Cargando…

A Multiclass Radiomics Method–Based WHO Severity Scale for Improving COVID-19 Patient Assessment and Disease Characterization From CT Scans

OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to evaluate the severity of COVID-19 patients' disease by comparing a multiclass lung lesion model to a single-class lung lesion model and radiologists' assessments in chest computed tomography scans. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The proposed method, AssessN...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Henao, John Anderson Garcia, Depotter, Arno, Bower, Danielle V., Bajercius, Herkus, Todorova, Plamena Teodosieva, Saint-James, Hugo, de Mortanges, Aurélie Pahud, Barroso, Maria Cecilia, He, Jianchun, Yang, Junlin, You, Chenyu, Staib, Lawrence H., Gange, Christopher, Ledda, Roberta Eufrasia, Caminiti, Caterina, Silva, Mario, Cortopassi, Isabel Oliva, Dela Cruz, Charles S., Hautz, Wolf, Bonel, Harald M., Sverzellati, Nicola, Duncan, James S., Reyes, Mauricio, Poellinger, Alexander
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10662611/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37493348
http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/RLI.0000000000001005
_version_ 1785148574504321024
author Henao, John Anderson Garcia
Depotter, Arno
Bower, Danielle V.
Bajercius, Herkus
Todorova, Plamena Teodosieva
Saint-James, Hugo
de Mortanges, Aurélie Pahud
Barroso, Maria Cecilia
He, Jianchun
Yang, Junlin
You, Chenyu
Staib, Lawrence H.
Gange, Christopher
Ledda, Roberta Eufrasia
Caminiti, Caterina
Silva, Mario
Cortopassi, Isabel Oliva
Dela Cruz, Charles S.
Hautz, Wolf
Bonel, Harald M.
Sverzellati, Nicola
Duncan, James S.
Reyes, Mauricio
Poellinger, Alexander
author_facet Henao, John Anderson Garcia
Depotter, Arno
Bower, Danielle V.
Bajercius, Herkus
Todorova, Plamena Teodosieva
Saint-James, Hugo
de Mortanges, Aurélie Pahud
Barroso, Maria Cecilia
He, Jianchun
Yang, Junlin
You, Chenyu
Staib, Lawrence H.
Gange, Christopher
Ledda, Roberta Eufrasia
Caminiti, Caterina
Silva, Mario
Cortopassi, Isabel Oliva
Dela Cruz, Charles S.
Hautz, Wolf
Bonel, Harald M.
Sverzellati, Nicola
Duncan, James S.
Reyes, Mauricio
Poellinger, Alexander
author_sort Henao, John Anderson Garcia
collection PubMed
description OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to evaluate the severity of COVID-19 patients' disease by comparing a multiclass lung lesion model to a single-class lung lesion model and radiologists' assessments in chest computed tomography scans. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The proposed method, AssessNet-19, was developed in 2 stages in this retrospective study. Four COVID-19–induced tissue lesions were manually segmented to train a 2D-U-Net network for a multiclass segmentation task followed by extensive extraction of radiomic features from the lung lesions. LASSO regression was used to reduce the feature set, and the XGBoost algorithm was trained to classify disease severity based on the World Health Organization Clinical Progression Scale. The model was evaluated using 2 multicenter cohorts: a development cohort of 145 COVID-19–positive patients from 3 centers to train and test the severity prediction model using manually segmented lung lesions. In addition, an evaluation set of 90 COVID-19–positive patients was collected from 2 centers to evaluate AssessNet-19 in a fully automated fashion. RESULTS: AssessNet-19 achieved an F1-score of 0.76 ± 0.02 for severity classification in the evaluation set, which was superior to the 3 expert thoracic radiologists (F1 = 0.63 ± 0.02) and the single-class lesion segmentation model (F1 = 0.64 ± 0.02). In addition, AssessNet-19 automated multiclass lesion segmentation obtained a mean Dice score of 0.70 for ground-glass opacity, 0.68 for consolidation, 0.65 for pleural effusion, and 0.30 for band-like structures compared with ground truth. Moreover, it achieved a high agreement with radiologists for quantifying disease extent with Cohen κ of 0.94, 0.92, and 0.95. CONCLUSIONS: A novel artificial intelligence multiclass radiomics model including 4 lung lesions to assess disease severity based on the World Health Organization Clinical Progression Scale more accurately determines the severity of COVID-19 patients than a single-class model and radiologists' assessment.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10662611
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-106626112023-11-21 A Multiclass Radiomics Method–Based WHO Severity Scale for Improving COVID-19 Patient Assessment and Disease Characterization From CT Scans Henao, John Anderson Garcia Depotter, Arno Bower, Danielle V. Bajercius, Herkus Todorova, Plamena Teodosieva Saint-James, Hugo de Mortanges, Aurélie Pahud Barroso, Maria Cecilia He, Jianchun Yang, Junlin You, Chenyu Staib, Lawrence H. Gange, Christopher Ledda, Roberta Eufrasia Caminiti, Caterina Silva, Mario Cortopassi, Isabel Oliva Dela Cruz, Charles S. Hautz, Wolf Bonel, Harald M. Sverzellati, Nicola Duncan, James S. Reyes, Mauricio Poellinger, Alexander Invest Radiol Original Article OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to evaluate the severity of COVID-19 patients' disease by comparing a multiclass lung lesion model to a single-class lung lesion model and radiologists' assessments in chest computed tomography scans. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The proposed method, AssessNet-19, was developed in 2 stages in this retrospective study. Four COVID-19–induced tissue lesions were manually segmented to train a 2D-U-Net network for a multiclass segmentation task followed by extensive extraction of radiomic features from the lung lesions. LASSO regression was used to reduce the feature set, and the XGBoost algorithm was trained to classify disease severity based on the World Health Organization Clinical Progression Scale. The model was evaluated using 2 multicenter cohorts: a development cohort of 145 COVID-19–positive patients from 3 centers to train and test the severity prediction model using manually segmented lung lesions. In addition, an evaluation set of 90 COVID-19–positive patients was collected from 2 centers to evaluate AssessNet-19 in a fully automated fashion. RESULTS: AssessNet-19 achieved an F1-score of 0.76 ± 0.02 for severity classification in the evaluation set, which was superior to the 3 expert thoracic radiologists (F1 = 0.63 ± 0.02) and the single-class lesion segmentation model (F1 = 0.64 ± 0.02). In addition, AssessNet-19 automated multiclass lesion segmentation obtained a mean Dice score of 0.70 for ground-glass opacity, 0.68 for consolidation, 0.65 for pleural effusion, and 0.30 for band-like structures compared with ground truth. Moreover, it achieved a high agreement with radiologists for quantifying disease extent with Cohen κ of 0.94, 0.92, and 0.95. CONCLUSIONS: A novel artificial intelligence multiclass radiomics model including 4 lung lesions to assess disease severity based on the World Health Organization Clinical Progression Scale more accurately determines the severity of COVID-19 patients than a single-class model and radiologists' assessment. Lippincott Williams & Wilkins 2023-12 2023-07-27 /pmc/articles/PMC10662611/ /pubmed/37493348 http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/RLI.0000000000001005 Text en Copyright © 2023 The Author(s). Published by Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial-No Derivatives License 4.0 (CCBY-NC-ND) (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/) , where it is permissible to download and share the work provided it is properly cited. The work cannot be changed in any way or used commercially without permission from the journal.
spellingShingle Original Article
Henao, John Anderson Garcia
Depotter, Arno
Bower, Danielle V.
Bajercius, Herkus
Todorova, Plamena Teodosieva
Saint-James, Hugo
de Mortanges, Aurélie Pahud
Barroso, Maria Cecilia
He, Jianchun
Yang, Junlin
You, Chenyu
Staib, Lawrence H.
Gange, Christopher
Ledda, Roberta Eufrasia
Caminiti, Caterina
Silva, Mario
Cortopassi, Isabel Oliva
Dela Cruz, Charles S.
Hautz, Wolf
Bonel, Harald M.
Sverzellati, Nicola
Duncan, James S.
Reyes, Mauricio
Poellinger, Alexander
A Multiclass Radiomics Method–Based WHO Severity Scale for Improving COVID-19 Patient Assessment and Disease Characterization From CT Scans
title A Multiclass Radiomics Method–Based WHO Severity Scale for Improving COVID-19 Patient Assessment and Disease Characterization From CT Scans
title_full A Multiclass Radiomics Method–Based WHO Severity Scale for Improving COVID-19 Patient Assessment and Disease Characterization From CT Scans
title_fullStr A Multiclass Radiomics Method–Based WHO Severity Scale for Improving COVID-19 Patient Assessment and Disease Characterization From CT Scans
title_full_unstemmed A Multiclass Radiomics Method–Based WHO Severity Scale for Improving COVID-19 Patient Assessment and Disease Characterization From CT Scans
title_short A Multiclass Radiomics Method–Based WHO Severity Scale for Improving COVID-19 Patient Assessment and Disease Characterization From CT Scans
title_sort multiclass radiomics method–based who severity scale for improving covid-19 patient assessment and disease characterization from ct scans
topic Original Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10662611/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37493348
http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/RLI.0000000000001005
work_keys_str_mv AT henaojohnandersongarcia amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT depotterarno amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT bowerdaniellev amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT bajerciusherkus amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT todorovaplamenateodosieva amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT saintjameshugo amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT demortangesaureliepahud amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT barrosomariacecilia amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT hejianchun amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT yangjunlin amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT youchenyu amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT staiblawrenceh amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT gangechristopher amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT leddarobertaeufrasia amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT caminiticaterina amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT silvamario amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT cortopassiisabeloliva amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT delacruzcharless amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT hautzwolf amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT bonelharaldm amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT sverzellatinicola amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT duncanjamess amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT reyesmauricio amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT poellingeralexander amulticlassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT henaojohnandersongarcia multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT depotterarno multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT bowerdaniellev multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT bajerciusherkus multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT todorovaplamenateodosieva multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT saintjameshugo multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT demortangesaureliepahud multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT barrosomariacecilia multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT hejianchun multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT yangjunlin multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT youchenyu multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT staiblawrenceh multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT gangechristopher multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT leddarobertaeufrasia multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT caminiticaterina multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT silvamario multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT cortopassiisabeloliva multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT delacruzcharless multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT hautzwolf multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT bonelharaldm multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT sverzellatinicola multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT duncanjamess multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT reyesmauricio multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans
AT poellingeralexander multiclassradiomicsmethodbasedwhoseverityscaleforimprovingcovid19patientassessmentanddiseasecharacterizationfromctscans