed/37963938 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-47016-9 Text en © The Author(s) 2023 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) .
spellingShingle Article
Makarian, Esmael
Mirhashemi, Maryam
Elyasi, Ayub
Mansourian, Danial
Falahat, Reza
Radwan, Ahmed E.
El-Aal, Ahmed
Fan, Cunhui
Li, Hu
A novel directional-oriented method for predicting shear wave velocity through empirical rock physics relationship using geostatistics analysis
title A novel directional-oriented method for predicting shear wave velocity through empirical rock physics relationship using geostatistics analysis
title_full A novel directional-oriented method for predicting shear wave velocity through empirical rock physics relationship using geostatistics analysis
title_fullStr A novel directional-oriented method for predicting shear wave velocity through empirical rock physics relationship using geostatistics analysis
title_full_unstemmed A novel directional-oriented method for predicting shear wave velocity through empirical rock physics relationship using geostatistics analysis
title_short A novel directional-oriented method for predicting shear wave velocity through empirical rock physics relationship using geostatistics analysis
title_sort novel directional-oriented method for predicting shear wave velocity through empirical rock physics relationship using geostatistics analysis
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10645940/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37963938
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-47016-9
work_keys_str_mv AT makarianesmael anoveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT mirhashemimaryam anoveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT elyasiayub anoveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT mansouriandanial anoveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT falahatreza anoveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT radwanahmede anoveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT elaalahmed anoveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT fancunhui anoveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT lihu anoveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT makarianesmael noveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT mirhashemimaryam noveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT elyasiayub noveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT mansouriandanial noveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT falahatreza noveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT radwanahmede noveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT elaalahmed noveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT fancunhui noveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis
AT lihu noveldirectionalorientedmethodforpredictingshearwavevelocitythroughempiricalrockphysicsrelationshipusinggeostatisticsanalysis