Cargando…
1441. Hand hygiene compliance in Brazil: from rich hospitals in the southwest to jungle hospitals - the big challenge
BACKGROUND: Our study seeks to address three important questions: (a) What is the current rate of HH adherence in Brazilian hospitals? (b) Which of the five moments of HH has the lowest adherence rate in Brazilian hospitals? (c) What is the HH compliance rate, as measured by direct observation, amon...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Oxford University Press
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10677874/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofad500.1278 |
_version_ | 1785150232766447616 |
---|---|
author | Couto, Braulio Silva, Estevão Urbano Souza, Guenael Freire Ferreira, Shirley Vrandecic, Erika Góis, Louranny Peixoto, Maria Luiza Santos, Thais Andrade, Virginia Vieira, Carolina Romaniello, Jeruza Covello, Luciana Couto, Thaís Vieira, Angela Fonseca, Anna Elisa Novato, Thiago Silva, Vanessa Maia, Amanda Macêdo, Jéssica Pereira, Matheus Lima, Thalita Zampa, Camila de Paula, Fabrizia Soares, Jacqueline Ferreira, Janete Carmos, Sara Fernandes, Rafael Pereira, Hoberdan Munefiça, Eder Hideki Mantovanelli, Lorraine Mota, Gabrielle Miranda, Kehone M Starling, Carlos E |
author_facet | Couto, Braulio Silva, Estevão Urbano Souza, Guenael Freire Ferreira, Shirley Vrandecic, Erika Góis, Louranny Peixoto, Maria Luiza Santos, Thais Andrade, Virginia Vieira, Carolina Romaniello, Jeruza Covello, Luciana Couto, Thaís Vieira, Angela Fonseca, Anna Elisa Novato, Thiago Silva, Vanessa Maia, Amanda Macêdo, Jéssica Pereira, Matheus Lima, Thalita Zampa, Camila de Paula, Fabrizia Soares, Jacqueline Ferreira, Janete Carmos, Sara Fernandes, Rafael Pereira, Hoberdan Munefiça, Eder Hideki Mantovanelli, Lorraine Mota, Gabrielle Miranda, Kehone M Starling, Carlos E |
author_sort | Couto, Braulio |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: Our study seeks to address three important questions: (a) What is the current rate of HH adherence in Brazilian hospitals? (b) Which of the five moments of HH has the lowest adherence rate in Brazilian hospitals? (c) What is the HH compliance rate, as measured by direct observation, among physicians, nurses, nursing technicians, and other healthcare professionals? And (d) is there a difference in HH adherence rates when comparing private hospitals to public/philanthropic hospitals? METHODS: We conducted covert, random daily observations to assess hand hygiene compliance in 8 Brazilian hospitals over three months (Jan-Mar/2023). Observations were conducted in both critical and non-critical care units, and data on compliance rates were collected in the SACIH 3i system (https://nsp.sacihweb.com). To calculate the compliance rate, we divided the number of observations in which hand hygiene was performed correctly when necessary by the total number of observed instances where hand hygiene was required. RESULTS: We conducted observations on 4,662 hand hygiene opportunities across 8 hospitals in three months. The global hand hygiene adherence rate varied between hospitals, ranging from 14% to 74% (Fig. 1), with a median adherence rate of 57% for Brazilian hospitals. The first moment, before touching a patient, had the lowest adherence rate of 47% (Fig. 2). Nursing technicians were the most frequently observed professional group (69%), with compliance rates of physicians = 51%, nurses = 65%, nursing technicians = 62%, and other healthcare professionals = 54% (p-value < 0.001). There was no difference in the overall hand hygiene rate between private and public/philanthropic hospitals, both with a compliance rate of 60%. However, significant differences were found between hospital types in Moment 1, Moment 2, and Moment 5 (Tab.1 ). [Figure: see text] [Figure: see text] [Figure: see text] CONCLUSION: Hand hygiene adherence in Brazilian hospitals remains low at 47%. The first moment, before touching the patient, has the lowest adherence rate, indicating that professionals prioritize their own safety over patients. Physicians have the lowest adherence rate, and private hospitals have better adherence than public/philanthropic hospitals. DISCLOSURES: All Authors: No reported disclosures |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-10677874 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | Oxford University Press |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-106778742023-11-27 1441. Hand hygiene compliance in Brazil: from rich hospitals in the southwest to jungle hospitals - the big challenge Couto, Braulio Silva, Estevão Urbano Souza, Guenael Freire Ferreira, Shirley Vrandecic, Erika Góis, Louranny Peixoto, Maria Luiza Santos, Thais Andrade, Virginia Vieira, Carolina Romaniello, Jeruza Covello, Luciana Couto, Thaís Vieira, Angela Fonseca, Anna Elisa Novato, Thiago Silva, Vanessa Maia, Amanda Macêdo, Jéssica Pereira, Matheus Lima, Thalita Zampa, Camila de Paula, Fabrizia Soares, Jacqueline Ferreira, Janete Carmos, Sara Fernandes, Rafael Pereira, Hoberdan Munefiça, Eder Hideki Mantovanelli, Lorraine Mota, Gabrielle Miranda, Kehone M Starling, Carlos E Open Forum Infect Dis Abstract BACKGROUND: Our study seeks to address three important questions: (a) What is the current rate of HH adherence in Brazilian hospitals? (b) Which of the five moments of HH has the lowest adherence rate in Brazilian hospitals? (c) What is the HH compliance rate, as measured by direct observation, among physicians, nurses, nursing technicians, and other healthcare professionals? And (d) is there a difference in HH adherence rates when comparing private hospitals to public/philanthropic hospitals? METHODS: We conducted covert, random daily observations to assess hand hygiene compliance in 8 Brazilian hospitals over three months (Jan-Mar/2023). Observations were conducted in both critical and non-critical care units, and data on compliance rates were collected in the SACIH 3i system (https://nsp.sacihweb.com). To calculate the compliance rate, we divided the number of observations in which hand hygiene was performed correctly when necessary by the total number of observed instances where hand hygiene was required. RESULTS: We conducted observations on 4,662 hand hygiene opportunities across 8 hospitals in three months. The global hand hygiene adherence rate varied between hospitals, ranging from 14% to 74% (Fig. 1), with a median adherence rate of 57% for Brazilian hospitals. The first moment, before touching a patient, had the lowest adherence rate of 47% (Fig. 2). Nursing technicians were the most frequently observed professional group (69%), with compliance rates of physicians = 51%, nurses = 65%, nursing technicians = 62%, and other healthcare professionals = 54% (p-value < 0.001). There was no difference in the overall hand hygiene rate between private and public/philanthropic hospitals, both with a compliance rate of 60%. However, significant differences were found between hospital types in Moment 1, Moment 2, and Moment 5 (Tab.1 ). [Figure: see text] [Figure: see text] [Figure: see text] CONCLUSION: Hand hygiene adherence in Brazilian hospitals remains low at 47%. The first moment, before touching the patient, has the lowest adherence rate, indicating that professionals prioritize their own safety over patients. Physicians have the lowest adherence rate, and private hospitals have better adherence than public/philanthropic hospitals. DISCLOSURES: All Authors: No reported disclosures Oxford University Press 2023-11-27 /pmc/articles/PMC10677874/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofad500.1278 Text en © The Author(s) 2023. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Infectious Diseases Society of America. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted reuse, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. |
spellingShingle | Abstract Couto, Braulio Silva, Estevão Urbano Souza, Guenael Freire Ferreira, Shirley Vrandecic, Erika Góis, Louranny Peixoto, Maria Luiza Santos, Thais Andrade, Virginia Vieira, Carolina Romaniello, Jeruza Covello, Luciana Couto, Thaís Vieira, Angela Fonseca, Anna Elisa Novato, Thiago Silva, Vanessa Maia, Amanda Macêdo, Jéssica Pereira, Matheus Lima, Thalita Zampa, Camila de Paula, Fabrizia Soares, Jacqueline Ferreira, Janete Carmos, Sara Fernandes, Rafael Pereira, Hoberdan Munefiça, Eder Hideki Mantovanelli, Lorraine Mota, Gabrielle Miranda, Kehone M Starling, Carlos E 1441. Hand hygiene compliance in Brazil: from rich hospitals in the southwest to jungle hospitals - the big challenge |
title | 1441. Hand hygiene compliance in Brazil: from rich hospitals in the southwest to jungle hospitals - the big challenge |
title_full | 1441. Hand hygiene compliance in Brazil: from rich hospitals in the southwest to jungle hospitals - the big challenge |
title_fullStr | 1441. Hand hygiene compliance in Brazil: from rich hospitals in the southwest to jungle hospitals - the big challenge |
title_full_unstemmed | 1441. Hand hygiene compliance in Brazil: from rich hospitals in the southwest to jungle hospitals - the big challenge |
title_short | 1441. Hand hygiene compliance in Brazil: from rich hospitals in the southwest to jungle hospitals - the big challenge |
title_sort | 1441. hand hygiene compliance in brazil: from rich hospitals in the southwest to jungle hospitals - the big challenge |
topic | Abstract |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10677874/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofad500.1278 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT coutobraulio 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT silvaestevaourbano 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT souzaguenaelfreire 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT ferreirashirley 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT vrandecicerika 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT goislouranny 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT peixotomarialuiza 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT santosthais 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT andradevirginia 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT vieiracarolina 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT romaniellojeruza 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT covelloluciana 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT coutothais 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT vieiraangela 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT fonsecaannaelisa 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT novatothiago 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT silvavanessa 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT maiaamanda 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT macedojessica 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT pereiramatheus 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT limathalita 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT zampacamila 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT depaulafabrizia 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT soaresjacqueline 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT ferreirajanete 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT carmossara 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT fernandesrafael 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT pereirahoberdan 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT muneficaederhideki 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT mantovanellilorraine 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT motagabrielle 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT mirandakehonem 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge AT starlingcarlose 1441handhygienecomplianceinbrazilfromrichhospitalsinthesouthwesttojunglehospitalsthebigchallenge |