Cargando…

Real-Time Artificial Intelligence–Based Guidance of Echocardiographic Imaging by Novices: Image Quality and Suitability for Diagnostic Interpretation and Quantitative Analysis

BACKGROUND: We aimed to assess in a prospective multicenter study the quality of echocardiographic exams performed by inexperienced users guided by a new artificial intelligence software and evaluate their suitability for diagnostic interpretation of basic cardiac pathology and quantitative analysis...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Mor-Avi, Victor, Khandheria, Bijoy, Klempfner, Robert, Cotella, Juan I., Moreno, Merav, Ignatowski, Denise, Guile, Brittney, Hayes, Hailee J., Hipke, Kyle, Kaminski, Abigail, Spiegelstein, Dan, Avisar, Noa, Kezurer, Itay, Mazursky, Asaf, Handel, Ran, Peleg, Yotam, Avraham, Shir, Ludomirsky, Achiau, Lang, Roberto M.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10659245/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37955139
http://dx.doi.org/10.1161/CIRCIMAGING.123.015569
_version_ 1785148297395044352
author Mor-Avi, Victor
Khandheria, Bijoy
Klempfner, Robert
Cotella, Juan I.
Moreno, Merav
Ignatowski, Denise
Guile, Brittney
Hayes, Hailee J.
Hipke, Kyle
Kaminski, Abigail
Spiegelstein, Dan
Avisar, Noa
Kezurer, Itay
Mazursky, Asaf
Handel, Ran
Peleg, Yotam
Avraham, Shir
Ludomirsky, Achiau
Lang, Roberto M.
author_facet Mor-Avi, Victor
Khandheria, Bijoy
Klempfner, Robert
Cotella, Juan I.
Moreno, Merav
Ignatowski, Denise
Guile, Brittney
Hayes, Hailee J.
Hipke, Kyle
Kaminski, Abigail
Spiegelstein, Dan
Avisar, Noa
Kezurer, Itay
Mazursky, Asaf
Handel, Ran
Peleg, Yotam
Avraham, Shir
Ludomirsky, Achiau
Lang, Roberto M.
author_sort Mor-Avi, Victor
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: We aimed to assess in a prospective multicenter study the quality of echocardiographic exams performed by inexperienced users guided by a new artificial intelligence software and evaluate their suitability for diagnostic interpretation of basic cardiac pathology and quantitative analysis of cardiac chamber and function. METHODS: The software (UltraSight, Ltd) was embedded into a handheld imaging device (Lumify; Philips). Six nurses and 3 medical residents, who underwent minimal training, scanned 240 patients (61±16 years; 63% with cardiac pathology) in 10 standard views. All patients were also scanned by expert sonographers using the same device without artificial intelligence guidance. Studies were reviewed by 5 certified echocardiographers blinded to the imager’s identity, who evaluated the ability to assess left and right ventricular size and function, pericardial effusion, valve morphology, and left atrial and inferior vena cava sizes. Finally, apical 4-chamber images of adequate quality, acquired by novices and sonographers in 100 patients, were analyzed to measure left ventricular volumes, ejection fraction, and global longitudinal strain by an expert reader using conventional methodology. Measurements were compared between novices’ and experts’ images. RESULTS: Of the 240 studies acquired by novices, 99.2%, 99.6%, 92.9%, and 100% had sufficient quality to assess left ventricular size and function, right ventricular size, and pericardial effusion, respectively. Valve morphology, right ventricular function, and left atrial and inferior vena cava size were visualized in 67% to 98% exams. Images obtained by novices and sonographers yielded concordant diagnostic interpretation in 83% to 96% studies. Quantitative analysis was feasible in 83% images acquired by novices and resulted in high correlations (r≥0.74) and small biases, compared with those obtained by sonographers. CONCLUSIONS: After minimal training with the real-time guidance software, novice users can acquire images of diagnostic quality approaching that of expert sonographers in most patients. This technology may increase adoption and improve accuracy of point-of-care cardiac ultrasound.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10659245
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-106592452023-11-20 Real-Time Artificial Intelligence–Based Guidance of Echocardiographic Imaging by Novices: Image Quality and Suitability for Diagnostic Interpretation and Quantitative Analysis Mor-Avi, Victor Khandheria, Bijoy Klempfner, Robert Cotella, Juan I. Moreno, Merav Ignatowski, Denise Guile, Brittney Hayes, Hailee J. Hipke, Kyle Kaminski, Abigail Spiegelstein, Dan Avisar, Noa Kezurer, Itay Mazursky, Asaf Handel, Ran Peleg, Yotam Avraham, Shir Ludomirsky, Achiau Lang, Roberto M. Circ Cardiovasc Imaging Original Articles BACKGROUND: We aimed to assess in a prospective multicenter study the quality of echocardiographic exams performed by inexperienced users guided by a new artificial intelligence software and evaluate their suitability for diagnostic interpretation of basic cardiac pathology and quantitative analysis of cardiac chamber and function. METHODS: The software (UltraSight, Ltd) was embedded into a handheld imaging device (Lumify; Philips). Six nurses and 3 medical residents, who underwent minimal training, scanned 240 patients (61±16 years; 63% with cardiac pathology) in 10 standard views. All patients were also scanned by expert sonographers using the same device without artificial intelligence guidance. Studies were reviewed by 5 certified echocardiographers blinded to the imager’s identity, who evaluated the ability to assess left and right ventricular size and function, pericardial effusion, valve morphology, and left atrial and inferior vena cava sizes. Finally, apical 4-chamber images of adequate quality, acquired by novices and sonographers in 100 patients, were analyzed to measure left ventricular volumes, ejection fraction, and global longitudinal strain by an expert reader using conventional methodology. Measurements were compared between novices’ and experts’ images. RESULTS: Of the 240 studies acquired by novices, 99.2%, 99.6%, 92.9%, and 100% had sufficient quality to assess left ventricular size and function, right ventricular size, and pericardial effusion, respectively. Valve morphology, right ventricular function, and left atrial and inferior vena cava size were visualized in 67% to 98% exams. Images obtained by novices and sonographers yielded concordant diagnostic interpretation in 83% to 96% studies. Quantitative analysis was feasible in 83% images acquired by novices and resulted in high correlations (r≥0.74) and small biases, compared with those obtained by sonographers. CONCLUSIONS: After minimal training with the real-time guidance software, novice users can acquire images of diagnostic quality approaching that of expert sonographers in most patients. This technology may increase adoption and improve accuracy of point-of-care cardiac ultrasound. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins 2023-11-13 /pmc/articles/PMC10659245/ /pubmed/37955139 http://dx.doi.org/10.1161/CIRCIMAGING.123.015569 Text en © 2023 The Authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/Circulation: Cardiovascular Imaging is published on behalf of the American Heart Association, Inc., by Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial-NoDerivs (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) License, which permits use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided that the original work is properly cited, the use is noncommercial, and no modifications or adaptations are made.
spellingShingle Original Articles
Mor-Avi, Victor
Khandheria, Bijoy
Klempfner, Robert
Cotella, Juan I.
Moreno, Merav
Ignatowski, Denise
Guile, Brittney
Hayes, Hailee J.
Hipke, Kyle
Kaminski, Abigail
Spiegelstein, Dan
Avisar, Noa
Kezurer, Itay
Mazursky, Asaf
Handel, Ran
Peleg, Yotam
Avraham, Shir
Ludomirsky, Achiau
Lang, Roberto M.
Real-Time Artificial Intelligence–Based Guidance of Echocardiographic Imaging by Novices: Image Quality and Suitability for Diagnostic Interpretation and Quantitative Analysis
title Real-Time Artificial Intelligence–Based Guidance of Echocardiographic Imaging by Novices: Image Quality and Suitability for Diagnostic Interpretation and Quantitative Analysis
title_full Real-Time Artificial Intelligence–Based Guidance of Echocardiographic Imaging by Novices: Image Quality and Suitability for Diagnostic Interpretation and Quantitative Analysis
title_fullStr Real-Time Artificial Intelligence–Based Guidance of Echocardiographic Imaging by Novices: Image Quality and Suitability for Diagnostic Interpretation and Quantitative Analysis
title_full_unstemmed Real-Time Artificial Intelligence–Based Guidance of Echocardiographic Imaging by Novices: Image Quality and Suitability for Diagnostic Interpretation and Quantitative Analysis
title_short Real-Time Artificial Intelligence–Based Guidance of Echocardiographic Imaging by Novices: Image Quality and Suitability for Diagnostic Interpretation and Quantitative Analysis
title_sort real-time artificial intelligence–based guidance of echocardiographic imaging by novices: image quality and suitability for diagnostic interpretation and quantitative analysis
topic Original Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10659245/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37955139
http://dx.doi.org/10.1161/CIRCIMAGING.123.015569
work_keys_str_mv AT moravivictor realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT khandheriabijoy realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT klempfnerrobert realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT cotellajuani realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT morenomerav realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT ignatowskidenise realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT guilebrittney realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT hayeshaileej realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT hipkekyle realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT kaminskiabigail realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT spiegelsteindan realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT avisarnoa realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT kezureritay realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT mazurskyasaf realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT handelran realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT pelegyotam realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT avrahamshir realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT ludomirskyachiau realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis
AT langrobertom realtimeartificialintelligencebasedguidanceofechocardiographicimagingbynovicesimagequalityandsuitabilityfordiagnosticinterpretationandquantitativeanalysis