Cargando…

A spectroscopic liquid biopsy for the earlier detection of multiple cancer types

BACKGROUND: A rapid, low-cost blood test that can be applied to reliably detect multiple different cancer types would be transformational. METHODS: In this large-scale discovery study (n = 2092 patients) we applied the Dxcover® Cancer Liquid Biopsy to examine eight different cancers. The test uses F...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Cameron, James M., Sala, Alexandra, Antoniou, Georgios, Brennan, Paul M., Butler, Holly J., Conn, Justin J. A., Connal, Siobhan, Curran, Tom, Hegarty, Mark G., McHardy, Rose G., Orringer, Daniel, Palmer, David S., Smith, Benjamin R., Baker, Matthew J.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Nature Publishing Group UK 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10645969/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37717120
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41416-023-02423-7
_version_ 1785134811912863744
author Cameron, James M.
Sala, Alexandra
Antoniou, Georgios
Brennan, Paul M.
Butler, Holly J.
Conn, Justin J. A.
Connal, Siobhan
Curran, Tom
Hegarty, Mark G.
McHardy, Rose G.
Orringer, Daniel
Palmer, David S.
Smith, Benjamin R.
Baker, Matthew J.
author_facet Cameron, James M.
Sala, Alexandra
Antoniou, Georgios
Brennan, Paul M.
Butler, Holly J.
Conn, Justin J. A.
Connal, Siobhan
Curran, Tom
Hegarty, Mark G.
McHardy, Rose G.
Orringer, Daniel
Palmer, David S.
Smith, Benjamin R.
Baker, Matthew J.
author_sort Cameron, James M.
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: A rapid, low-cost blood test that can be applied to reliably detect multiple different cancer types would be transformational. METHODS: In this large-scale discovery study (n = 2092 patients) we applied the Dxcover® Cancer Liquid Biopsy to examine eight different cancers. The test uses Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy and machine-learning algorithms to detect cancer. RESULTS: Area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (ROC) values were calculated for eight cancer types versus symptomatic non-cancer controls: brain (0.90), breast (0.76), colorectal (0.91), kidney (0.91), lung (0.91), ovarian (0.86), pancreatic (0.84) and prostate (0.86). We assessed the test performance when all eight cancer types were pooled to classify ‘any cancer’ against non-cancer patients. The cancer versus asymptomatic non-cancer classification detected 64% of Stage I cancers when specificity was 99% (overall sensitivity 57%). When tuned for higher sensitivity, this model identified 99% of Stage I cancers (with specificity 59%). CONCLUSIONS: This spectroscopic blood test can effectively detect early-stage disease and can be fine-tuned to maximise either sensitivity or specificity depending on the requirements from different healthcare systems and cancer diagnostic pathways. This low-cost strategy could facilitate the requisite earlier diagnosis, when cancer treatment can be more effective, or less toxic. STATEMENT OF TRANSLATIONAL RELEVANCE: The earlier diagnosis of cancer is of paramount importance to improve patient survival. Current liquid biopsies are mainly focused on single tumour-derived biomarkers, which limits test sensitivity, especially for early-stage cancers that do not shed enough genetic material. This pan-omic liquid biopsy analyses the full complement of tumour and immune-derived markers present within blood derivatives and could facilitate the earlier detection of multiple cancer types. There is a low barrier to integrating this blood test into existing diagnostic pathways since the technology is rapid, simple to use, only minute sample volumes are required, and sample preparation is minimal. In addition, the spectroscopic liquid biopsy described in this study has the potential to be combined with other orthogonal tests, such as cell-free DNA, which could provide an efficient route to diagnosis. Cancer treatment can be more effective when given earlier, and this low-cost strategy has the potential to improve patient prognosis.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10645969
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Nature Publishing Group UK
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-106459692023-09-16 A spectroscopic liquid biopsy for the earlier detection of multiple cancer types Cameron, James M. Sala, Alexandra Antoniou, Georgios Brennan, Paul M. Butler, Holly J. Conn, Justin J. A. Connal, Siobhan Curran, Tom Hegarty, Mark G. McHardy, Rose G. Orringer, Daniel Palmer, David S. Smith, Benjamin R. Baker, Matthew J. Br J Cancer Article BACKGROUND: A rapid, low-cost blood test that can be applied to reliably detect multiple different cancer types would be transformational. METHODS: In this large-scale discovery study (n = 2092 patients) we applied the Dxcover® Cancer Liquid Biopsy to examine eight different cancers. The test uses Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy and machine-learning algorithms to detect cancer. RESULTS: Area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (ROC) values were calculated for eight cancer types versus symptomatic non-cancer controls: brain (0.90), breast (0.76), colorectal (0.91), kidney (0.91), lung (0.91), ovarian (0.86), pancreatic (0.84) and prostate (0.86). We assessed the test performance when all eight cancer types were pooled to classify ‘any cancer’ against non-cancer patients. The cancer versus asymptomatic non-cancer classification detected 64% of Stage I cancers when specificity was 99% (overall sensitivity 57%). When tuned for higher sensitivity, this model identified 99% of Stage I cancers (with specificity 59%). CONCLUSIONS: This spectroscopic blood test can effectively detect early-stage disease and can be fine-tuned to maximise either sensitivity or specificity depending on the requirements from different healthcare systems and cancer diagnostic pathways. This low-cost strategy could facilitate the requisite earlier diagnosis, when cancer treatment can be more effective, or less toxic. STATEMENT OF TRANSLATIONAL RELEVANCE: The earlier diagnosis of cancer is of paramount importance to improve patient survival. Current liquid biopsies are mainly focused on single tumour-derived biomarkers, which limits test sensitivity, especially for early-stage cancers that do not shed enough genetic material. This pan-omic liquid biopsy analyses the full complement of tumour and immune-derived markers present within blood derivatives and could facilitate the earlier detection of multiple cancer types. There is a low barrier to integrating this blood test into existing diagnostic pathways since the technology is rapid, simple to use, only minute sample volumes are required, and sample preparation is minimal. In addition, the spectroscopic liquid biopsy described in this study has the potential to be combined with other orthogonal tests, such as cell-free DNA, which could provide an efficient route to diagnosis. Cancer treatment can be more effective when given earlier, and this low-cost strategy has the potential to improve patient prognosis. Nature Publishing Group UK 2023-09-16 2023-11-09 /pmc/articles/PMC10645969/ /pubmed/37717120 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41416-023-02423-7 Text en © The Author(s) 2023 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article’s Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article’s Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) .
spellingShingle Article
Cameron, James M.
Sala, Alexandra
Antoniou, Georgios
Brennan, Paul M.
Butler, Holly J.
Conn, Justin J. A.
Connal, Siobhan
Curran, Tom
Hegarty, Mark G.
McHardy, Rose G.
Orringer, Daniel
Palmer, David S.
Smith, Benjamin R.
Baker, Matthew J.
A spectroscopic liquid biopsy for the earlier detection of multiple cancer types
title A spectroscopic liquid biopsy for the earlier detection of multiple cancer types
title_full A spectroscopic liquid biopsy for the earlier detection of multiple cancer types
title_fullStr A spectroscopic liquid biopsy for the earlier detection of multiple cancer types
title_full_unstemmed A spectroscopic liquid biopsy for the earlier detection of multiple cancer types
title_short A spectroscopic liquid biopsy for the earlier detection of multiple cancer types
title_sort spectroscopic liquid biopsy for the earlier detection of multiple cancer types
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10645969/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37717120
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41416-023-02423-7
work_keys_str_mv AT cameronjamesm aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT salaalexandra aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT antoniougeorgios aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT brennanpaulm aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT butlerhollyj aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT connjustinja aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT connalsiobhan aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT currantom aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT hegartymarkg aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT mchardyroseg aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT orringerdaniel aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT palmerdavids aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT smithbenjaminr aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT bakermatthewj aspectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT cameronjamesm spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT salaalexandra spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT antoniougeorgios spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT brennanpaulm spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT butlerhollyj spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT connjustinja spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT connalsiobhan spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT currantom spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT hegartymarkg spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT mchardyroseg spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT orringerdaniel spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT palmerdavids spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT smithbenjaminr spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes
AT bakermatthewj spectroscopicliquidbiopsyfortheearlierdetectionofmultiplecancertypes