On Prototropy and Bond Length Alternation in Neutral and Ionized Pyrimidine Bases and Their Model Azines in Vacuo

In this review, the complete tautomeric equilibria are derived for disubstituted pyrimidine nucleic acid bases starting from phenol, aniline, and their model compounds—monosubstituted aromatic azines. The differences in tautomeric preferences for isolated (gaseous) neutral pyrimidine bases and their model compounds are discussed in light of different functional groups, their positions within the six-membered ring, electronic effects, and intramolecular interactions. For the discussion of tautomeric preferences and for the analysis of internal effects, recent quantum-chemical results are taken into account and compared to some experimental ones. For each possible tautomer-rotamer of the title compounds, the bond length alternation, measured by means of the harmonic oscillator model of electron delocalization (HOMED) index, is examined. Significant HOMED similarities exist for mono- and disubstituted derivatives. The lack of parallelism between the geometric (HOMED) and energetic (ΔG) parameters for all possible isomers clearly shows that aromaticity is not the main factor that dictates tautomeric preferences for pyrimidine bases, particularly for uracil and thymine. The effects of one-electron loss (positive ionization) and one-electron gain (negative ionization) on prototropy and bond length alternation are also reviewed for pyrimidine bases and their models.